Our library is an extension of the excellence which is provided in classroom. In-depth knowledge for every subject, making subjects interesting and easy to understand.

CA INTER VEDANTA LIBRARY

Welcome to the academic powerhouse of Sharma Sir's Vedanta Academy. 

Built with a single vision "Academic & Professional Excellence of CA Students"

We are not a single teacher but a cluster of knowledgeable teachers, working 24x7 to provide you with the most updated, in-depth, and easy-to-understand content for CA Intermediate.

The Vedanta Library Provides you:

1. EXPLANATION OF AS & IMPORTANT CONCEPTS
2. CA INTER ADVANCE ACCOUNTS - QUICK REVISION
3. CA INTER MCQs FOR 30 MARKS
4. LDR ADVANCE ACCOUNTS

Buyback 3 Tests: 25% Shares, 25% Reserves & 2:1 Debt Equity Ratio

Learn why company needs to pass all 3 buyback tests - 25% shares, 25% paid-up capital & free reserves, and 2:1 debt equity ratio. Take lowest limit.

Company has to pass ALL 3 tests. If it fails even 1 test, buyback is not allowed. So we always take the LOWEST of the 3.

Think of it like 3 locks on a door. You have to open all 3 to go inside. 

Why are there 3 different limits?
Because each limit protects a different person.

1) 25% of Total Paid-up Equity Shares Outstanding

What it means: 

Company cannot buyback more than 25% of its total equity shares in one financial year.

Example: 

If company has 10,00,000 equity shares outstanding, it can buyback maximum 2,50,000 shares.


Why this rule is there?
i) To prevent promoters from taking full control: 

If company buys back 80% shares, only promoters shares will remain. Public shareholders will be thrown out.
ii) To prevent secret delisting: 

Company cannot use buyback to remove itself from stock exchange.
iii) To keep company as a public company: 

After buyback, company should still have enough shareholders and shares in market for trading.

This limit is in NUMBER of shares.

2) 25% of Paid-up Capital + Free Reserves

What it means: 

The total MONEY spent on buyback cannot be more than 25% of Paid-up Capital + Free Reserves.

Example: 

Paid-up Capital =  05 Cr 

+ Free Reserves = 15 Cr 

= Total 20 Cr. X 25% = 5 Cr. 

So company cannot spend more than 5 Cr on buyback.


Why this rule is there?
i) To protect company's working capital: 

If company spends all its reserves on buyback, it will have no money left to run business, pay salary, buy raw material.
ii) To protect future growth: 

Reserves are for future expansion. Company cannot empty its piggy bank in one go.
iiii) To protect creditors: 

Reserves are the safety cushion for bankers. If reserves become zero, bankers will be at risk.

This limit is in AMOUNT / MONEY, not in number of shares.

Important: 

For this limit, you take Paid-up Capital of ALL types, Equity + Preference, plus Free Reserves like General Reserve, Retained Earnings, Securities Premium.

3. Post Buyback Debt Equity Ratio Should Not Exceed 2:1

What it means: 

AFTER buyback, Debt should not be more than 2 times of Equity.


Why this rule is there?
Buyback reduces Equity, but Debt remains same. So ratio goes up.

Example: 

Before buyback Debt = 20 Cr, 

Equity = 20 Cr. 

Ratio = 1:1. 

Company does buyback of 12 Cr. 

New Equity = 20 - 12 = 8 Cr. 

New Ratio = 20 / 8 = 2.5:1. 

This is NOT allowed. 

Maximum buyback allowed here is only 10 Cr, 

because then Equity becomes 10 Cr 

& Ratio becomes 20 / 10 = 2:1.

This limit is for SOLVENCY and to protect Creditors / Bankers.

Why Do We Take LOWER of All Three?

Because company has to satisfy all three laws at same time.

Full Practical Example:

Company has:
Total Equity Shares: 10,00,000 shares of Rs. 10 each
Paid-up Capital + Free Reserves = Rs. 20 Cr
Debt = Rs. 24 Cr, Equity (for ratio) = Rs. 20 Cr
Buyback Price = Rs. 100 per share

Calculate 3 Limits:
Limit 1 : Shares O/S Test

25% of 10,00,000 = 2,50,000 shares
Limit 2 : Resources Test: 

25% of 20 Cr = 5 Cr. At Rs. 100 price = 5,00,000 shares
Limit 3 : Debt Equity

Max buyback money allowed 

= Equity - Debt/2 

= 20 Cr - 12 Cr 

= 8 Cr. x 100/110 divide by 100 price 

= 7,27,273 shares

Lowest is 2,50,000 shares. So co. can buyback only 2,50,000 shares.

If it buys 5,00,000 shares, it will pass Limit 2 and 3 but will FAIL Limit 1. So it is illegal.


Lower of the three is taken because buyback must satisfy all three conditions of Sec 68 simultaneously - 25% shares limit protects shareholders, 25% reserves limit protects working capital, and 2:1 ratio protects creditors. If any one is breached, buyback is void.

Post Buyback Debt Equity Ratio 2:1 Explained | Vedanta Academy

Confused why 2:1 ratio is maintained after buyback? 

Why should Debt Equity Ratio be 2:1 after buyback? Understand Sec 68 Companies Act 2013 in simple words with example by Sharma Sir. For CA Inter & Final.

First of all understand What is Debt Equity Ratio?

Debt Equity Ratio = Total Debt / Total Equity


a) Debt means money company has taken from outsiders. Like bank loan, debentures, public deposits.
b) Equity means money of owners. Like share capital + free reserves + securities premium.


Example: 

If Debt is 200 and Equity is 100, ratio is 2:1. It means for every Rs. 1 of owners money, company has taken Rs. 2 from outsiders.

What Happens in Buyback?

In buyback, company uses its own money to buy its own shares and then cancels them.

So, Equity goes DOWN.

Example:
Before Buyback:
Equity = 100
Debt = 100
Ratio = 100 / 100 = 1:1 safe

Company does buyback of Rs. 50 from its reserves.

After Buyback:
Equity = 100 - 50 = 50
Debt = 100 (Debt remains same)
Ratio = 100 / 50 = 2:1 - Now at limit

You can see, buyback does not reduce debt, it only reduces equity. So ratio automatically goes UP.


Why Law Says After Buyback Ratio Should Not Be More Than 2:1

Companies Act, 2013, Section 68 says after buyback, debt should not be more than twice the equity. There are 4 big reasons:

1. To Protect Creditors and Bankers

This is the main reason.
Creditors gave loan trusting that company has enough owners money.
If company returns all owners money through buyback, then only creditors money is left in business. If business fails, creditors will lose everything.


Simple Analogy: 

Suppose you and your friend start a shop. You put 50,000 and bank gives 50,000 loan. If you take out your 50,000 through buyback, now shop is running only on bank money. If shop fails, bank will suffer full loss. Law does not allow this.

Law says, owners must keep at least Rs. 1 for every Rs. 2 of debt, so that creditors have some safety cushion.


Buyback reduces the company's Net Worth because company pays cash to shareholders and cancels shares. If a company does huge buyback by taking loans, its Equity becomes very small and Debt becomes very large. In case of liquidation, creditors will not get their money back. So law keeps a limit - Debt cannot be more than double of Equity.

2. To Prevent Company From Becoming Over Dependent On Debt

If a company keeps doing buyback, its equity will become very small and debt will become very big.
Such a company is called Over Leveraged.
Over leveraged company has to pay huge interest every year. Even a small loss can make it bankrupt.
Law wants company to remain financially healthy and stable after buyback. 2:1 is considered a healthy limit in India for most businesses.


Without this limit, promoters can do buyback by taking huge loans, take out all cash, and leave a hollow company with only debt. 2:1 limit stops the company from becoming over-leveraged and financially weak.

3. To Stop Promoters From Misusing Buyback

Without this rule, promoters could do this trick:

Take huge loan from bank

Use that loan money to buyback shares from public

Increase their own percentage holding

Leave the company full of debt


In the end, promoters become owners of company without putting their own money, and bank bears all risk.

2:1 rule stops this misuse. Company cannot do buyback if it will make it too debt heavy.


Buyback should be done from surplus profits, not by making the company bankrupt. 2:1 ensures that after buyback, the company still has enough own funds to continue business and repay debts.

4. To Maintain Solvency And Protect Public Interest

Buyback reduces cash and reserves of company.
If after buyback company has very low equity, it may not be able to pay its debts, salaries, taxes, suppliers on time.
Government wants to ensure that even after buyback, company is able to continue its business and pay its dues. That is why this solvency check is kept.


If company becomes too debt-heavy, interest burden increases, profits fall, and share price falls. This harms remaining shareholders. The limit ensures company remains healthy after buyback.


Buyback is Returning money to owners.
But you cannot return so much money that the company is left with only loans and no own capital. The law says - For every Rs. 1 of your own money left, you can have maximum Rs. 2 of borrowed money.

What If Ratio Goes Above 2:1?

Then buyback is NOT ALLOWED.


Company has only 2 options:
a) Reduce Buyback Amount: 

Do smaller buyback so ratio stays within 2:1
b) Reduce Debt First: 

Repay some bank loan or debentures first, then do buyback

This ratio is checked AFTER buyback, not before. Even if before buyback ratio is 1:1, if after buyback it becomes 2.5:1, buyback is not allowed.

Post buyback Debt Equity Ratio of 2:1 is maintained to protect creditors, to prevent excessive dependence on borrowed funds, to keep company solvent and to stop misuse of buyback by promoters.

FOR QUICK REVISION  SLIDE OVER

LDR ADVANCE ACCOUNTS

image

 20) AS1,2,4,5,7,9,11,12,16

 
image

 1) COMPANY FINAL ACCOUNTS

 
image

 2) BUYBACK OF SHARES

 
CASE SCENARIOS
ADVANCE ACCOUNTS 
image
 

                 1 

image
 

              2 & 3 

 

image
 

                   4

 

image
 

                   5

 

image
 

                  

 

EXPLANATION OF above

CASE SCENARIO

image
MCQ'S ON AS FOR QUICK REVISION
ATTEMPT AFTER REVISION OF CLASS NOTES & READING MATERIAL GIVEN BELOW
image
 
image
 
image
 
image
 
image
 
image
 
image
 
image
 
Goodwill, Patent, Copyright, Software - You cannot see them, you cannot touch them, but without them, no business can survive.

9) AS 26 Intangible Assets - The Invisible Wealth of Business | You Can't Touch It, But It Makes Crores!

1. WHAT IS AN INTANGIBLE ASSET?  

An Intangible Asset must satisfy ALL 4 conditions:

i) Identifiable: It can be separated from business and sold alone, OR its legal rights can be transferred to us.

Example: 

You can sell your Patent separately from your factory. That means it is identifiable.

ii) Non-Monetary: Its value is not fixed by contract. You will not receive a fixed amount of money for it.

Example: 

Cash is monetary because its value is fixed at Rs. 100 = Rs. 100. But Patent is non-monetary because its value depends on how much profit it will give.

iii) Without Physical Substance: It has no body. You cannot touch it.

iv) Held for use: It is held for use in production or supply of goods and services, or for giving on rent to others, or for administrative purpose. It is not held for sale like stock.


Simple Rule: 

If it is Identifiable + Non-Monetary + No Physical Body + Held for Use = Intangible Asset.

2. COMBINATION OF TANGIBLE + INTANGIBLE ASSET

Many times, an asset has BOTH tangible and intangible part together.

Examples:

1. Compact Disc (CD) containing songs / movie: CD is tangible (you can touch), Songs / Movie inside is intangible.

2. Computer with Operating System (Software): Computer hardware is tangible, Software inside is intangible.

3. Machinery from Government with right to use it: Machinery is tangible, Right to use it in a particular area for certain years is intangible.


What to do?

If Cost is Separable: 

Split the cost. Tangible part as per AS 10, Intangible part as per AS 26.
If Cost is NOT Separable: 

See which part is substantial (bigger/ more important) & apply that AS. 

a) If tangible part is substantial, apply AS 10. 

b) If intangible part is substantial, apply AS 26.

3. WHEN IS INTANGIBLE ASSET RECOGNIZED?

Intangible Asset is recorded in Balance Sheet only when BOTH conditions are satisfied:

1. Future economic benefits will flow: It is probable that it will give future profit.
2. Cost can be reliably measured: We can calculate its cost correctly.

If any one condition fails, we cannot show it as asset. We will charge it to Profit & Loss Account.

4. HOW IS INTANGIBLE ASSET MEASURED?

Intangible Asset is recognized at Cost.

Cost = Cost at which it is Acquired (Purchased) OR Cost at which it is Internally Created (Generated inside business)

In Balance Sheet it is shown as:

Cost - Accumulated Amortization - Accumulated Impairment Loss.


Very Important point: 

Revaluation Model is NOT allowed for Intangible Assets. Unlike AS 10 where you can revalue PPE, in AS 26 you cannot revalue Intangibles. Only Cost Model is allowed.

5. INTERNALLY GENERATED GOODWILL - NEVER AN ASSET

Internally Generated Goodwill cannot be recorded as an asset.

Why?
Because its cost cannot be identified and reliably measured. It is difficult to separate the cost of generating goodwill from day-to-day operations.

Example: 

You spend money to give best quality goods to customers. This may create Goodwill. But you cannot say how much of that cost created Goodwill and how much was just production cost. So, it is expensed out, not capitalized.

Rule: 

Only Purchased Goodwill (Goodwill bought from another business) can be shown as asset. Self-created Goodwill cannot.

6. INTERNALLY GENERATED INTANGIBLES (OTHER THAN GOODWILL) - RESEARCH vs DEVELOPMENT

An internally generated intangible goes through 2 Phases:

1. RESEARCH PHASE:

Original and planned investigation for gaining new scientific and technical knowledge and understanding. It is the search stage. You are still trying to find out if something is possible.

2. DEVELOPMENT PHASE:
Application of research to a plan for production. Expenses after research till commencement of large-scale production. 

Example: 

Developmental engineering, Market analysis, Customer survey. It is the implementation stage.

7. RESEARCH COST vs DEVELOPMENT COST - THE BIGGEST DIFFERENCE

Research Cost: CANNOT be Capitalized

It is debited to Profit & Loss Account because its viability is not yet known during research phase. You don't know if research will succeed or fail.


Development Cost: CAN be Capitalized.
It can be recorded as Intangible Asset because development is done only if research is proved viable. If research is successful, then only you go for development.


Example - Cancer Drug Case (Q1):
Company spent Rs. 5,00,000 in 2016-17 to develop drug for cancer. It will take 3 years to know if drug is effective, and 2 more years to make marketable product.
Treatment: 

Full Rs. 5,00,000 is Research Cost. Charge to P&L. Do not capitalize because viability not proved.
If later test proves adverse and project is terminated, then whatever was capitalized earlier must also be written off to P&L immediately.


Simple way to remember:
In case of Research Risk is involved so debited to P&L A/c.
Development means research Successful so it treated as Intangible Asset

8. EXPENDITURE INCURRED BUT NO ASSET CREATED

In some cases, you spend money to get future benefit, but no Intangible Asset or any other asset is created. Then such expense is debited to P&L.

Examples:

i) Preliminary Expenses: Expenditure on startup of an entity. Example: Company formation expenses.
ii) Expenditure on Training Activities: Training your staff.
iii) Expenditure on Initial Heavy Advertisement & Promotional Activities: First big advertisement for new product.

Why? Because no identifiable asset is created which you can control and sell separately.

Examples:
1) Company spent Rs. 45 Lakhs for publicity and research on new product, but product failed. Charge full Rs. 45 Lakhs to P&L because no future benefit will come.


2) Company with turnover Rs. 250 Cr spent Rs. 2 Cr on special initial advertisement for new product expecting Rs. 25 Cr turnover. Still, charge full Rs. 2 Cr to P&L because advertisement does not create an identifiable asset.

9. WHY HUMAN RESOURCE IS NOT AN ASSET? 

 Human Resource (Staff) is NOT recognized in Balance Sheet.

Reason: 

Company does NOT have control over staff. Staff can resign anytime. Company cannot restrict others from taking benefit of staff. Even if training increases efficiency and gives future benefit, control is missing. So, definition of asset fails.


Example: 

Company gave training to staff on GST, AS, Ind AS. This will increase efficiency. But staff can leave. So, training cost is NOT an intangible asset. Charge to P&L.

10. AMORTIZATION OF INTANGIBLE ASSET

Amortization means Depreciation of Intangible Asset.

Depreciable Amount = Cost - Residual Value
Residual Value of intangible is mostly ZERO, because after its life, it has no value.

This amount is allocated (written off) over its useful life, in such a way that it shows the consumption pattern of the intangible - how the asset is used up.


Useful Life Rule: 

In absence of any information, AS 26 suggests life of intangible is unlikely to exceed 10 years. Mostly we follow SLM (Straight Line Method) if consumption pattern cannot be determined.


Example:
PQR Ltd bought a Brand for Rs. 100 Lakhs and says brand is very popular, so no amortization needed.
Wrong. Every intangible has a finite life. Even famous brands must be amortized. Popularity does not mean infinite life. You must amortize over its useful life.

11. REVENUE BASED AMORTIZATION - NOT ALLOWED (With 1 Exception)

General Rule: 

Revenue Based Amortization is NOT appropriate.

Why? 

Revenue generated over years does NOT represent consumption pattern of intangible. Revenue is affected by many other factors like change in sales quantity, change in sales price due to inflation or competition. Moreover, sales includes Cost of Goods Sold, whereas consumption of intangible may be more close to Cost of Production.


Exception - When Revenue Based IS Allowed:

If an intangible like Patent or License is to be used only up to generating a particular level (amount) of total revenue over the years, then revenue-based amortization DOES represent consumption pattern. Then you can amortize in ratio of revenues (cash flows) generated.


Example - Swift Ltd (Q5):
Patent bought for Rs. 80 Lakhs for 5 years. Amortized at Rs. 10 Lakhs per year initially - this was wrong. After 2 years, it was found product life will continue for another 5 years from then. Net cash flows expected: 36L, 46L, 44L, 40L 34L etc. Here amortization must be recalculated based on remaining life and revised pattern. You cannot just continue old Rs. 10 Lakhs.

12. CHANGE IN AMORTIZATION PERIOD - Q6

Case: 

Intangible appearing in Balance Sheet at Rs. 15,00,000 on 1/4/2018. It was acquired for Rs. 25 Lakhs on 1/4/2016. Company was amortizing over 5 years on SLM. Now company determines amortization period as 8 years being best estimate from date asset was available for use.

Treatment: 

This is a Change in Estimate, not Change in Policy. So change is done Prospectively. Do not change past years. Take carrying amount on date of change as new cost and amortize over remaining revised life.


Illustration 1 - Know-how Case

ABC Ltd developed know-how by spending Rs. 20 Lakhs, used from 1/4/20X1, useful life 10 years, but company did NOT amortize till 31/3/20X8.
Treatment: 

Total amortization for 7 years = Rs. 14,00,000. Out of this, 6 years amortization Rs. 12,00,000 is Prior Period Item (Debit P&L as Prior Period), and current year amortization Rs. 2,00,000 is current year. Credit Know-how Account.

13. COMPUTER SOFTWARE - WHEN TO CAPITALIZE? -  Illustration 5

Costs incurred in creating computer software should be charged to Research & Development expense until technological feasibility / asset recognition criteria is established.

In Illustration:
Phase 1 - Detailed program design: Rs. 50,000
Phase 2 - Coding and Testing: Rs. 40,000
Total Rs. 90,000 = Expense to P&L (Because feasibility not yet proved)


After Phase 2, feasibility established. So:
Phase 3 & 4 - Other coding: Rs. 63,000 + Testing: Rs. 18,000 + Product masters: Rs. 19,500 = Rs. 1,00,500 = Capitalize as Software Cost.

Phase 6 - Packing cost: Rs. 16,500 = Expense to P&L (Packing is not part of software development)

14. OTHER IMPORTANT CASES

Q2 - Research Cost Charged Earlier, Benefit Comes Back:
If Research cost was charged to P&L few years back, and now benefit comes back, you cannot reverse it and capitalize it now. Once expensed, always expensed. AS 26 does not allow reinstatement.


Q8 - Copyright Becomes Useless Due to Law Change:
Company bought copyright for 10 years, amortizing over 10 years. After 7 years, new environmental law says only new technology safety equipment is valid. Old copyright is useless.
Treatment: 

Write off full balance amount in year of implementation of law. Do not wait for remaining 3 years.


Illustration 4 - Research Deferred:
AB Ltd incurred Rs. 20 Lakhs towards Research. Management says product cannot be manufactured for next 10 years, so defer write-off to future years.
Wrong. As per AS 26, Research expense must be charged to P&L in current year itself. You cannot defer research cost even if you think future benefit will come after 10 years.

15.  VEDANTA TRICKS FOR AS 26

Research = P&L, Development = Asset - This is 50% of AS 26 questions.

Internally Generated Goodwill = Never Asset

Revaluation NOT Allowed in AS 26, unlike AS 10.

Life Unlikely to Exceed 10 Years - If question silent, take 10 years.

Training, Advertisement, Preliminary Expenses = Always P&L

Human Resource = Not Asset - Because No Control.

Complete Notes in Simplified manner | By Sharma Sir - Vedanta Academy - For CA Inter | Base for CA Final | 

8) AS 10 (REVISED) - PROPERTY, PLANT & EQUIPMENT

AS 10 Property, Plant & Equipment - Complete Notes in Simple English | CA Inter

AS 10 tells us how to account for Property, Plant and Equipment - the fixed tangible assets of a business like Building, Machine, Furniture and Vehicle.

In simple words, AS 10 answers 4 questions:

1. What is PPE? 

Assets which are used for more than one year for production, supply, rent or office work, and are not held for sale.


2. What is the Cost? 

Cost includes Purchase Price plus all expenses needed to make the asset ready for use like Installation, Transport, Testing, and Dismantling Cost.


3. How to charge Depreciation? 

The cost of asset minus scrap value is charged as depreciation over its useful life in a systematic way.


4. What after Depreciation? 

After depreciation, asset can be shown at Cost Model (WDV) or at Revaluation Model (Fair Value). When asset is sold or held for sale, it is removed from books and profit or loss is booked.In short, 

AS 10 is the complete guide from Buying an Asset to Selling an Asset.


AS 10 = How to Buy, Use, Depreciate, Revalue and Sell your Fixed Assets - Correctly.

What problems do life coaches solve?

A life coach is just like mentors. They help you address your concerns and reach a viable solution for it. They can help you set up routines to ultimately meet your targets and do a lot more.

1. WHAT IS AN ASSET?

 An Asset is a resource which is:

1) Controlled by the business - The business has full right to use it.

2) Comes from a past event - It was bought or created in the past.

3) Future benefit will come - It will give profit or benefit in future.


Example: A machine bought by a company is an asset because the company controls it, it was bought in the past, and it will help to produce goods in future.

2. WHAT IS PPE?

PPE means Property, Plant and Equipment. These are Tangible Fixed Assets - you can touch and see them.PPE must satisfy all 3 conditions:

1) Held for use - Used for production of goods, supply of services, for giving on rent, or for office / administrative purpose.

2) Used for more than one year - It is not for one-time use. It will be used for more than one accounting period.

3) Not held for sale - It is not bought to sell again in normal business. It is bought to use.

Example: Building, Machine, Furniture, Vehicle, Computer are PPE. Stock of goods to sell is NOT PPE.

3. WHEN TO RECORD PPE IN BALANCE SHEET? - RECOGNITION

PPE is recorded in Balance Sheet only when both conditions are satisfied:

1) Future benefit will flow - It is probable that the asset will give future economic benefit.

2) Cost can be measured reliably - We can calculate its cost correctly.

If any one condition fails, we cannot show it as PPE. We will charge it to Profit & Loss A/c.

 4. WHERE AS 10 DOES NOT APPLY?

AS 10 does NOT apply to these 4 items:

1. Biological Assets: Living animals and agricultural produce like crops, fruits, sugarcane held for sale.
Exception: Bearer Plants ARE covered by AS 10. Bearer Plant means a plant used to produce agricultural produce, like a Mango Tree. Mango tree is PPE, but mangoes on it are not PPE.

2. Wasting Assets: Natural resources taken from earth like mineral ores, oil, natural gas. These are wasting because they finish after extraction.

3. Investment Property: Land and Building bought only for giving on rent or for capital appreciation (price increase), an  d not for use in business. This is covered by AS 13, not AS 10.

4. Small Spare Parts: Small spare parts are treated as Inventory (AS 2). When they are used, they are charged to Profit & Loss Account.
Exception: Major Spare Parts ARE treated as PPE. Example: Engine of an aircraft.

5. COST OF PPE - INITIAL COST

Cost means total amount spent to buy the asset and to make it ready for use. It has 3 parts:

A) Purchase Cost:

Purchase Price

Plus: Non-refundable taxes, Import Duty, Inspection Cost

Less: Trade Discount, Rebate


B) Cost to bring asset to its location and condition:

This includes:

Installation Charges

Site Preparation Cost

Transport Cost / Delivery Cost

Testing Cost

Professional Fees like Architect Fees

Trial Run Cost (Less: Sale of product made during trial run). If trial run fails, that cost is NOT included.

Wages / Salaries paid to workers who constructed or installed the asset

Borrowing Cost as per AS 16 (Interest on loan taken to buy the asset)


C) Cost of Dismantling and Site Restoration:

If after using the asset, you have to remove it and clean the site, then that future cost must be added today at its Present Value.


How to do accounting:

On purchase date: 

Debit Asset Account, Credit Provision for Dismantling Account with Present Value.

Every year: 

The Provision will increase because of interest. Debit Interest Expense Account, Credit Provision Account.

At the end of life: 

When you actually pay dismantling cost, Debit Provision Account, Credit Cash / Bank Account. By that time, Provision will be equal to full dismantling cost.

6. COSTS WHICH ARE NOT INCLUDED IN COST OF PPE

These 7 costs are NOT capitalized. They are charged to Profit & Loss Account:

1. Training Cost - 

Cost to train employees to work on new machine.

2. Administration and General Overheads - 

Office expenses.

3. Initial Operating Losses - 

Loss in starting period before asset starts working properly.

4. Cost of Relocating Employees - 

Cost to shift staff to new site.

5. Cost of Opening Ceremony - 

Cost of inauguration of new factory.

6. Incidental Income / Expenses - 

Small income / expense during construction, like income from using building under construction as car parking.

7. Interest on Deferred Credit - 

Interest paid to supplier because payment is made late (on long-term credit).


Simple Rule: If cost is not directly needed to make asset ready, do NOT add it to asset cost.

 7. COMPONENT ACCOUNTING

If one big asset has different parts and each part has a different useful life, then we must depreciate each part separately. This is called Component Accounting.

How to find cost of component?

1) Cost breakup given by Vendor / Supplier, OR

2) Cost breakup given by Technical Expert (Internal or External), OR

3) Current Replacement Cost of the component.


Examples:

Building: Structure, Lift, Heating / Cooling System, Water System, Electrical System - all have different lives.

Ship: Hull (Body), Keel (Bottom), Engines, Navigation System, Major Inspection.

Vehicle: Engine, Metal Body, Glass and Rubber Parts, Tyres.

 8. SUBSEQUENT COST - COST AFTER PURCHASE

After buying the asset, if you spend more money, when will you add it to asset cost?

Add to Asset Cost (Capitalize) when:

1) The spending will increase life of asset, OR increase production capacity, OR improve quality of production, OR decrease cost of production.

2) Major Part Replacement: Some parts need replacement after few years. 

Example: Tyres, Aircraft Engine. Old part is almost fully depreciated. So, remove old part from books (Debit Profit & Loss) and add new part cost to asset.

3) Major Inspection Cost: For some assets like Aircraft, major inspection is compulsory by law to continue using it, even if no part is replaced. This inspection cost is capitalized like a component.


Do NOT Add (Charge to P&L) when:

Regular servicing, repairs and maintenance to keep asset in working condition. 

Example: Annual overhaul to maintain efficiency.

 9. EXCHANGE OF ASSET

Sometimes we give one asset and take another asset in exchange.

What is Commercial Substance?
If future cash flows (future earnings / profits) will change because of exchange, then it has Commercial Substance. If no change, then it has No Commercial Substance.


Cost of New Asset Acquired:

1) If it has Commercial Substance: Cost = Fair Value of Asset Given Up OR Fair Value of Asset Acquired, whichever is more clearly known.

2) If it has NO Commercial Substance OR Fair Value cannot be measured: Cost = Carrying Amount (WDV) of Asset Given Up.


Insurance Replacement: 

If asset is destroyed in fire and insurance company gives a new asset (not cash), then it is treated as exchange. The new asset is recorded at its Fair Value, and old asset is removed, profit / loss is recorded.

10. DEPRECIATION

What is Depreciation?
Decrease in value of asset due to:

(a) Wear and Tear (use), and

(b) Effluxion of Time (passing of time)


Important Points:

1) Depreciable Amount = Cost - Scrap Value (Residual Value)

2) Depreciation must be charged on a systematic basis over useful life.

3) Depreciation must reflect the pattern of using the asset.

4) AS 10 does NOT fix any method. Company can choose any method.

5) Methods:

SLM - Straight Line Method: 

Depreciation per year = (Cost - Scrap Value) / Estimated Life. Same amount every year.

Reducing Balance Method (WDV): 

Rate = 1 - (Scrap Value / Cost) ^ (1/n). Depreciation is more in early years, less later.

Sum of Digits Method: 

Depreciation = Life Remaining including Current Year / Sum of Digits x (Cost - Scrap Value). Sum of Digits = n(n+1)/2.


6) Review Every Year: Every year, Scrap Value and Estimated Life must be reviewed. If there is a change, it is a Change in Estimate, not Change in Policy. So change is done Prospectively (for future years only, not past years). The Book Value on that date becomes the new Cost.

7) Depreciation Starts from the date asset is Ready to Use, not from date of actual use. Even if you don't use it, depreciation starts.

8) Impairment: Decrease in value other than depreciation is called Impairment (AS 28). Example: Asset damaged, market value falls suddenly.

 11. SUBSEQUENT RECOGNITION - VALUE AFTER DEPRECIATION

After depreciation, asset can be shown in Balance Sheet by 2 Models:

1. Cost Model:
Carrying Amount = Cost - Accumulated Depreciation - Accumulated Impairment Loss = WDV

2. Revaluation Model:
Carrying Amount = Fair Value on date of Revaluation.


How to find Fair Value?

(a) From Active Market (Market Price), OR

(b) By Approved Valuer (Outsider is preferred, but internal staff can also do), OR

(c) Depreciated Replacement Cost = Replacement Cost - Accumulated Depreciation on Replacement Cost.

Note: 

AS 10 does not tell how often revaluation should be done. Company can decide.


Investment Property (AS 13) is always shown as per Cost Model only.


Accumulated Depreciation on Revaluation:

On revaluation, there are 2 methods:

1) Elimination Method:

Remove full Accumulated Depreciation. Asset is shown at new Revalued amount.


2) Proportionate Restatement Method: 

Increase both Cost and Accumulated Depreciation in same proportion so that net amount becomes Revalued amount.

12. INCREASE / DECREASE DUE TO REVALUATION

A) First Time Revaluation:

If Increase: 

Credit Revaluation Reserve Account. This will increase future depreciation. That extra depreciation on increase is transferred from Revaluation Reserve to Retained Earnings.

If Decrease: 

Debit Profit & Loss Account. This will decrease future depreciation.


B) Subsequent Revaluation (Second time onwards):

If Increase: 

First, to the extent of earlier Decrease, Credit Profit & Loss Account. Remaining Increase, Credit Revaluation Reserve.

If Decrease: 

First, to the extent of earlier Increase remaining, Debit Revaluation Reserve Account. Remaining Decrease, Debit Profit & Loss Account.


Simple Rule to Remember:

First time: Increase = Reserve, Decrease = P&L.
Next time: Reverse the earlier treatment first, then new treatment.


One Class Rule: 

If you apply Revaluation Model to one asset, you must apply it to Entire Class of assets. 

Example: 

If you revalue one Office Building, you must revalue all Office Buildings. You cannot revalue Office Building and keep Factory Building on Cost Model if they are same class, but you can keep different classes on different models if classes are different.

13. ASSET HELD FOR SALE / DERECOGNITION

 1. When to Remove Asset:
Remove asset from books on Disposal (Sale) or when it is Held for Sale. When Held for Sale, show it separately in Balance Sheet at Carrying Amount (WDV) OR Net Selling Price, whichever is less. Gain or Loss is transferred to Profit & Loss Account. Depreciation STOPS once asset is Held for Sale, even if you still use it a little.


2. Date of Sale:
Date of sale is decided as per AS 9 - Revenue Recognition. Sale is complete when Risk and Rewards of ownership are transferred to buyer.
Example: If you sell plant and buyer will take delivery from your factory, sale is complete when plant leaves your factory. If you will deliver to buyer's factory, sale is complete when plant reaches buyer's factory.


3. Revaluation Reserve on Sale:
When asset is sold, its Revaluation Reserve is transferred to Retained Earnings (Profit & Loss Appropriation). It is a realized profit now.

14. VEDANTA ACADEMY'S EXAM TIPS FOR AS 10

1) Cost vs Expense: Always ask - "Will this cost make asset ready or increase its benefit?" If Yes = Capitalize, If No = P&L.


2) Depreciation Starts on Ready to Use date, not Actual Use date. ICAI loves this trick.


3) Component Accounting is compulsory if lives are different. Do not depreciate whole asset together.


4) Revaluation: Remember - First Increase to Reserve, First Decrease to P&L.


5) Dismantling Cost: Always take Present Value, not Future Value.

MAT ensures that every profitable company pays at least some tax to the government, even if it uses all deductions to bring its taxable income to zero.

7B) AS12 DEFERRED TAX in case of MAT

MAT — Minimum Alternate Tax: Why Profitable Companies Pay Tax Even When They Show Zero Tax?

D Ltd. is a big company. It shows Profit of Rs. 500 Crores in its Profit & Loss Account to shareholders.

But when it files Income Tax Return, it shows Taxable Income = Rs. 0 — because it took many deductions, exemptions, depreciation benefits.

Shareholders are shocked — inspite of such high profit how tax is zero ?   

Government said — This is unacceptable

And that is why MAT — Minimum Alternate Tax was introduced.

 1. What is MAT? 

MAT is the minimum tax that a company MUST pay, even if its taxable income under normal provisions is very low or zero.

It is levied under Section 115JB of Income Tax Act.

Rate: Currently 15% (plus surcharge & cess) on Book Profit.

  2. What is Book Profit?

Book Profit is NOT your taxable income.

It is your Profit as per Profit & Loss Account prepared under Companies Act, with some adjustments.


The full list of adjustments is given in Section 115JB Explanation — but for CA Inter, you need to remember the concept, not the full list.

3. How MAT Works 

D Ltd. for FY 2025-26:
Profit as per P&L (Book Profit) = Rs. 100 Lacs
Taxable Income as per Normal Provisions = Rs. 10 Lacs (after deductions)
Normal Tax @ 25% on 10 Lacs = Rs. 2,50,000
MAT @ 15% on 100 Lacs = Rs. 15,00,000

Which tax will D Ltd will pay?

Higher of the two — Rs. 15,00,000


So DLtd will pay Rs. 15 Lacs as MAT, not Rs. 2.5 Lacs.

Excess MAT paid = 15 Lacs - 2.5 Lacs = Rs. 12,50,000

This excess can be carried forward as MAT Credit for next 15 years.

4. What is MAT Credit?

MAT Credit is like a prepaid tax.

If in future years, your Normal Tax becomes more than MAT, you can use your MAT Credit to reduce your tax.


Example Year 2:
Normal Tax = Rs. 20 Lacs
MAT = Rs. 12 Lacs
Tax Payable = Rs. 20 Lacs (higher)
Less: MAT Credit available (12.5 Lacs) = Net Tax Payable = Rs. 7,50,000

MAT Credit is shown as an Asset in the Balance Sheet under AS 22 — but only if there is convincing evidence that you will pay normal tax in future.

This is the link between MAT and AS 22 

5. Who is Liable to Pay MAT?

a) All Companies (Indian & Foreign) — Except those who opt for 115BAA / 115BAB (New Tax Regime with lower rate)
b) If you opt for new regime (22% / 15%), MAT does not apply.

6. AS 22 & MAT  

As per AS 22, MAT Credit is a Deferred Tax Asset.

But it can be recognised only when:

There is convincing evidence that the company will pay normal income tax in future.

If company is in continuous losses, MAT Credit should NOT be recognised as asset.

7. Treatment of MAT from 1/4/26

1. MAT Rate = 14%
From 1st April 2026, MAT rate is 14% on Book Profit.


2. MAT is Final Tax
From Tax Year 2026-27, MAT paid will not create any new MAT Credit.


3. Old MAT Credit — 25% Rule
Credit available as on 31st March 2026 can be used, but only up to 25% of Tax Payable in any one year.

Balance can be carried forward up to 15 Years from the year in which the credit arose.


Example: 

Tax Payable is Rs. 88 Lakhs. Set-off allowed is Rs. 22 Lakhs (25% of 88). Balance Rs. 66 Lakhs if not used will lapse after 15 year from date of creation.


4. If New Regime is Opted
Old MAT Credit can be used at 25% per year for up to 15 years.


5. If New Regime is Not Opted
Old MAT Credit cannot be used. It remains blocked and will lapse after 15 years.

6. AS 22 Treatment
MAT Credit is a Deferred Tax Asset. Show it only to the extent it can be recovered under the 25% rule. Write off the balance to Profit & Loss.

 

7A) AS12 DEFERRED TAX in tax holiday period

Why Deferred Tax is NOT Created in Tax Holiday Period? 

Your company is in a Tax Holiday Period — like 80-IA, 80-IB, SEZ, or Startup 80-IAC. You are paying 0% tax for next 5 years.

Your accountant says — "We have timing differences, we should create Deferred Tax."

But AS 22 says — NO.


WHY ?

1. First, What is Deferred Tax?

Deferred Tax = Tax of Future.

If you pay less tax today but will pay more tomorrow, you create Deferred Tax Liability (DTL).
If you pay more tax today but will pay less tomorrow, you create Deferred Tax Asset (DTA).

It works only when there is a difference between Book Profit and Tax Profit AND tax will actually be paid in future.

2. What is Tax Holiday Period?

Tax Holiday :

Government says, You don't pay tax for 5 years, we are encouraging you to do business.

 Example:
D Ltd. sets up a unit in SEZ. It gets 100% tax exemption for 5 years.


Its Book Profit = Rs. 100 Lacs, Taxable Profit = Rs. 100 Lacs, but Tax Rate = 0%.

So Tax Payable = 0.

3. Why No Deferred Tax in Holiday Period?

Logic 1: No Tax = No Deferred Tax

Deferred tax is calculated as:
Timing Difference NP x Tax Rate

If Tax Rate during holiday = 0%, then
Timing Difference NP x 0% = 0

So DTA / DTL will always be Zero for timing differences that reverse during the holiday period.


Logic 2: AS 22 Principle — Substance over Form

AS 22 says — Deferred tax should be recognised only if the timing difference will reverse in a period when tax is payable.

If your timing difference originates today and reverses within the holiday period, it will never affect your tax. So why create an asset/liability for something that will never happen?


Example:
You claim extra depreciation of Rs. 20 Lacs in Tax books in Year 1.
In normal case, this will reverse in Year 3-4 and you will pay more tax then — So you create DTL today.
But if Year 1 to Year 5 is your tax holiday, and this depreciation reverses in Year 3 (still holiday), you will still pay 0 tax in Year 3. So there is no future tax effect. Hence, No DTL.

4. What About Timing Difference That Reverses AFTER Holiday?

If timing difference originates in holiday period but reverses AFTER holiday period, then deferred tax WILL BE CREATED.


Example:
Holiday Period: Year 1 to Year 5 (Tax 0%)
In Year 1, you create a timing difference of Rs. 50 Lacs (say, Provision for Gratuity — Book expense now, Tax allowed in Year 6)
Year 6 is after holiday, Tax Rate = 25%
Then DTA = 50 Lacs x 25% = Rs. 12,50,000 — WILL BE CREATED in Year 1 itself.

Because the tax benefit will actually be received in Year 6 when tax is payable.


Question: 

D Ltd. is in tax holiday under Section 80-IA for 5 years (2022-2027). In 2025, it has timing difference of Rs. 40 Lacs which will reverse in 2026 (during holiday) and Rs. 30 Lacs which will reverse in 2028 (after holiday). Tax Rate = 30%. Calculate DTA/DTL?
Answer:
For Rs. 40 Lacs (reverses in holiday) = Nil — No DTA/DTL
For Rs. 30 Lacs (reverses after holiday) = 30L x 30% = Rs. 9 Lacs — DTA/DTL to be created


Tax Holiday does not mean AS 22 does not apply. It means AS 22 applies with common sense.

If no tax will ever be paid on that difference, don't show a fake asset or liability. If tax will be paid later, show it now.

That's the whole philosophy of AS 22 — Prudence and True & Fair View.

 

7) AS12 DEFERRED TAX ASSETS

AS 22: Deferred Tax Assets in Case of Losses — Why Companies Can't Just Create DTA?

Your company made a huge loss this year. You paid no tax. But can you show a Deferred Tax Asset (DTA) in your balance sheet and claim that in future there will be savings in tax?

 1. First, Understand what is DTA

Deferred Tax Asset = Future tax Savings

It arises when:
a) You have paid tax now but expense will be allowed later (eg. Provision for Gratuity)
b) Or, you have a Carry Forward Loss which you can set off against future profit.

Example: 

Loss = Rs. 100 Lacs. Tax Rate = 30%.
If you are sure you will make profit next year, you can create DTA = Rs. 30 Lacs today.

2. The Problem With Losses

When there is a loss, the company wants to create a big DTA to show better net worth and reduce loss in books.


But AS 22 says:
Because DTA is based on future profit. If future profit is not sure, DTA is just a fake asset.


Two Situations:

Normal Case 

No History of Loss Create DTA only if there is Reasonable Certainty that future taxable income will be available.
Loss Case 

History of Recent Losses Create DTA only if there is Virtual Certainty supported by Convincing Evidence that future taxable income will be available.


Virtual Certainty means almost 100% sure. Like you have confirmed orders, long-term contracts, or a new product launch that will definitely give profit.

 3. Example    

Year 1: D Ltd made a loss of Rs. 50 Lacs due to a new factory setup. Tax rate 30%.

Can it create DTA of Rs. 15 Lacs?


Case A — If D Ltd has orders of Rs. 200 Lacs already confirmed for next year, and its business is profitable for last 5 years:

Yes, it can create DTA of Rs. 15 Lacs. Virtual certainty is proved.


Case B — If D Ltd has losses for last 3 years, no new orders, market is down:

No. It cannot create DTA. It should disclose in notes that it has unabsorbed loss but DTA not recognised due to lack of virtual certainty.


Exam Question:
Company has carry forward business loss of Rs. 70,00,000 and unabsorbed depreciation of Rs. 30,00,000. It has history of losses. What is DTA?

Answer

1. Total Timing Difference = 70L + 30L = 100L
2. Potential DTA = 100L x 25% (or given rate) = 25L
3. But, as per AS 22 Para 17, since company has history of recent losses, DTA can be recognised only to the extent of Virtual Certainty.
4. If no convincing evidence is given, DTA = Nil to be recognised.
5. Disclosure in Notes is mandatory.

If evidence is given — like company has a new export order — then recognise DTA up to that amount.


Common Mistakes Students Make
Mistake 1: 

The moment you see Loss you create DTA without checking Virtual Certainty.
Mistake 2: 

DTA is shown on the Asset side of the Balancesheet but reassement is not done. As per AS22 reassesement should be done on every Balancesheet date. If future profit is doubtful reduce DTA or viveversa.

 
Mistake 3: 

Unabsorbed depreciation is treated like business loss. Carryforward of Depreciation is unlimited but business loss can be carried forward for 8 years only. So, show both seperately.


Points to remember

AS 22 is not about saving tax. It is about showing a true picture. If your company is in loss, showing a fake DTA to look profitable is against the principle of Prudence. ICAI wants you to be conservative.


Whenever question mentions "history of losses" then DTA NOT RECOGNISED unless convincing evidence is available.

 

6) AS 16 BORROWING COST 

 What is AS 16? Borrowing Costs Meaning, Capitalisation & Examples

 AS 16 in 20 Minutes | Borrowing Cost Full Revision | CA Intermediate

1. What is AS-16?

 Borrowing Cost = Cost of borrowing money.

If you take a loan to buy / make an asset, the interest you pay on that loan — is it an expense of the year, or is it part of the cost of the asset?


If you had not taken the loan, you would not have got the asset. So interest is directly related to the asset. So it should become part of the asset's cost — but only in some cases.

2. What is Included in Borrowing Cost?

Not only interest. AS-16 says:
a) Interest on Term Loans, Debentures, Bonds
b) Amortisation of discount / premium on borrowings

c) Finance charges on finance lease
d) Exchange difference to the extent it is interest adjustment (foreign currency loan)


Anything you pay extra because you borrowed is Borrowing Cost.

3. Two Types of Assets 

A) Qualifying Asset:
An asset which takes Substantial Period of Time to get ready for use or sale.

Examples: Building under construction, Plant under construction, Power Plant, Bridge, Inventory that takes 1 year to make.

"Substantial period" = Generally 12 months or more (ICAI says — substantial is a matter of judgement, but 12 months is standard).

B) Non-Qualifying Asset:
Asset ready immediately. 

Example: You buy a car, you buy a machine ready to use, you buy raw material.

 4. MAIN RULE 

Rule 1 For Qualifying Asset: 

CAPITALISE Borrowing cost during construction period i.e Add to cost of asset.

Because asset is not yet ready to give you income. Interest is part of making it. So don't show as expense today, show as asset.


Rule 2 For Non-Qualifying Asset: 

EXPENSE Borrowing cost i.e Charge to P&L immediately.
Asset is already ready. Interest has no connection with making it. So it's a period cost.

 5. When to Start, Stop, and Suspend Capitalisation - The 3 Timelines

START — When all 3 happen together:
1. Expenditure on asset has started
2. Borrowing cost is being incurred
3. Activity to prepare asset is in progress

If even one is missing, don't start.


SUSPEND
If active development is stopped for a long period due to abnormal reasons— stop capitalising.
Example: Construction stopped for 6 months due to strike, legal dispute.
If work is stopped, interest is not helping to make asset, so expense it.

But If stoppage is normal — like monsoon delay for 2 months, or technical delay — DO NOT suspend. Continue capitalising.


STOP
When asset is substantially ready for use or sale.

Even if small work like painting is pending, stop. Even if asset is ready in parts, stop for that part.

Example: Building has 3 floors. Ground floor ready, 1st & 2nd under construction — Stop capitalising for ground floor portion.

 6. How to Calculate Amount to Capitalise?

Case A: Specific Borrowing
Loan taken ONLY for that asset.

Capitalisable Amount = Actual Interest minus Income from temporary investment of that loan

Example: 

You took Rs. 10 Lakh loan @10% for building. For 2 months you did not use Rs. 2 Lakh and kept in FD and earned Rs. 5,000 interest. Then capitalise = 1,00,000 - 5,000 = Rs. 95,000
If you earned income from unused loan, that reduces your cost.


Case B: General Borrowing
You have many loans, and you use them for asset.

Capitalisable Amount = Weighted Average Capitalisation Rate x Expenditure on Asset

Capitalisation Rate = Total Interest on General Borrowings / Total General Borrowings x 100

You cannot capitalise MORE than actual interest incurred in the year.

 7. Disclosure Requirements

1. Accounting Policy for borrowing costs
2. Amount of borrowing cost capitalised during the year

8. Important points to remember

1: Inventory is a Qualifying Asset ONLY if it takes substantial time to manufacture. Normal stock is NOT qualifying.

2: If you buy asset on deferred credit — the difference between cash price and deferred price is borrowing cost.

3: Foreign exchange difference — only the part which is interest saving is borrowing cost. Full exchange loss is NOT borrowing cost.

4: Interest on working capital loan — Never capitalise. Always expense.


Cost is not what you pay, cost is what you pay to make it ready.

5) NP, PRIOR PERIOD ITEMS, CHANGE IN POLICIES & ESTIMATES

1) WHAT AS 5 SAYS 

1. OBJECTIVE:
To prescribe classification and disclosure of:
a) Ordinary activities
b) Extraordinary items
c) Prior period items
d) Changes in accounting estimates
e) Changes in accounting policies

So that users can compare current vs previous year profit correctly.


2. KEY DEFINITIONS:

a) Ordinary Activities: Normal business activities. Eg: For ABC LTD - Sales income, salary, rent - These are ordinary.
b) Extraordinary Items: Events which are DISTINCT from ordinary activities and NOT expected to recur frequently. 

Eg: Loss due to earthquake, attachment of property, profit on sale of business.
Note: As per 2016 amendment, ICAI says extraordinary items should be disclosed separately but Ind AS does not allow extraordinary concept.
c) Prior Period Items: Income/Expense which arose in one year but error/omission discovered in later year. Eg: In FY 2024-25 you forgot to record Rs.10,000 salary - You record in FY 2025-26 as Prior Period Item.
d) Change in Accounting Estimate: Revision of estimate due to new info. Eg: You thought laptop life is 5 years, now you think 3 years. This is NOT prior period, it's a change in estimate.
e) Change in Accounting Policy: Change from one accepted method to another for better presentation. Eg: Changing depreciation from WDV to SLM.


3. MAIN PROVISIONS - What to show where?

A) Profit/Loss from Ordinary Activities:
i) Show separately - Profit before extraordinary.
ii) If any ordinary item is big and needs understanding, disclose separately.
Eg: Sale of fixed asset, Inventory write-down, Restructuring cost.


B) Extraordinary Items:
i) Show in P&L separately after ordinary profit.
ii)Nature + Amount must be disclosed.
Example in Notes: 

"Loss due to flood Rs.5,00,000 - Extraordinary Item"


C) Prior Period Items:
i) Show separately in current year's P&L after arriving at current profit.
ii) Nature + Amount disclosure must.
iii) NOT adjusted in previous year - Only disclosure.

Journal:
Prior Period Expense A/c Dr.
  To Cash A/c
And disclose: "Prior period salary Rs.10,000"


D) Change in Accounting Estimates:
i) Effect to be included in SAME year P&L (Current + Future).
ii) If material, disclose nature and amount.
Eg: Change in bad debts from 5% to 10% - Additional 5% hit to current P&L.


E) Change in Accounting Policy:
Change ONLY if:

1. Required by Statute (Law says), OR

2. Required by Accounting Standard, OR

3. Better presentation of financial statements.
Treatment:

a) If change has material effect - disclose change + impact.

b) If cannot estimate impact - disclose fact.

c) Change like depreciation method = Change in Accounting Estimate + Policy - Apply retrospectively.


4. DISCLOSURE REQUIREMENTS -  
1.  Prior period items - nature and amount
2.  Extraordinary items - nature and amount
3.  Effect of change in accounting estimate if material
4.  Change in accounting policy - reason and financial impact


"AS 5 deals with reporting of net profit/loss. Ordinary activities are main business activities. Any material ordinary item, extraordinary item and prior period item must be disclosed separately so that profit is comparable. Change in estimate is applied prospectively in current year, while change in policy is applied retrospectively and disclosed with impact. As per latest position, extraordinary concept is removed under Ind AS."


5. UPDATED POINTS - After Companies Act 2013 & Ind AS:
a) As per Schedule III of Companies Act 2013, Prior Period Items and Extraordinary Items must be shown separately on face of P&L.

b) Under Ind AS 8 (which replaces AS 5 for Ind AS companies), the term "Extraordinary Items" is NOT ALLOWED. Everything is ordinary. 

c) Prior period errors are corrected RETROSPECTIVELY by restating previous year, not in current year P&L. This is the BIG difference between AS 5 and Ind AS 8.

2) Legislative change in Income & Expense

Suppose: As per Supreme Court order a company has to pay, not only current years Bonus but even last Five Years Bonus, due to which expense increases.


What is happening here?

Government changed Bonus Act. Supreme Court says - "Companies, you have to pay more bonus. Not only for this year, but for last 5 years also."

So this year, company's bonus expense suddenly becomes very big - Rs. 2 lakhs for this year + Rs. 8 lakhs for last 5 years = Rs.10 lakhs total.


The confusion here is :
This Rs.8 lakhs is for last 5 years, so is it Prior Period Item?
Answer: NO. It is NOT Prior Period Item.


Because,
a) Prior Period Item means - 

You made a mistake or forgot to record last year. Eg: You forgot to record salary.
b) But here, you did NOT make mistake. Last year you paid correct bonus as per old law. Now law itself changed retrospectively. So extra bonus is due to Legislative Change.


As per AS 5:
Any expense/income due to retrospective change in law (like Supreme Court order, new Act, wage board revision) is NOT Prior Period.
It is treated as Exceptional Item  and must be disclosed separately.


How to show in P&L?
NP before Extraordinary & Exceptional Items    XXX

(+/-) Exceptional Item -

Additional Bonus due to retrospective amendment in Bonus Act (including Rs.8 lakhs for past years as per SC order)            (Rs.8,00,000)
Profit for the year                                        XXX
And in Notes to Accounts, you write full story.


"Retrospective legislative change = Current year expense, not Prior Period. Show as Exceptional Item separately."


Other examples of same logic:
a) New Gratuity Act - Pay extra gratuity for past years
b) New Wage Agreement - Pay arrears for past 3 years
c) Change in tax rate by Government retrospectively.


All these are Current Year Exceptional Items, NOT Prior Period.

3) BASIS OF CONCLUSIONS

This is NOT part of the Standard, but explains why ICAI made this Standard like this.

1. WHY AS 5 WAS NEEDED?
a) Before AS 5, companies were hiding losses.
b) They would show: "Profit Rs.10 lakh" but inside it included flood loss, last year's mistake, change of method - Nobody could compare this year vs last year.
c) So ICAI said: We must separate Normal profit from Abnormal / Past / Change to make P&L comparable and true.


2. WHY DISTINGUISH ORDINARY vs EXTRAORDINARY?
ICAI discussed: What is extraordinary?
Conclusion: Extraordinary must be BOTH - Distinct from ordinary + Not expected to recur frequently. If only one condition met, it is NOT extraordinary.
Example: Earthquake is distinct AND rare = Extraordinary.
Sale of machine is distinct but expected sometimes = NOT extraordinary, it's ordinary but separate disclosure if material.

3. WHY PRIOR PERIOD ITEMS SEPARATELY?
Basis: Financial statements are for THAT year. If you made mistake last year, you should not correct last year now. You show in current year but label it "Prior Period" so user knows "This expense is not of this year".
ICAI concluded: Retrospective restatement of last year will confuse users. Better to show separately in current year P&L.


4. WHY CHANGE IN ESTIMATE IS NOT PRIOR PERIOD OR POLICY CHANGE?
This was biggest debate.

ICAI concluded:

Estimate is a JUDGEMENT about future (like life of asset, bad debts %). As you get new info, estimate naturally changes. It's NOT an error.

Therefore, you cannot call it mistake (Prior Period) or rule change (Policy).

It must be PROSPECTIVE - Apply forward only. Because you cannot go back in time and change your guess.


5. WHY CHANGE IN ACCOUNTING POLICY RETROSPECTIVE DISCLOSURE?
ICAI: Policy is a RULE you choose (e.g., WDV vs SLM). If you change rule, it affects comparability of many years.
So change allowed ONLY if:
 a) Law requires, or
 b) AS requires, or
 c) Better presentation
And you must disclose why you changed + how much profit affected. Otherwise companies will change policy every year to show more profit.


6. WHY INVENTORY WRITE-DOWN, BAD DEBTS, etc. SEPARATE DISCLOSURE EVEN IF ORDINARY?
Basis: AS 5 Para 12. ICAI said: Some ordinary items are so BIG that if you don't show separately, user cannot understand business performance.
So even if it is ordinary, if it is material and unusual in size, show separately. Example you asked: Rs.2.5 lakh inventory write-down.

7. WHY EXTRAORDINARY CONCEPT REMOVED IN IND AS 8?

a) This is in Basis for Conclusion of Ind AS 8 (which replaced AS 5).
b) Globally IFRS says: Everything is from ordinary activities. Nothing is extraordinary because every business faces risk. Calling something extraordinary is subjective.
c) So Ind AS removed extraordinary line. Prior period errors are now corrected retrospectively by restating previous year, not showing in current year.


ICAI issued AS 5 to make profit comparable. It concluded that P&L should show ordinary profit separately from rare events (extraordinary), past mistakes (prior period), and changes in judgement (estimates) or rules (policies). Change in estimate is due to new info, so prospective. Change in policy affects comparability, so allowed only for better presentation with disclosure. Material ordinary items like inventory write-down to NRV also need separate disclosure to understand true performance. This logic later evolved into Ind AS 8 where extraordinary concept was removed to match IFRS.

4) Detailed Disclosure Rules under AS 5(vv Imp)

1. Extraordinary Items (Paragraph 8)

These are incomes or expenses that arise from events or transactions that are clearly distinct from the ordinary activities of the enterprise and, therefore, are not expected to recur frequently or regularly 

e.g., attachment of property of the enterprise, earthquake losses.
• In P/L Statement: 

You must disclose extraordinary items on the face of the P/L statement as a separate line item. They must be presented in a manner that shows their relative impact on the net profit or loss for the period.
• In Notes to Accounts: 

The nature and the specific breakup of each extraordinary item must be explicitly described.


2. Prior Period Items (Paragraph 15)

These are incomes or expenses which arise in the current period as a result of errors or omissions in the preparation of the financial statements of one or more prior periods 

e.g., mathematical mistakes, misinterpretation of facts.
• In P/L Statement: 

You must disclose prior period items separately on the face of the P/L Statement. They are typically presented after determining the profit/loss from ordinary activities so that the user can see their effect on the current year's performance.
• In Notes to Accounts: 

You must disclose the nature of the prior period error and its quantitative impact on the relevant accounts.

3. Ordinary Items of Exceptional Size, Type, or Incidence (Paragraph 12)
When items of income and expense within profit or loss from ordinary activities are of such size, nature, or incidence that their disclosure is relevant to explain the performance of the enterprise, they must be highlighted 

e.g., write-downs of inventories, disposals of items of fixed assets.
• In P/L Statement: 

They do not require a mandatory separate line item on the face of the P/L (they stay clubbed inside ordinary activities).
• In Notes to Accounts: 

The nature and amount of such items must be disclosed separately in the notes.

4. Changes in Accounting Policies (Paragraph 29)
• In P/L Statement: 

There is no specific line item on the face. The financial impact is integrated directly into the current period's standard line numbers.
• In Notes to Accounts: 

Any change in an accounting policy which has a material effect must be disclosed. You must state the nature of the change, the reasons for the change, and the quantified material impact (amount by which the current period items are affected). If the impact cannot be quantified, that fact must be explicitly disclosed.

5) Presentation of Changes in Accounting Estimates under AS 5
A change in an accounting estimate occurs when new information comes to light, more experience is gained, or subsequent developments take place (e.g., changing the estimated useful life of a machine or revising a provision for bad debts).
Under AS 5, changes in estimates are treated prospectively (affecting the current and future periods only) and are never treated as prior period or extraordinary items.

• In P/L Statement: 

No separate line item (Directly included within the relevant ordinary income/expense line)

• In Notes to Accounts: 

Required (Disclose nature and amount if material; if impact cannot be quantified, state that fact)


Additional notes on 

1) change in estimates

Detailed Disclosure Rules for Changes in Estimates (Paragraph 21-25)

• In P/L Statement: 

You do not create a separate line item called "Change in Accounting Estimate" on the face of the P/L Statement. Instead, the effect of the change is automatically merged and classified under the same ordinary line item that was used previously for that estimate. For example, a change in a provision for bad debts is blended directly into Other Expenses, and a change in the useful life of an asset is blended directly into Depreciation and Amortization Expense.
• In Notes to Accounts:
• If the change has a material effect in the current period, or is expected to have a material effect in subsequent periods, you must disclose its nature and quantified financial impact in the Notes to Accounts.
• If it is impracticable to quantify the exact financial amount of the change, you must explicitly disclose that fact in the notes.


2) ordinary items other than exceptional items

Under AS 5, ordinary items that are neither extraordinary nor exceptional are simply the routine, day-to-day operating revenues and expenses of your business (e.g., standard employee salaries, normal rent, utility bills, regular sales, and standard cost of goods sold).


Detailed Presentation Rules
1. On the Face of the P/L Statement
You do not list every single routine invoice on the face of the P/L. Instead, under Companies Act Schedule III formats, you aggregate these ordinary items into standardized, high-level line items:
• Revenue from Operations (Your core sales/service revenue)
• Other Income (Routine non-operating income like standard bank interest)
• Cost of Materials Consumed
• Employee Benefit Expenses (Regular salaries, wages, bonus)
• Finance Costs (Standard interest on bank loans)
• Depreciation and Amortization Expense (Normal annual wear and tear)
• Other Expenses (Normal administrative and selling overheads)


2. In the Notes to Accounts
The Notes to Accounts are mandatory for standard ordinary items to break down the large numbers shown on the face of the P/L.
• For example,

if the face of the P/L shows "Other Expenses = ₹5,000,000", the Notes to Accounts will feature a dedicated note providing the exact breakdown:
• Rent: ₹2,000,000
• Power & Fuel: ₹1,500,000
• Insurance: ₹500,000
• Repairs & Maintenance: ₹1,000,000

The Main Difference in a Nutshell
• Standard Ordinary Items: 

Disclosed as part of aggregated lines on the face of the P/L and fully itemised in the Notes to Accounts.
• Exceptional Ordinary Items:

 Kept inside those same aggregated lines on the face of the P/L, but explicitly singled out and highlighted in the Notes to Accounts because their size or frequency could distort a user's understanding of regular business performance.

5) case studies 

1) Explain whether the following constitute a change in accounting policy or not as per AS5.
a) Introduction of a formal retirement Gratuity scheme by a employer in place of adhoc ex – gratia payment to employees on retirement.
b) Management decided to pay pension to those employees who have retired after 5 years of service in the organisation such employees will get pension of Rs. 20000 p.m. earlier their was no such scheme of pension in organization.

Explanation:

As per AS 5 Para 32:

If transaction is SAME + policy is changed = Change in Policy.

If transaction is NEW / DIFFERS IN SUBSTANCE + new policy = NOT a change, it is first time adoption.

Analysis of both the above cases:

a) Introduction of formal Gratuity scheme in place of adhoc ex-gratia payment
Answer: NOT a change in accounting policy.
Reason:

Earlier: Adhoc ex-gratia = Owner's wish. No rule. You pay if you want, when you want. No liability in books. You accounted on cash basis - Pay Rs.10,000 and debit Expense.

Now: Formal Gratuity scheme = Legal obligation. As soon as employee works for 1 year, you have liability to pay after 5 years. You must make provision every year as per AS 15, with actuarial valuation.

Substance is different:
Adhoc = Discretionary, No obligation, No provision needed.
Formal = Statutory obligation under Payment of Gratuity Act, Provision must.

So transaction differs in substance. You are not changing a policy for same transaction, you are making a new policy for a new type of obligation that never existed before.

So as per AS 5, it is NOT a change. 

No need to disclose as change in policy under AS 5, but you must disclose the new policy adopted as per AS 1.

Adoption of new accounting policy for events which did not occur previously or were immaterial does not constitute change.


b) Management decided to pay pension Rs.20,000 p.m. to employees retired after 5 years service, earlier no scheme.

Answer: Also NOT a change in accounting policy.
Even more clear case.
a) Earlier there was NO pension scheme at all. Zero. So there was no accounting policy for pension.
b) Now you introduced a NEW scheme - Pension Rs.20,000 p.m.
c) This is a completely new transaction that never happened before. You are adopting AS 15 Employee Benefits for pension for first time.
It differs in substance from anything before - Before nothing, now monthly pension for life.
d) So this is also NOT a change in policy. It is introduction of new policy for first time.

How to do accounting:

As per AS 15, you will calculate past service cost for those who already completed 5 years and charge it to P&L in current year. It is not a prior period item, not a change in policy.


Final conclusion:

a) Adhoc to Formal Gratuity - Not a Change - New obligation, differs in substance from discretionary payment
b) No Pension to Rs.20000 Pension - Not a Change - New event, never occurred before, new policy adoption


Both (a) and (b) are examples of adoption of accounting policy for transactions that differ in substance from previously occurring transactions, hence as per Para 32 of AS 5, it will NOT be considered as change in accounting policy.


2) Company finds that stock sheet of 31/3/2017 did not include 2 pages containing inventory details worth Rs. 20,00,000 state how will you deal with this matter in A/c’s of A ltd for Y/E 31/3/2018 with reference to AS – 5.

Explanation:

a) On 31/3/2017 you counted stock, but 2 pages were lost. So your Closing Stock of 2016-17 was shown LESS by Rs.20,00,000.

b) Now in 31/3/2018 those 2 pages were found. So what to do now?

As per AS 5 - Treatment:
AS 5 says - Errors or omissions in financial statements of one or more prior periods are called Prior Period Items. If you find it in current year, you should not hide it by correcting opening stock silently.

You must:
1. Show it separately in current year P&L as Prior Period Item
2. Disclose its nature and amount so that user can understand that current year profit is affected due to last year's mistake.


Accounting Treatment for A Ltd for Year Ended 31/3/2018:

Step 1: What is the impact?
a) 2016-17 Closing Stock understated by 20L = Profit of 2016-17 understated by 20L
b) 2017-18 Opening Stock will also be understated by 20L (because last year's closing = this year's opening). If Opening is less, your COGS will be less, so Profit of 2017-18 will be OVERSTATED by 20L automatically if you now take correct closing of 2017-18.


Step 2: How to correct in books of 2017-18?
You will NOT reopen 2016-17 books.
In 2017-18 books you will do:
Stock A/c Dr. Rs.20,00,000
   To Prior Period Income A/c Rs.20,00,000
(Being correction of omission of stock in 2016-17)
Or

 you can route through Profit and Loss:
In P&L for year ended 31/3/2018:
Profit before prior period items:                       XXX
Add: Prior Period Item - Understatement of Closing Stock of 2016-17:                Rs.20,00,000
Profit after prior period item:                            XXX


Step 3: Disclosure in Notes to Accounts as per AS 5 Para 15:
"During the current year, it was discovered that closing stock for year ended 31.3.2017 was understated by Rs.20,00,000 due to omission of two pages of stock sheet. As a result, profit for year ended 31.3.2017 was understated by Rs.20,00,000. The same has been disclosed as prior period income in the year 2017-18. Profit of current year 2017-18 is overstated to that extent."


This is NOT a change in accounting policy and NOT a change in estimate. This is a Prior Period Error due to omission / mistake.

 4) AS 4 EVENTS AFTER B/S DATE

 1) AS4 CONTINGENCIES & EVENTS OCCURING AFTER THE B/S DATE

1) OBJECTIVE OF AS 4
AS 4 tells how to deal with 2 things in financial statements:
1.  Contingencies - Uncertain future events whose outcome will be known later
2.  Events After Balance Sheet Date - Events that happen between Balance Sheet Date (31st March) and Board Approval Date (say 30th May).


2. WHAT IS CONTINGENCY?
Contingency: A condition whose outcome will be confirmed only on happening / not happening of uncertain future events.

There are Two Types of contingencies:

A) Contingent Loss / Liability: Potential loss due to past event. 

Example:
a)Court case against company - if lost, pay Rs.10L
b) Guarantee given for loan of subsidiary
c) Product warranty claims expected
d) Bills Receivable discounted - if party defaults, you pay


B) Contingent Gain: Potential gain. 

Example:
a) Court case filed BY company - if won, will receive money
b) Claim for insurance, royalty expected.


3. ACCOUNTING TREATMENT OF CONTINGENCIES

Rule is based on Prudence - Provide for Loss, Ignore Gain.

A) Contingent Loss:

i) Loss is Probable & Amount can be estimated reasonably High - > 50% chance to lose *PROVIDE in P&L* - Create Provision. Charge to Profit & Loss.

ii) Loss is Possible but not probable, or amount cannot be estimated Medium - 5% to 50% *DISCLOSE as Contingent Liability* in Notes to Accounts - No entry in P&L

iii) Loss is Remote - Very less chance Low - < 5% - IGNORE - Do nothing. No provision, no disclosure


Example: 

ABC Ltd - Court case for Rs.20L. 

Lawyer says 80% chance to lose. Amount determinable.
Treatment: Provide Rs.20L as Provision.
Entry:

P&L            Dr.                        20L 

   To Provision for Court Case 20L

If lawyer says only 40% chance to lose: Disclose as Contingent Liability: "Court case pending for Rs.20L - outcome uncertain"


B) Contingent Gain:

RULE: 

If probable then Disclose in Directors Report which is not an Accounting record.


Never recognize Contingent Gain in books, even if probable. 


As per AS 4, Contingent Gains are NOT recognized at all. Only when actually realized, then recognize.


 Its based on Prudence - Don't anticipate profit.


Example: Company filed case for Rs.30L insurance claim. Expected to win. 

Treatment: Do NOT show Rs.30L as income. No entry. You may disclose in Directors Report if material, but not in accounts as asset.

EXCEPTION: 

If gain is virtually certain (not just probable, but almost 100% certain) and realized after BS date but before approval, then it can be recognized? 

This is very important discussion:

As per AS 4, still wait till realized. 

Under Ind AS 37, virtually certain gain is recognized as asset. As per Ind As 37 virtually certain means 90+% sure. 

But under AS 4, conservative approach. As per AS4 virtual certainity is 100% sure.


4. EVENTS OCCURRING AFTER BALANCE SHEET DATE

Period Covered: From Balance Sheet Date (31st March) to Date of Approval by Board (say 30th May). 

Events after approval date are NOT covered.


These are of Two Types:

A) ADJUSTING EVENTS: Those events which provide additional evidence about conditions EXISTING on Balance Sheet Date. You must ADJUST accounts.

List of Adjusting Events

1.  Insolvency of debtor - If customer becomes insolvent in April, and you had receivable on 31st March, it confirms that debt was doubtful on 31st March - Provide for Bad Debts.
2.  Settlement of court case - If court case existing on 31st March gets settled in April for different amount, adjust provision to actual settlement amount.
3.  Sale of goods at loss - Goods costing Rs.10L on 31st March sold in April at Rs.7L at loss due to market crash already existing on 31st March - Value inventory at Rs.7L on 31st March (NRV).
4.  Detection of fraud / error - Fraud existing on 31st March detected in April - Adjust.
5.  Determination of cost of asset purchased or sale proceeds of asset sold before year-end - Price finalized after year-end.


Example: Stock valued at Rs.5L on 31st March. In April, sold at Rs.4L. Market condition of fall existed on 31st March. Adjust - Value at Rs.4L on 31st March and book loss Rs.1L in current year.


B) NON-ADJUSTING EVENTS: Those events which arise due to conditions that OCCUR AFTER Balance Sheet Date. Do NOT adjust accounts. Only DISCLOSE if material.
List of Non-Adjusting Events

1.  Fire / Flood / Earthquake destroys factory in April - Condition did not exist on 31st March.
2.  Huge fall in market value of investments in April due to market crash in April.
3.  Announcement of new product / new business / new plant in April.
4.  Issue of shares, debentures after BS date.
5.  Dividend declared after BS date (See below special rule).
6.  Major business combination / merger after BS date.


Example: Factory burnt in fire on 15th April, loss Rs.50L. Do NOT adjust 31st March Balance Sheet. Disclose in Notes: "Fire loss Rs.50L after year-end - no adjustment made."


5. SPECIAL TOPIC - DIVIDEND

If Board proposes dividend after Balance Sheet Date (e.g., Board meeting on 15th May proposes dividend for year ended 31st March), is it adjusting or non-adjusting?
Answer: It is NON-ADJUSTING EVENT. Do NOT provide for dividend in 31st March Balance Sheet.
As per Revised AS 4 (2016), proposed dividend is NOT a liability on 31st March. It will be shown only after approval by shareholders in AGM. Only disclose in notes.


6. GOING CONCERN ISSUE
If after Balance Sheet Date, it is found that company is not a Going Concern (e.g., Bank refuses to renew loan in April, company decides to shut down), then accounts for year ended 31st March should NOT be made on going concern basis. Even if event happened after 31st March, it affects going concern assumption existing on 31st March.

You must change basis - Assets valued at realizable value, not historical cost.


 7. DISCLOSURE REQUIREMENTS OF AS 4
a) Nature of Contingency and Contingent Liability - amount, uncertainties
b) Estimated financial effect if determinable
c) Nature of Adjusting and Non-Adjusting Events after BS date
d) For Non-Adjusting Events, nature of event and financial effect if material
e) Proposed Dividend - amount per share, total amount (disclosed, not provided)


9. CASE STUDIES
Case 1: Debtor Rs.5L due on 31st March. He becomes insolvent on 10th April. Adjust or not?
Ans: Adjusting - Provide for doubtful debt Rs.5L on 31st March, because insolvency confirms condition existing on BS date.

Case 2: Stock market crash on 10th April, value of investment falls from Rs.20L to Rs.12L. Adjust?
Ans: Non-Adjusting - Market crash happened after BS date. No adjustment. Only disclose if material.

Case 3: Fire in godown on 5th April destroys stock Rs.10L which was there on 31st March. Adjust?
Ans: Non-Adjusting - Fire is new event. No adjustment. Disclose.

Case 4: Court case pending on 31st March for Rs.15L. On 20th April court orders to pay Rs.12L. Adjust?
Ans: Adjusting - Settlement provides evidence of liability existing on 31st March. Adjust provision to Rs.12L.

 2) Basis of conclusion

1. What is AS-4?

AS-4 deals with two things which happen after your financial year ends but before Board approves Balance Sheet.


a) Contingencies: A condition where result will be known only on happening or not happening of uncertain future event. Example - Court case pending on 31st March.

b) Events Occurring After Balance Sheet Date: Events that happen between 31st March and date of approval of accounts by Board. Example - Fire in factory on 10th April, debtor becomes insolvent on 15th April.


2. Basis for Conclusion - Why This Standard Was Made?

ICAI made this AS because of these reasons:
REASON 1: To Give True and Fair View
If you don't disclose a big court case loss or debtor insolvency after 31st March, your Balance Sheet will show wrong profit. Standard says - you must adjust or disclose to show true position.


REASON 2: Distinction Between Adjusting and Non-Adjusting Events
This is the heart of AS-4. ICAI concluded:

Adjusting Events: Those events which provide additional evidence about condition existing on Balance Sheet date. You MUST adjust your accounts.
Example 1: 

Debtor of Rs.5 Lakhs on 31st March becomes insolvent on 15th April. This proves that on 31st March itself his position was weak. So you must make provision for doubtful debt in current year.
Example 2: 

Court case pending on 31st March - Judgement received on 20th April against company. Adjust it.

Non-Adjusting Events: Those events which show condition arising AFTER Balance Sheet date. You should NOT adjust, but DISCLOSE in Directors Report if material.
Example 1: Fire destroyed factory on 10th April. On 31st March factory was OK. So don't adjust, but disclose.

Example 2: Huge fall in market value of investment after 31st March, Bonus declared after year end, Flood, Earthquake.


REASON 3: Why Contingent Loss and Contingent Gain Treated Differently? (Conservatism Principle)


This is the most important Basis for Conclusion:

Contingent LOSS: If it is probable that loss will occur, you must PROVIDE for it. If it is possible but not probable, only disclose as Contingent Liability. Why? Because of Prudence / Conservatism - Anticipate all losses, don't overstate profit.

Contingent GAIN: You should NEVER recognize contingent gain. Not even disclose as asset. Only disclose if required? No. As per AS-4 Revised, contingent gains should not be disclosed also. Why? Because recognizing gain before it actually happens will overstate profit and mislead users. Gain should be recognized only when actually realized.

This difference is based on the fundamental accounting principle of Conservatism.


REASON 4: Why Proposed Dividend is Not an Adjusting Event? (As per Revised AS-4 in 2017)

In old AS-4, proposed dividend was adjusting event. But after Revised AS-4 (as per AS-4 Revised + Ind AS 10), ICAI concluded:
Proposed Dividend is NOT a liability on 31st March. Because dividend becomes liability only when it is DECLARED by shareholders in AGM, not when Board proposes it. So as per Revised AS-4, you should NOT provide for proposed dividend in Balance Sheet. Only disclose it in Notes to Accounts.

This was a major change to align with International Standards.


Simple Formula to Remember:
a) Condition Existing on 31st March + New Evidence before Board Meeting = ADJUST
b) New Condition After 31st March = DON'T ADJUST, Only DISCLOSE
c) Loss = Provide if Probable
d) Gain = Never Provide


Summary

1.  To ensure financial statements show true and fair view by dealing with events after Balance Sheet date.
2.  To clearly distinguish between Adjusting events (evidence of condition existing on BS date - ADJUST) and Non-Adjusting events (condition arising after BS date - Only DISCLOSE).
3.  To apply Principle of Prudence - Provide for contingent losses if probable, but never recognize contingent gains to avoid overstating profit.
4.  To align with global practice - Proposed dividend is not a liability on BS date, only disclosed, not provided.

Master AS 2 Valuation of Inventories! 

3) AS 2 INVENTORY 

1) AS 2 VALUATION OF INVENTORY IN DETAIL

1. OBJECTIVE OF AS 2
To prescribe principles for valuation of inventories. Main principle: Inventory should be valued at Lower of Cost or Net Realizable Value (NRV). This is based on Prudence Concept - don't overstate profit.


2. SCOPE - Where AS 2 Applies & Does NOT Apply
AS 2 Applies to: All inventories except those specifically excluded.

AS 2 Does NOT Apply to:
a) Work in Progress under construction contracts (Covered by AS 7)
b) WIP of service providers where revenue recognized as per AS 9 (Now partly Ind AS 115)
c) Shares, Debentures held as Stock-in-Trade (Covered by AS 13)
d) Producers of agricultural products, forest products, mineral oils, natural gas, livestock - IF they measure at NRV as per industry practice. Example: ONGC valuing natural gas at NRV.
e) Machinery spares which are PPE as per AS 10.

3. DEFINITIONS
Inventories are assets:
a) Held for sale in ordinary course of business (Finished Goods)
b) In process of production for such sale (WIP)
c) In form of materials to be consumed in production or services (Raw Material, Stores)


Net Realizable Value (NRV): 

Estimated selling price less estimated cost to complete and estimated selling costs.
Formula: 

NRV = Expected Sale Price - Cost to Complete - Selling Expenses
Example: 

Medicine cost 500, can be sold as scrap @100, selling cost 10. NRV = 90.


4. MEASUREMENT - Cost of Inventories
Cost Includes 3 Parts: 

Cost of Purchase + Cost of Conversion + Other Costs to bring to present location & condition.


A) Cost of Purchase:
Purchase Price + Duties & Taxes (non-refundable) + Freight Inward + Handling
Less: Trade Discount, Rebate, GST Input Credit

B) Cost of Conversion:
Direct Labour + Direct Expenses + Fixed & Variable Production Overheads


Fixed OH: 

Depreciation, Factory Rent, Factory Manager Salary. Allocation based on NORMAL capacity.
Important: 

If production is low due to breakdown, excess unallocated OH goes to P&L. You cannot inflate inventory cost.

Example: 

Normal capacity 20,000 units, Fixed OH 4L (20/unit). Actual production 8,000 units. Inventory value = 8,000 x 20 = 1,60,000. Balance 2,40,000 is loss to P&L.

Variable OH: 

Power, Indirect material - Allocated based on ACTUAL production.

C) Other Costs: 

Design cost for specific customer order.


What is NOT Included in Cost 

Treatment: Exclude all the items mentioned below  from Inventory &  Charge to P&L in the year in which it is incurred.
1. Abnormal waste, abnormal idle cost
2. Storage costs after production (unless necessary like wine aging)
3. Admin overheads not related to production
4. Selling & Distribution costs
5. Interest / Borrowing Cost (unless inventory is Qualifying Asset taking 12+ months like wine, timber)


5. COST FORMULAS
Once cost is determined, which formula to use?
Allowed Formulas:
1. Specific Identification: For items which are not interchangeable and are specifically made for a project. Example: Custom-built ship.
2. FIFO: First In First Out - Assumes old stock sold first. In inflation, inventory value is higher.
3. Weighted Average: Weighted average of similar items.

NOT Allowed:

LIFO is BANNED as per Revised AS 2.

Rule: Same cost formula must be used for all inventories having similar nature and use.


6. NET REALIZABLE VALUE (NRV) - Lower of Cost or NRV

As per Prudence i.e. not to overstate profit - cost or NRV which ever is lower is considered.


When to write down below cost?
a) Goods damaged, obsolete, slow-moving
b) Selling price declined
c) Government ban (Medicine ban case)
d) Cost to complete increased


Raw Material Rule: 

Raw material is NOT written down below cost if finished goods in which it will be used is expected to be sold at or above cost. If finished goods will be sold below cost, then raw material is written down to NRV.

Example: 

Steel cost 100, to make car. Car sale price falling below cost, then steel to be valued at NRV.


 7. SPECIAL CASES IN AS 2
a) By-Product: 

If by-product is immaterial, measure at NRV and deduct from main product cost.
b) Joint Products: 

Allocate joint cost based on Relative Sales Value at split-off.
c) Service Provider WIP: 

Salary of staff working on project + attributable overheads. No profit, no selling cost, no admin cost included. (Para 19 of Ind AS 2) -- NOT FOR CA INTER STUDENTS.
d) Agricultural Produce: 

Harvested produce measured at NRV at harvest, that NRV becomes cost for AS 2 after that.
e) Cushion Gas vs Fuel Gas: 

Permanent cushion gas for pressure = PPE under AS 10. Daily fuel gas burnt for pressure = part of cost under AS 2.


8. DISCLOSURE REQUIREMENTS
In Financial Statements, disclose:
a) Accounting policy adopted for valuation including cost formula used (FIFO / Weighted Average)
b) Total carrying amount of inventories and classification - Raw Material, WIP, Finished Goods, Stores
c) Carrying amount at NRV / Fair Value less cost to sell
d) Amount of inventories recognized as expense (Cost of Goods Sold)


 5 GOLDEN RULES FOR EXAM
1.  LIFO never allowed.
2.  Fixed OH allocation = Normal Capacity only.
3.  Abnormal, Admin, Selling, Storage (after production), Interest (general) = Never include.
4.  NRV = Sale Price - Completion Cost - Selling Cost.
5.  Raw Material write-down only if FG will be sold below cost.


10. CONCLUSION
AS 2 ensures inventories are not overstated and profit is not inflated.

 2) SUMMARY IN SIMPLE WORDS

Valuing inventory correctly under AS 2 isn't just about legal compliance; it gives an accurate picture of your business's financial health. Overvaluing inventory artificially boosts your profits, while undervaluing it hides your true capability—both of which can get a business into serious trouble with auditors and tax authorities.


What Exactly Counts as "Inventory"?

Under AS 2, inventory isn't just the final product you sell. It is divided into three distinct categories:

Finished Goods: Ready-to-sell products waiting for a buyer.

Work-in-Progress (WIP): Half-finished goods currently on the factory floor.

Raw Materials & Supplies: Ingredients, components, and materials waiting to be used in production.


The Golden Rule of AS 2

If you remember only one thing about AS 2, make it this golden rule: 

Inventories must be valued at the LOWER of Cost or Net Realizable Value (NRV).


Why? 

Because of the accounting principle of Prudence (conservatism). You should never overestimate your asset values or show anticipated profits, but you must always record potential losses immediately.


what Cost and NRV actually mean.

1. Calculating the "Cost"

The cost of your inventory includes all expenses incurred to bring the items to their current location and condition. It consists of:

Purchase Price: The actual price paid to the supplier (minus any trade discounts or rebates).

Conversion Costs: Direct labor and a systematic allocation of fixed and variable factory overheads used to make the product.

Other Costs: Freight, delivery charges, and transit insurance.


What to Exclude: You cannot include abnormal wastage, administrative salaries, selling expenses, or storage costs (unless storage is necessary for the production process).


2. Finding the "Net Realizable Value" (NRV)

NRV is the estimated selling price of the item in the ordinary course of business, minus the estimated costs required to complete the product and make the sale.

Formula: 

NRV = Estimated Selling Price – Estimated Cost of Completion – Estimated Selling Costs


Example : 

Imagine a smartphone manufacturing company has 1,000 units of a specific model in stock at the end of the financial year.

Actual Cost to manufacture: ₹15,000 per phone.

Market Trend: A newer model was just released, so the estimated selling price has dropped to ₹14,000.

Selling Expense: The company has to pay a ₹500 commission per phone to its distributors.


Step 1: Calculate the NRV

NRV=14,000 (SP) -500 COMMISSION=13,500


Step 2: Apply the Golden Rule

Compare Cost (₹15,000) vs. NRV (₹13,500).

The lower value is ₹13,500.


The Result: The company must value its inventory at ₹13,500 per phone on the balance sheet, recording a write-down loss of ₹1,500 per phone immediately.


Formulas for Matching Costs (Cost Formulas)

If you sell identical items (like thousands of identical pens or bars of soap), you cannot track the exact cost of each specific item. AS 2 allows you to use two primary methods to estimate costs:

FIFO (First-In, First-Out): Assumes that the oldest stock is sold first. The remaining inventory is valued at the most recent purchase prices.

Weighted Average Cost: Calculates a new average cost every time a new batch of goods is purchased.

Note: The LIFO (Last-In, First-Out) method is strictly prohibited under AS 

3) BASIS OF CONCLUSION

At Vedanta Academy, we teach not just WHAT the standard says, but WHY it says so. Understanding the Basis of Conclusion is what makes a CA Topper.


1. Why AS-2 Needed a Revision?

Old AS-2 (1999) had many doubts. Students and professionals were confused about:
a) Should interest cost be included in inventory?
b) What about machinery spares?
c) How to value by-products?

ICAI revised AS-2 in 2016 to align with Ind AS-2 and to give Right Angle to the confusion.

2. Basis for Key Conclusions in AS-2

A) Inventories Should Be Valued at Lower of Cost or NRV - WHY?

Basis: This is based on Conservatism / Prudence Principle.

We should not anticipate profit, but provide for all losses.

If NRV < Cost, loss has occurred. Showing inventory at cost would overstate profit and assets.

Example: You bought 100 phones at Rs. 10,000. Market price falls to Rs. 8,000. If you show at 10,000, you are hiding a loss of Rs. 2 lakhs. AS-2 says - Show at Rs. 8,000.


B) Why Cost Includes Purchase, Conversion & Other Costs - But NOT Abnormal Costs?

Basis: Matching Principle. Only costs that bring inventory to present location and condition should be capitalized.


Abnormal waste, storage cost after production, selling cost - these do NOT bring inventory to saleable condition, they are period costs. Charge to P&L.


 Interest / Borrowing cost is NOT included unless inventory takes substantial time (qualifying asset). Why? To prevent manipulation of profit by capitalizing interest.


C) Why LIFO Method is BANNED?

Basis: Faithful Representation & Comparability.
LIFO assumes latest goods sold first - which is opposite to actual physical flow for most businesses. In inflation, LIFO shows lower profit and lower inventory, not reflecting true position. IFRS and Ind AS also ban LIFO. So AS-2 bans it to bring global uniformity.


Allowed methods: FIFO and Weighted Average only.

D) Why Fixed Production Overheads Based on NORMAL Capacity?

Basis: To avoid inflating inventory cost in case of low production.

Example: Normal capacity 10,000 units, Fixed OH Rs. 1,00,000 = Rs.10/unit. If you produce only 2,000 units due to strike, cost per unit becomes Rs. 50. If you include full Rs. 50 in inventory, you defer loss to next year. AS-2 says - Charge only Rs. 10 to inventory (10,000*10 = 20,000) and balance Rs. 80,000 to P&L immediately.


E) Why NRV is Estimated Selling Price Less Cost to Complete & Sell?

Basis: Realizable value, not market replacement value. Because we are going to SELL, not replace. The true value is what we will actually get in hand after incurring selling expenses.


F) Why Disclosure of Accounting Policy & Cost Formula is Mandatory?

Basis: Full Disclosure & Comparability. Investor must know whether you use FIFO or Weighted Average, otherwise two companies cannot be compared.


3. The Right Angle Conclusion for Students
AS-2 is not a rule to memorize. It is logic:
Cost = What you spent to make it saleable
NRV = What you will actually get
Valuation = Lower of both, because business should be honest, not optimistic.

4) LEGAL FIGHTS  

Accounting Standard 2 (AS 2) operates in the real corporate world, we can examine prominent legal and tax disputes in India. When the Companies (Accounting Standards) Rules, 2006 made AS 2 mandatory, it triggered fascinating legal battles between corporations and the Income Tax Department.


The three major real-world corporate case studies below illustrate the friction between operational changes, accounting rules, and tax liabilities:


Case 1: The SAP/ERP Upgrade Dispute

The Case: BSES Rajdhani Power Ltd. vs. Assistant Commissioner of Income Tax


The Scenario: The company upgraded its entire accounting infrastructure to a modern SAP ERP system. Historically, they had been using the FIFO (First-In, First-Out) method to track and value their inventory. However, the new SAP software default architecture processed and valued material stock on a Weighted Moving Average basis.


The Conflict: By transitioning from FIFO to the Moving Average method, the valuation of their closing inventory dropped significantly for that specific financial year. The Income Tax Department immediately flagged this, claiming the company changed its methodology solely to suppress profits and evade corporate tax.


The Verdict: The High Court ruled in favour of the company. The court noted that because both FIFO and Weighted Average are explicitly permitted under AS 2, upgrading to a scientific ERP system constitutes a legitimate, bona fide structural change. A company cannot be penalized for a tax drop resulting from adopting a more precise tracking technology permitted by the accounting standards.


Case 2: The Mandatory Shift to the "Prudence" Rule

The Case: Whirlpool India Ltd. vs. Income Tax Department


The Scenario: Before AS 2 became legally mandatory under the 2006 rules, Whirlpool (and several other manufacturing firms) historically valued their closing stock of raw materials, components, and work-in-progress (WIP) purely on a historical cost basis.


The Conflict: When AS 2 came into full mandatory effect, Whirlpool adjusted its accounting policy to comply with the standard's core mandate: valuing inventory at the lower of cost or Net Realisable Value (NRV). Because market conditions had dipped, writing the inventory down to its lower NRV resulted in a massive reduction in reported profit for the year. The Assessing Officer rejected the accounts, claiming there was "no operational bona fide need" to alter their long-standing accounting method.


The Verdict: The Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT) completely overruled the tax department. It established that since the Companies Act mandates compliance with Accounting Standards, matching the books to AS 2 is a statutory obligation, not a optional choice. The resulting lower valuation was a legal requirement of the financial concept of Prudence (Conservatism).


Case 3: The Tech Obsolescence Battle

The Case: CIT vs. IBM India Ltd.


The Scenario: Operating in the hyper-fast tech sector, IBM held an extensive inventory of computer spares, components, and technological stock. At the close of the financial year, the company realized that market progress had rendered a massive portion of these components obsolete.


The Conflict: Under Para 22 of AS 2, when inventory becomes damaged or wholly/partially obsolete, it must be written down to its Net Realisable Value. IBM took a 100% provision on the slow-moving, obsolete stock, drastically lowering their taxable income. The revenue authorities blocked this, arguing that the write-down was an unverified, "notional loss" because the physical items were still sitting in the warehouse and hadn't been sold or thrown away yet.


The Verdict: The High Court ruled in favor of IBM. The court established that if a company can provide clear, item-wise technical details proving inventory obsolescence, AS 2 mandates a write-down. The business does not need to physically destroy or sell the assets to recognize the drop in economic value.


Core Takeaway from the Courts

Indian case law consistently reinforces that AS 2 holds absolute supremacy over arbitrary tax assessments. If a company alters its inventory numbers due to a strict application of AS 2 (such as applying the lower of cost or NRV, or switching from FIFO to Weighted Average), the tax department cannot reject the books simply because the state collects less tax that year.

5) CASE STUDIES

CASE STUDY 1: Producer vs Trader - Does AS 2 Apply?
Situation: ONGC Ltd extracts Natural Gas from Bombay High. Cost of extraction Rs.20 per cubic meter. Market price Rs.45 per cubic meter. ONGC values its extracted gas at NRV Rs.45 as per oil industry practice.

XYZ Gas Trading Co. purchases natural gas from ONGC @ Rs.45 and holds it for sale to factories. How should both value ?

Answer:
ONGC (Producer): AS 2 NOT Applicable. 

As per AS 2 Para 3(e), AS 2 does not apply to inventories of producers of mineral oils, natural gas etc. where they are measured at NRV in accordance with well-established industry practice. So ONGC correctly values at Rs.45 (NRV). No Lower of Cost or NRV.

XYZ Gas Trading Co. (Trader): AS 2 IS Applicable. Because they are not producer, they are trader. They must value at Lower of Cost (Rs.45) or NRV. If market price falls to Rs.40, they must value at Rs.40 and book loss.

Producer = No AS 2, Trader = Yes AS 2


CASE STUDY 2: Joint Extraction - Crude Oil + Natural Gas
Situation: XYZ Oil & Gas Ltd drills one well. From one process it gets:
Crude Oil: 10,000 barrels

Natural Gas: 5,000 cubic meters
Joint cost before split-off Rs.80,00,000. Sale value at split-off: Oil Rs.6000/barrel, Gas Rs.400/cubic meter. How to allocate cost?

Answer:
This is Joint Product case. Even though AS 2 doesn't apply to producers measured at NRV, if they want to show cost, allocation is based on Relative Sales Value Method.

Total Sales Value:
Oil = 10,000 x 6,000 = Rs.6,00,00,000
Gas = 5,000 x 400 = Rs.20,00,000
Total = Rs.6,20,00,000

Cost Allocation:
Oil cost = 80,00,000 x (6cr / 6.2cr) = Rs.77,41,935
Gas cost = 80,00,000 x (20L / 6.2cr) = Rs.2,58,065
This is basis for profit calculation of each product.


CASE STUDY 3: Natural Gas as Fuel vs Inventory
Situation: Vedanta Steel Ltd extracts natural gas from its own gas field. 70% it uses as fuel in its own steel furnace, 30% it sells to outside market.

Question: AS 2 applicable?

Answer:
70% used internally = NOT inventory. It is consumed as fuel. Accounted as per AS 10 (if used for production) or charged as fuel cost.
30% held for sale = It is inventory, BUT as a producer of natural gas, if industry practice is to value at NRV, AS 2 will not apply. If they value at cost, then AS 2 applies.

Intention decides. Captive consumption = Not inventory. Held for sale = Inventory.


CASE STUDY 4: The Storage Cost Controversy - CNG Bottling
Situation: XYZ CNG Ltd purchases natural gas @ Rs.30/kg. It spends:
Compression & bottling cost Rs.5/kg (necessary to make saleable)
Storage cost after bottling in warehouse Rs.2/kg (rent for 2 months)
Selling commission Rs.1/kg
What is inventory cost per kg as per AS 2?
Answer:
As per AS 2 Para 6-8:
Purchase cost Rs.30 = INCLUDED
Compression Rs.5 = INCLUDED (cost to bring to saleable condition)
Storage after production Rs.2 = NOT INCLUDED - unless necessary for sale (like wine aging). CNG storage is not necessary, it's just holding. Charge to P&L.
Selling commission Rs.1 = NOT INCLUDED (selling cost)

So Inventory Cost = Rs.35/kg only.

This is most asked case study in CA Inter - Students add storage and selling cost by mistake.

Extracted Natural Gas at well-head = No AS 2 if valued at NRV (industry practice).

But once purchased for trading or bottled for sale - AS 2 = Lower of Cost or NRV.


CASE STUDY 5 : Advanced concept of AS 2 in Oil & Gas

AS 2: Natural Gas Required to Build Pressure for Extraction - Treatment?
In natural gas extraction, you need to inject some gas back into the well to maintain reservoir pressure. This is called Cushion Gas / Base Gas / Fuel Gas for Pressure. Is this gas Inventory?

Answer:

TWO Different Situations - Two Different Accounting:

SITUATION 1: Cushion Gas / Base Gas - Which Stays in Reservoir Permanently
What it is: To extract gas, you must keep a minimum quantity of gas permanently in the reservoir/well to build pressure. This gas is never extracted, it stays there for life of well. Like you need water in pump to start pump.

Example: ABC Gas Ltd. injects 10,000 cubic meters of gas @ Rs.400/m = Rs.40,00,000 as cushion gas. This gas will remain till well is abandoned.


Treatment as per AS 2 + AS 10:
NOT INVENTORY. It is NOT held for sale.


It is Fixed Asset as per AS 10 because:
It is required to get the well to function
It has long-term benefit (life of well 20 years)
It is not consumed


Accounting:
Capitalize Rs.40,00,000 as part of Oil & Gas Asset (PPE) under AS 10
Depreciate over life of well using Unit of Production Method

Do NOT value at Lower of Cost or NRV

Journal: Oil & Gas Asset - 

Cushion Gas A/c Dr. 40,00,000
   To Inventory / Bank 40,00,000

SITUATION 2: Fuel Gas / Recycled Gas - Used to Run Compressors to Build Pressure Daily

What it is: Every day you burn / use some extracted gas to run compressors that maintain pressure to extract more gas. This gas is consumed daily.

Example: Daily you extract 1000 m3. Out of it, you use 100 m3 as fuel to run compressor for pressure building. Cost of that 100 m3 is Rs.40,000.


Treatment as per AS 2:
This IS part of COST of Inventory (Production Overhead).

Because this gas is consumed to bring remaining 900 m3 to saleable condition. It is like fuel consumed in factory.


Accounting:
Cost of 900 m3 saleable gas = All extraction costs + Cost of 100 m3 fuel gas consumed.


Calculation:
Total extraction cost = Rs.5,00,000 + Fuel gas cost Rs.40,000 = Rs.5,40,000
Cost per m3 of saleable gas = 5,40,000 / 900 = Rs.600/m3

NOT shown as separate inventory. It is absorbed in cost of final gas.


Case Study 6: Market Crash & The "Raw Material Shield" (Cost vs. NRV)

Scenario:

Company: A smartphone manufacturer holds a massive inventory of microchips bought at ₹5,000 per chip.

The Market Shift: A breakthrough technology causes the replacement cost of these microchips to drop drastically to ₹3,500 per chip.

The Paradox: Even though microchip prices crashed, the final smartphones they are built into are still expected to be sold at a premium well above their total manufacturing cost.

The Question: Does the company need to write down the microchips to ₹3,500?

Answer :

The Application of AS 2:

AS 2 outlines a crucial caveat regarding raw materials: Raw materials are not written down below cost if the finished products in which they will be incorporated are expected to be sold at or above cost.

The Outcome: Because the final smartphones will remain profitable, the microchips are protected by this "shield." The company will continue to value the raw material microchips at their original cost of ₹5,000 per chip. No write-down is recorded.


Case Study 7: The Custom Luxury Watchmaker (Cost Formula Selection)

Scenario:

Company: A boutique brand produces 10 bespoke, highly customized luxury watches a year.

The Cost: Because each watch uses unique diamonds and materials, the production cost ranges from ₹50,000 to ₹60,000 per unit.

The Portfolio: Five watches are sold, leaving 5 distinct watches in closing stock.

The Question: Can the company pool these costs and use FIFO (First-In, First-Out) or Weighted Average methods to value the remaining stock?

Answer :
The Application of AS 2:

AS 2 strictly states that standard cost formulas like FIFO or Weighted Average cannot be used for items that are not ordinarily interchangeable, or for goods produced and segregated for specific projects.

The Outcome: The company must use the Specific Identification Method. Each individual watch must be tracked alongside its exact actual cost. This prevents the artificial smoothing of profits that generic cost formulas would cause in a high-value, low-volume business.


Case Study 7: Dealing with Waste (Normal vs. Abnormal Loss)

Scenario:

Company: A steel plant inputs raw iron ore to manufacture steel coils.

The Numbers: Normally, 2% of the iron ore evaporates or is lost as dross during the heat treatment process (Normal Loss). However, a sudden power grid failure causes a furnace leak, ruining an extra 5% of the batch (Abnormal Loss).

The Question: How are these two distinct losses factored into the inventory valuation?

Answer :

The Application of AS 2:

AS 2 requires companies to separate inherent process losses from accidental operational inefficiencies.

Normal Loss Treatment: 

The cost of the 2% normal loss is absorbed into the cost of the remaining good units. This directly inflates the per-unit cost of the sellable steel coils.

Abnormal Loss Treatment: 

The cost corresponding to the 5% furnace leak cannot be added to the inventory value. It must be immediately stripped out and treated as a direct loss in the P&L statement so that closing inventory doesn't carry the cost of inefficiency.


Case Study 8: The "Hyperinflationary Vineyard" (Financing Costs & Capitalization)

Scenario:

Company: A luxury winery produces a premium vintage wine that requires 3 years of barrel aging before it is bottled and sold.

The Funding: To fund the massive cash flow gap during this aging period, the winery takes out a ₹50,000,000 bank loan specifically to pay for the storage and climate control systems.

The Issue: The interest expense on this loan amounts to ₹5,000,000 per year.

The Question: Can the winery include this interest expense in the value of the wine inventory, or must it be treated as a direct finance cost in the P&L?

Answer :
The Application of AS 2:

Generally, AS 2 states that interest and borrowing costs are excluded from inventory valuation. However, there is a major exception: borrowing costs can be capitalized if they are directly attributable to a qualifying asset—an asset that necessarily takes a substantial period of time to get ready for its intended sale.

The Verdict: 

Because wine aging is a deliberate, necessary technological process taking 3 years, the wine is a qualifying asset.

The Treatment: 

The ₹5,000,000 annual interest is capitalized into the inventory cost of the wine barrels. However, if the wine was kept in the warehouse for an extra year simply because sales were slow (ordinary storage), that extra year's interest would be forced into the P&L as an expense.


Case Study 9 : The 12-Year Aging Whisky

The Scenario: 

A distillery spends ₹1,000 to distill raw spirit. To legally and chemically turn it into "Single Malt Whisky," the liquid must sit inside a warehouse barrel for 12 years to mature. This warehouse storage costs ₹150 per year.

The Rule under AS 2:

Ordinary storage costs must be thrown into the P&L as an expense. However, AS 2 makes a big exception: Storage costs are added to inventory if they are a mandatory part of the production process.

The Accounting Outcome:

Year 1 Cost: ₹1,000 (Initial distillation)

Years 2–12 Cost: ₹1,650 (₹150 × 11 years of storage)

Total Ending Inventory Value: ₹2,650 per litre


Because the whisky cannot exist without the aging time, AS 2 allows the company to capitalize the storage costs directly into the asset's value rather than writing it off as a loss.

ACCOUNTING STANDARDS 

2) AS 1 DISCLOSURE OF ACCOUNTING POLICIES

1) WHY AS 1 IS REQUIRED ?

1) Two companies with same profit but one shows stock at cost and other at market price? 

Who is correct?

Both can be correct, if they have disclosed their policies which are used in preperation & presentation of financial statements.

That is what AS-1 is all about.

_________________________________________________________________________________________________________

2) Two companies, Same sales, same building, same expenses.
Company A shows profit of Rs. 10 Cr, Company B shows Rs. 15 Cr.
Which company is better? You can't decide unless you know their accounting policies.
That is why AS-1 exists.

_________________________________________________________________________________________________________

3) Profit is not just a number. Profit depends on the policies used in preperation & presentation of financial statements.

AS-1 forces companies to disclose the accounting policies which are used in preperation & presentation of financial statements.

_________________________________________________________________________________________________________

2) What AS-1 Actually Says?

(I) Every financial statement is prepared using certain Rules (principles & policies). 

Accounting principles

means rules of accounts & these rules are compulsory. Sometimes there are more than 1 rule to give treatment for any transaction.

Accounting policies

Out of various available rules, the rules which we follow becomes our Accounting policies  


(II) AS-1 says, Don't hide the policies which are used in preperation & presentation of financial statements. 

(Financial statements includes Balance sheet, profit & loss statement, cash flow statement & notes to accounts).


Examples of various accounting policies:

1) How you value inventory (FIFO / Weighted Average)

2) Treatment of Goodwill.

3) Treatment of Borrowing cost

4) How you recognise revenue

5) Translation of foreign currency items.

6) Treament of Leases

7) How you value investments

8) How you treat fixed assets as per AS-10


If you don't disclose your rule, your financial statement is incomplete.


Examples of  vrious accounting policies with reasons:

1. Valuation of Inventories

Enterprises must choose a specific cost formula to value their closing inventory. A company cannot simply change this arbitrarily without disclosure.

Policy Option A: 

Valuing inventory using the First-In, First-Out (FIFO) method.

Policy Option B: 

Valuing inventory using the Weighted Average Cost method.


2. Treatment of Goodwill 

(As per AS 14 & AS 26)

An enterprise's policy must distinguish between goodwill acquired through corporate restructuring (amalgamations) and goodwill acquired via routine business asset acquisitions.

Amalgamation Goodwill (AS 14): 

Goodwill arising from an amalgamation in the nature of a purchase is recognized as an asset and amortised over a maximum period of 5 years, unless a longer period can be persuasively justified.

Acquisition/Subsidiary Goodwill (AS 26): 

Goodwill acquired through standard business acquisitions is recognized as an intangible asset and amortised over its estimated useful life (with a rebuttable presumption that it should not exceed 10 years).

Note: Internally generated goodwill is strictly not recognized as an asset.


3. Treatment of Borrowing Costs

When borrowing money to build or acquire assets, businesses choose how to treat the interest expenses incurred during the construction phase.

Policy Option A: 

Capitalizing interest expenses into the total cost of the qualifying asset until it is ready for use.

Policy Option B: 

Charging borrowing costs directly to the Profit & Loss statement as an immediate expense.


4. Revenue Recognition

Companies must define the exact point in time when sales or service revenues are officially recorded as earned.

Policy Option A: 

Recognizing revenue on a Percentage of Completion basis for long-term construction contracts.

Policy Option B: 

Recognizing revenue only when the Contract is Fully Completed or goods are physically delivered.


5. Translation of Foreign Currency Items

When a business deals with overseas clients or has foreign branches, it must choose how to convert foreign currency into its local currency.

Policy Option A: 

Converting transactions using the standard Average Exchange Rate of the month/year.

Policy Option B: 

Translating specific assets and liabilities using the precise Closing Rate on the Balance Sheet date.


6. Treatment of Leases (As per AS 19)

Lease transactions are structured and classified based on the level of risk and rewards transferred to the lessee.

Policy Option A: 

Classifying leases as Finance Leases when risks and rewards are fully transferred, thereby capitalizing the asset and recognizing a corresponding liability on the Balance Sheet.

Policy Option B: 

Classifying leases as Operating Leases when risks and rewards remain with the lessor, recognizing lease payments strictly as an operating expense in the Profit & Loss statement.


7. Accounting for Investments  

Enterprises must define how they measure and carry their short-term and long-term investments in the balance sheet.

Current Investments: 

Readily realizable assets intended to be held for less than one year, valued at cost or fair value, whichever is lower (evaluated on an individual or category-by-category basis).

Long-Term Investments: 

Intended to be held for more than one year, valued strictly at acquisition cost. However, a provision for a reduction in value is recognized if there is a decline that is other than temporary.


8. Accounting for Property, Plant and Equipment

An enterprise must define its policy for the measurement of tangible fixed assets after initial recognition at cost. The selected policy must be applied consistently to an entire class of PPE.

Policy Option A (Cost Model): 

Carrying an entire class of assets at its acquisition cost less accumulated depreciation and any accumulated impairment losses.

Policy Option B (Revaluation Model): 

Carrying a class of assets at a revalued amount (fair value at the date of revaluation) less subsequent accumulated depreciation and subsequent impairment losses.


(III) This disclosure should be at ONE PLACE - usually in Notes to Accounts.

The Big Update:
"Significant" vs. "Material" Disclosures
Previously, companies would routinely copy and paste page after page of generic accounting policies just because they were deemed "significant" to the business operations. This often used to hide material ploicies.

The MCA amended AS 1 to replace "significant" with "material accounting policy information."

You disclose 50 accounting policies in notes, copy-pasted from ICAI book. Out of them, only 5 policies are actually used by your company. Disclosing 45 immaterial policies to hide 5 material policies is wrong. Disclose only material policies.


IV) HOW TO SELECT AN ACCOUNTING POLICY:

According to Accounting Standard 1 (AS 1), there is one ultimate goal when choosing a policy:
The financial statements must provide a true and fair view of the enterprise's financial position and performance.
To achieve this, management must evaluate and select accounting policies based on three major considerations:

1. Prudence (Conservatism)
In accounting, uncertainty is inevitable. Future profits are never guaranteed, but future losses are often predictable. Prudence means exercising caution when making necessary estimates under conditions of uncertainty.
a) The Rule: Profits should not be anticipated or recorded until they are safely realized. However, all known, anticipated, or potential liabilities and losses must be provided for immediately.
b) The Goal: This ensures that assets or income are never overstated, and liabilities or expenses are never understated.


2. Substance Over Form
Transactions and financial events can sometimes look one way legally, but function completely different in reality. Substance over form dictates that accounting policies must prioritize economic reality over legal technicalities.

a) The Rule: Transactions must be recorded and presented in accordance with their financial substance and economic reality, rather than merely their legal form.
b) The Goal:  For instance, if a company enters into a long-term lease agreement that effectively transfers all risks and rewards of ownership to them, the asset is treated as an acquisition in economic substance, even if the legal ownership remains with the lessor.


3. Materiality
Financial statements can easily become cluttered if a company tries to break down every single transaction. Materiality acts as a filter to keep financial reports clean and relevant.

a) The Rule: Financial statements should disclose all material items—meaning any information that is important enough to influence the economic decisions of a person reading those statements.
b) The Goal: If an item or amount is tiny and irrelevant to decision-making, it does not require a dedicated, complex accounting policy disclosure. It can be lumped into a more general category.


v) Disclsoure of Fundamental Accounting Assumptions:

As per AS-1, there are 3 Fundamental Accounting Assumptions.

Treatment:

If these are followed, no need to disclose. If NOT followed, it MUST be disclosed in notes to accounts.

1. GOING CONCERN

Business will continue for long time, will not close soon.

Example: 

Machinery bought for ₹5 lakhs for 10 years. Shown as asset, not as loss, because it is assumed that business will continue.

If business is about to close, machinery cannot be shown  at cost - It is to be shown at scrap value and MUST be disclosed.


2. CONSISTENCY

Same accounting policy year after year. Don't change methods to show more profit.

Example: 

You used FIFO for stock valuation in Year 1. You must use FIFO in Year 2 also.
If you change from FIFO to WAM, you MUST disclose why you changed and what is effect on profit.


3. ACCRUAL

Record income when EARNED, expense when INCURRED, not when cash comes OR goes. Profit = Revenue - Expense (not cash in - cash out).

Example: 

Salary for March paid in April. You still show as expense of March only.
Sales made in March, money received in April - show as sales of March.


Prudence, Materiality, Substance over Form are NOT fundamental assumptions - they are Considerations in selecting policy.


VI) What Happens When You Change an Accounting Policy?

Consistency is king, which means you shouldn't change an accounting policy without a good reason. Under AS 1 (read alongside AS 5), a change is only allowed if:

1) It is required by statute or law

2) It is required by an accounting standard

3) It results in a more appropriate presentation of the financial statements.


What you must disclose during a change:

1) The nature and reason for the change

2) The monetary/financial impact of the change on the current period

3) If the financial impact cannot be figured out, you must state that it is not ascertainable


___________________________________________________________________________________________________________

What Does "More Appropriate Presentation" Mean?
This is the most confusing line of AS-5.


"More Appropriate Presentation" = More True & Fair, More Relevant, More Reliable, More Comparable.


It means: Old policy was allowed, but new policy shows the financial position and profit in a BETTER way. The new policy gives more useful information to investors, banks, shareholders.

You cannot change policy just to increase profit this year. You must prove - New policy is better than old policy for understanding the business.

ICAI will check 3 questions before allowing:

i) Does new policy give more relevant information?
ii) Does new policy give more reliable information?
iii) Will users of accounts understand business better with new policy?

If answer is YES - Change is allowed, but you must apply Retrospectively and disclose fully.


EXAMPLES 

 Example 1: Change in Method of Valuation of Inventory
Old Policy: Company was using FIFO Method for raw material valuation.
New Policy: Company changes to Weighted Average Method.
Reason for More Appropriate: Company is now dealing in bulk chemicals where prices fluctuate daily and lots are mixed. Weighted Average gives more realistic cost of production and stock value than FIFO. Profit is more fairly presented. Banks and auditors advised this is more appropriate for this industry.

Is this Allowed? YES.. This is change in Policy.


Example 2: Change in Treatment of Expenditure During Construction Period

Old Policy: Company was debiting all pre-operative expenses (like salaries of project team) directly to Profit & Loss Account.
New Policy: Company now capitalizes those expenses to the cost of the Plant (as per AS-10) and then charges depreciation.
Reason for More Appropriate: As per AS-10, expenses directly attributable to bringing asset to working condition should be part of asset cost. Old policy was understating asset value and overstating loss. New policy shows true cost of project and true profitability after plant starts.

Is this Allowed? YES.


 Example 3: Change in Classification of Investments

Old Policy: Company was valuing all investments (even long term) at Cost.
New Policy: Company is an Investment Company. It changes policy to value Current Investments at Lower of Cost or Fair Value and Long Term Investments at Cost with provision for permanent diminution.
Reason for More Appropriate: Cost alone was hiding huge losses in market value. Fair value method shows real financial health to shareholders. This is more appropriate as per AS-13.

Is this Allowed? YES.


Example 4: Change in Accounting for Government Grants Related to Fixed Assets
Old Policy: Company was crediting Government Grant received for machinery to Capital Reserve (Capital Approach).
New Policy: Company changes to deduct Grant from Cost of Machinery and show asset at net cost (Income Approach - Netting off), and charge depreciation on net cost.
Reason for More Appropriate: Both approaches are allowed in AS-12. But company realizes that netting off approach shows better matching of grant benefit over asset's life through lower depreciation. It presents P&L more appropriately. Auditors and Industry practice also follow netting method.

Is this Allowed? YES. Both methods are permitted, changing from one permitted method to another permitted method for better presentation is allowed.


Example 5: Correct Example 5: Change in Policy of Accounting for Royalty Income
Old Policy: Company was recognizing Royalty Income on Cash Basis (when received).
New Policy: Company changes to Accrual Basis (when earned).
Reason for More Appropriate: Accrual basis is fundamental accounting assumption as per AS-1. Cash basis was not showing true receivables and true profit of the year. Accrual basis gives more appropriate and true & fair view as per AS-9 Revenue Recognition.

Is this Allowed? YES.


What is NOT  More Appropriate Presentation & Will be Disallowed
1.  Changing policy only because this year profit will increase. 

Example - Changing inventory from Weighted Average to FIFO only because prices are rising and you want to show higher stock value. NOT ALLOWED.
2.  Changing policy every year. NOT ALLOWED.
3.  Change in depreciation method WDV to SLM - This is NOT a policy change at all. It is a Change in Estimate as per AS-5. So rule of "more appropriate presentation" does not apply here. It will be treated as prospective.

3) UNDERSTAND PRUDENCE IN DETAIL

Do not overstate profits & assets, Do not understate losses & liabilities. Anticipate losses, not profits.

 Examples

1. Provision for Doubtful Debts
Debtors ₹1,00,000 - you create 5% provision ₹5,000. You anticipate loss.

2. Stock Valued at Cost or Net Realizable Value, Whichever is LOWER
Cost ₹50,000 but market value ₹45,000 - Show at ₹45,000.

3. Provision for Discount on Debtors
You expect you will have to give discount to collect money - create provision.

4. Creating Provision for Warranty / Repairs
Sold 100 phones, you know 5 will come back - create provision in same year.

5. Providing Depreciation on Fixed Assets
Machine value will go down - anticipate loss, charge depreciation every year.

6. Provision for Loss on Investments
Invested ₹1 Lakh in shares, market value now ₹80,000 - Show loss ₹20,000 now.

7. Provision for Pending Lawsuits / Claims-Case going on -

 if you may lose, create provision.

8. Not Anticipating Profit on Goods Sold on Approval
Goods sent on approval not recorded as sales until approval received.

9. Provision for Fluctuation in Foreign Exchange
If foreign currency payment will result in loss due to rate change - provide.

10. Ignoring Contingent Assets, Showing Contingent Liabilities
If you may get ₹1 Lakh (contingent asset) - DON'T show. If you may have to pay ₹1 Lakh (contingent liability) - SHOW in notes.

4) UNDERSTAND MATERIALITY IN DETAIL

It's not about amount only. It's about "Will it affect the decision?"

If you hide something or show something wrong and your investor /bank will take a different decision, it is Material.

If it does NOT change anyone's decision, it is Immaterial.

Information is material if omitting or misstating it could influence decisions of primary users.


Materiality = Will it change the decision?
If hiding or misstating an item changes the decision of a bank, investor or reader, it is material. If not, it is immaterial. It is not only about amount, it is also about nature. Small illegal payment can be material, while Rs. 500 tea expense for a Rs. 100 cr company is immaterial.


Types of Materiality:

1. Quantitative (Number based): Big amount = Material
2. Qualitative (Nature based): Small amount but important nature = Material


Practical Examples:

1. Quantitative - Profit:
Your profit is Rs. 10 lakh. You forgot to book expense of Rs. 8 lakh. This is material because profit becomes Rs. 2 lakh. Bank will not give loan.


2. Qualitative - Illegal payment:
You paid Rs. 10,000 bribe. Amount is tiny, but nature is illegal. So material. Must be disclosed.


3. Director's personal expense:
You bought a Rs. 50,000 watch for your director from company money and booked as office expense. Amount is small, but it is a related party transaction, so material.


4. Change in Policy:
You changed stock valuation from FIFO to Weighted Average. Profit increased by Rs. 5 lakh. Even if 5 lakh is small for your company, change in policy is material.


5. Going Concern Doubtful:
You have a Rs. 2 crore loan and bank has sent notice to close your Mumbai shop. Even if you made profit this year, this information is material.


6. Small error becomes material in total:
One bill mistake of Rs. 1,000 is immaterial. But if you have 1000 such bills, total Rs. 10 lakh mistake is material.


7. Segment Information:
Your Mumbai branch made profit, but Japan branch made huge loss of Rs. 50 lakh. You show only combined profit. Hiding loss-making branch is material.


8. Post Balance Sheet Event:
After 31st March, your warehouse caught fire on 5th April and stock burnt. This event before signing accounts is material, even though it happened after year-end.


9. Immaterial Example:
Your company turnover is Rs. 100 crores. You paid Rs. 500 for tea & biscuits and forgot to book it. This is immaterial. No one will change decision for Rs. 500.


10. Auditors View on Accounting Policy:
Company disclosed 50 accounting policies in notes, copy-pasted from ICAI book. Out of them, only 5 policies are actually used by your company. So, as per Auditors opinion – Disclosing 45 immaterial policies to hide 5 material policies is wrong. Disclose only material policies.


If you have a doubt doubt whether item is material or not – Assume it is material and disclose it.

5) UNDERSTAND SUBSTANCE OVER FORM IN DETAIL

Form = What is written on paper legally
Substance = What is actually happening economically

Don't see the paper. See the reality.


Accounting should be done as per reality, not as per legal paper


Substance over Form = 

See reality, not just paper
Form is what is written legally. 

Substance is what is actually happening economically. 

Accounting must be done as per reality.

a) Rent agreement for full life of machine = Actually purchase

b) Selling building and taking it back on rent = Actually taking a loan

c) Sending goods to agent = Not a sale till agent sells

d) Redeemable preference shares = Actually a loan, not equity


Examples

1) Finance Lease
Form: You took a machine on rent for 5 years. Paper says "Rent Agreement".
Substance: Rent for 5 years = almost full price of machine, you will keep machine after 5 years, you repair it, you insure it. Reality is you have BOUGHT it.
Accounting: Show as your own asset + loan, not as rent expense.


2. Sale and Leaseback:
Form: You sold your Mumbai office building for Rs. 1 cr to bank and took it back on rent.
Substance: You didn't sell. You took a loan from bank and gave building as security. You still use building.
Accounting: Don't show profit on sale. Show it as loan.


3. Goods Sent on Consignment:
Form: You sent goods to Japan agent, made an invoice, legally it looks like sale.
Substance: Agent has not sold goods. If not sold, goods will come back. Risk is still yours.
Accounting: Not a sale. Still your stock.


4. Royalty on Sales:
Form: Your agreement says you sold goods to your sister company in Japan at Rs. 10 lakh.
Substance: Sister company will pay you only if it is able to sell to final customer. If it doesn't sell, you get zero.
Accounting: Don't book Rs. 10 lakh sale now. Book only when sister company sells.


5. Employee gets ESOP:
Form: You gave shares to employee for free. No legal contract of salary.
Substance: You gave shares because employee worked for you. It is salary, just paid in shares.
Accounting: Show as employee expense, not free gift.


6. Preference Shares that MUST be redeemed:
Form: Paper says "Preference Share Capital" – looks like equity.
Substance: You MUST pay back Rs. 1 cr after 5 years with 10% fixed dividend. It behaves like a loan.
Accounting: As per Ind AS, show as liability / debt, not equity.


7. Factoring of Debtors with Recourse:
Form: You sold your debtors to bank for Rs. 90 lakh. Paper says "Sale of debtors".
Substance: Agreement says if customer does not pay, you will pay bank. Risk is still yours.
Accounting: Don't remove debtors. Show Rs. 90 lakh as loan from bank.


8. Buying own shares through another company:
Form: Company A gives money to Company B, Company B buys shares of Company A. Legally Company B owns shares.
Substance: Company A is buying its own shares indirectly to increase its share price.
Accounting: Show as treasury shares, reduce equity.


9. Revenue – Consignment from Amazon:
Form: Amazon sends you Rs. 1000 order. Form says you sold for Rs. 1000.
Substance: Rs. 300 is Amazon commission, Rs. 100 is delivery, you get only Rs. 600. Real sale is Rs. 600 only.
Accounting: Show revenue at Rs. 600 (net), not Rs. 1000.


10. Free Gift with Product:
Form: You sell mobile for Rs. 20,000 and say free earphone worth Rs. 2,000 free.
Substance: You are not giving free. You are selling two products for Rs. 20,000. Customer is paying for both.
Accounting: Split Rs. 20,000 between mobile (Rs. 18,181) and earphone (Rs. 1,819) and recognise revenue separately


As per AS-1 / IAS-1, transactions should be accounted for as per their economic substance, not merely as per their legal form, to present true and fair view.


As per AS-1 / IAS-1, you must disclose material accounting policies and you must account for transactions as per their economic substance, not just legal form, to give a true and fair view.

6) Treatment of policy & estimates

Policy change is done retrospectively because policy is about how you measured the past. If you change how you measure, you must correct the past also to make it comparable.


Estimate change is done prospectively because estimate is about future. You can't correct past if future changed.


1. Accounting Policy = Your Rule Book

Example: You were using FIFO for stock. Now you change to Weighted Average.


FIFO and Weighted Average were both available on Day 1. If you think Weighted Average is a better rule today, it means FIFO was a wrong rule even last year.


So you must go back and change last year also. Otherwise:

Last Year Profit (with FIFO) = Rs. 10 lakh
This Year Profit (with Weighted Average) = Rs. 12 lakh.


You will think profit increased. But actually profit increased only because you changed the rule, not because business improved.

To make both years comparable, you must recalculate last year also with Weighted Average.

That is retrospective – As if new policy was always applied from the beginning.


2. Accounting Estimate = Your Guess about Future

Example: You thought your machine will run for 10 years. After 3 years, you realise it will run only for 5 years.


You can't say your past 3 years depreciation was wrong. Your guess was correct as per information available at that time.


Now future has changed, so you change depreciation only for future years.

That is prospective – No change in past, only change in current and future years.


As per AS-5 / IAS-8:

Change in Policy Retrospective: 

Restate opening retained earnings and comparative figures. Because you are changing the basis of measurement.

Change in Estimate: 

Prospective: No restatement of past. Only current year impact.


We apply policy change retrospectively to maintain comparability and consistency, so that users can compare financials on a like-to-like basis. We apply estimate change prospectively because estimates are based on new information about future, not correction of past error.


Summary:

Policy change = Retrospective because policy is your rule book. If you change the rule today, it means old rule was less appropriate even last year. So you must correct past year also and restate comparatives to make both years comparable.
Estimate change = Prospective because estimate is your guess about future. Your past guess was correct as per information then. Now future information changed, so you change only current and future years, no correction of past.

7) Change in method of depreciation is not change in policy

New Law (AS-10 Revised + AS-5 + IAS-8 + IAS-16): Change in depreciation method is now considered Change in Accounting Estimate & not change in accounting policy.


Why?


1. What is Policy and what is Estimate?

Policy = Which asset to depreciate? Cost model vs Revaluation model? That is your choice of rule.

Estimate = How that asset will be consumed? How much life? How much scrap value? In which pattern (SLM or WDV)? That is your guess about future.

Depreciation method is not a free choice. As per AS-10 / IAS-16, depreciation method should reflect the expected pattern of consumption of future economic benefits from the asset.


Example:

You bought a car. Initially you thought you will use it equally for 5 years = SLM.After 2 years, you realise you drive it very heavily in first 2 years and less later = WDV is better.


You changed method because your expectation of future usage pattern changed. That is a change in estimate of future, not change in rule book.


2. AS-10 Para 35 and IAS-8 Para 35 says:

Change in depreciation method, useful life and residual value are changes in accounting estimates. They are accounted for prospectively.


3. Practical Logic:

If you treat method change as policy change (retrospective), you will have to recalculate 10 years old depreciation and change all past profits. That is illogical because in past years you consumed asset as per old pattern.

Correct logic is – past was correct as per information then. Now new information came, so change only from current year.


Change in method of depreciation is a change in estimate because depreciation method reflects the pattern in which asset's future economic benefits are expected to be consumed. Change in such pattern due to new information is change in estimate as per AS-10 (Para 35), to be applied prospectively as per AS-5, not retrospectively as policy change.


______________________________________________________________________________________________

WHY Change in Stock Method = POLICY but Depreciation Method = ESTIMATE?


The Core Logic: RULE vs ALLOCATION


1. Stock Valuation Method (FIFO / Weighted Average) - WHY IT IS A POLICY?

What is stock?
Stock is an ASSET lying in your godown. At year end, you have to show its VALUE in Balance Sheet.


Question: What is the value of that asset?
There are different RULES allowed by ICAI to measure that asset.


Rule 1 - FIFO - First purchased goods sold first
Rule 2 - Weighted Average - Mix all purchases and take average.


Both rules are different MEASUREMENT PRINCIPLES. Both give different value of same physical stock.

Which rule you select - It decides HOW YOU MEASURE your asset. This is a fundamental accounting principle. This is a POLICY.

If you change from FIFO to Weighted Average, you are changing your PRINCIPLE OF MEASUREMENT of asset. So it is change in Policy.


Example:
100 kgs stock purchased at Rs.10 and 100 kgs at Rs.20.
Physical stock is same - 100 kgs.
But FIFO value = Rs.20 x 100 = Rs.2000
Weighted Average value = Rs.15 x 100 = Rs.1500

Same physical goods, different value because Rule changed. So it is Policy.


2. Depreciation Method (WDV / SLM) - WHY IT IS AN ESTIMATE?


Now come to Depreciation. This is where ICAI's logic is very deep.


What is depreciation?
Depreciation is NOT valuation of asset. Depreciation is ALLOCATION of cost of asset over its useful life.

Your machine cost is Rs.10 Lakhs. You know you will use it for 10 years. But HOW MUCH benefit you will get each year - is it equal every year or more in initial years?


This is a GUESS / JUDGEMENT.

SLM says - Benefit is equal every year - So equal depreciation.
WDV says - Benefit is more in initial years, less in later years - So more depreciation in initial years.

Both methods are trying to ESTIMATE the pattern of consumption of benefit from the asset. Both are just different ways of GUESSING the allocation.

So change from WDV to SLM means - Your GUESS about pattern of benefit changed. Earlier you thought benefit is more in initial years, now you think it is equal every year.


Any change in GUESS = Change in ESTIMATE.

That is why AS-5 specifically says:
> "Change in method of depreciation is a change in accounting estimate."


And ICAI gave 2 more strong reasons in Basis for Conclusion:

Reason A: Depreciation involves 3 Estimates Together
Depreciation needs 3 guesses:
1.  Useful Life - 10 years or 15 years?
2.  Residual Value - Rs.10,000 or Rs.50,000?
3.  Pattern of consumption - SLM or WDV?

All 3 are estimates. So method is also part of estimate family.


Reason B:  To Stop Retrospective Manipulation


If depreciation method was considered as Policy, then every time you change method you would have to apply Retrospectively - Recalculate depreciation from Day 1 of machine purchase.

That would create huge profit/loss adjustment in current year and allow companies to manipulate profit by changing method.


Example: Machine purchased 5 years ago. You change from WDV to SLM now and apply retrospectively - You will get Rs.3 Lakhs credit to P&L this year suddenly. That is not true profit.

So to avoid this manipulation, ICAI said - Treat it as Estimate and apply Prospectively - Only this year and future years. No recalculation of past.


 TO REMEMBER

Stock Method = How to MEASURE asset = RULE = POLICY = Retrospective

Depreciation Method = How to ALLOCATE cost based on GUESS of benefit pattern = ESTIMATE = Prospective


Inventory valuation methods (FIFO/Weighted Average) represent different principles for measurement of cost of inventory, hence selection of a method is an accounting policy as per AS-1 and AS-2. 


Whereas depreciation method (SLM/WDV) is a technique to allocate depreciable amount over useful life based on estimated pattern of consumption of economic benefits. It involves estimation of useful life, residual value and pattern of benefit. Therefore, as per AS-6, change in depreciation method is a change in accounting estimate, not policy, and is applied prospectively.

8) BASIS OF CONCLUSION OF AS 1

Basis for Conclusion is not a standard but WHY this standard was made? What logic, what problems, what discussions happened before finalising the rule.


Basis for Conclusion is NOT a part of the Accounting Standard. 

It is given for understanding and you don't need to follow it mandatorily. But it helps to understand the spirit of the standard.

It's like author's explanation - not the law, but explains the law.


BASIS FOR CONCLUSION OF AS-1

This is the OLDEST and MOTHER of all Standards. Without AS-1, no other AS can work.


1. WHY AS-1 Was Needed?  
Before AS-1 (1979), every company made accounts as they liked:
a) One company showed profit on cash basis, other on accrual basis
b) One company valued stock at FIFO, other at LIFO, but never told in accounts
c) Investors could not compare two companies because they didn't know WHICH policy was used.


ICAI Said in BC:
"Financial statements are full of estimates and judgements. Unless we tell the user WHAT policies we used, the numbers are meaningless. 

So we must make it compulsory to disclose Significant Accounting Policies."

AS-1 is like Ingredients List on a food packet. Food looks same, but ingredients are different. User must know.


2. Biggest Debate - What is Fundamental? 

BC discusses 3 Fundamental Accounting 


Assumptions. Why only 3?
ICAI considered many, but finalized only 3 as most basic. If you follow these, you don't need to disclose separately. If you DON'T follow, you MUST disclose why.
A) Going Concern:
BC Logic: We assume business will run forever. That is why we show assets at cost minus depreciation, not at sale price. If business is closing tomorrow, asset value is scrap value.

If you are NOT going concern (company closing), you must disclose and prepare accounts on liquidation basis.

B) Consistency:
BC Logic: If you change method every year - one year FIFO, next year Weighted Average - profit will change even if business is same. So you must use same policy year after year.

You can change only if:
1. Law requires, or
2. Accounting Standard requires, or  
3. Change gives more true and fair view.

C) Accrual:
BC Logic: Profit is not cash. Sale is recorded when done, not when money comes. Expense when incurred, not when paid. This gives true profit.

BC says: These 3 are so basic that if you are following, no need to say. But if you are NOT following (e.g., you are making accounts on cash basis), you MUST disclose with reason.


3. WHY Only Significant Policies?

Question raised: Should company disclose ALL policies, even small ones?

BC says: NO. Only SIGNIFICANT - means material.

If you have 100 policies, but 95 are small, disclosure will be 10 pages, user will be confused. So disclose only those which can affect decision.

Examples:
a) Depreciation method = Significant (Profit changes a lot)
b) Stationery accounting = Not significant


4. WHY All Policies at One Place?

BC Decision: All significant policies must be disclosed at ONE place as part of financial statements, normally as last notes.

Why? 

So that user does not search whole report. One place, all policies.


Also BC says: If any policy changes, you must disclose:
a) What changed?
b) Why changed?
c) What is effect on profit? (Quantum)
d) If you cannot find effect, say "Effect not ascertainable".


5. WHY Disclosure is Part of True and Fair?  
This is most powerful line in BC.
BC says: "Disclosure of accounting policies is part of giving true and fair view."

Even if your numbers are correct, but you did not disclose your policy, your accounts are NOT true and fair.


Example: Two companies, both show stock 10 lakhs. But one uses FIFO (during rising prices profit high), other uses Weighted Average. If they don't disclose, comparison is false. So non-disclosure itself is wrong.


6. Materiality Concept - Added in AS-1 

AS-1 BC first time explains Materiality:
"An item is material if its non-disclosure can affect decision of user."

BC clarifies: Materiality is not only amount, it can be nature also.

Example:
a) Rs. 10,000 bribe is small in amount, but nature is material - must disclose.
b) Rs.10 lakhs stock error in 100 crore company may be immaterial.

So AS-1 says use judgement for materiality.

 7. Difference from IAS 1 / IAS 8?
AS-1 (India Old) IAS 1 / IAS 8 (IFRS)
Talks about Fundamental Assumptions. No Fundamental Assumptions concept, directly says Accrual + Going Concern
Only disclosure IAS 1 also says about structure of financials
No Carve IN/OUT AS-1 is Indian origin, not converged
But core same: Disclosure at one place.

"Basis of Conclusion of AS-1 

States that to ensure proper understanding & comparability of financial statements, all significant accounting policies followed in preparation and presentation of financial statements must be disclosed at one place as part of financial statements & fundamental accounting assumptions of Going Concern, Consistency and Accrual are presumed to be followed, disclosure of which is required only if not followed, and any change in policy having material effect must be disclosed with reason and financial impact to give true and fair view."


Dissenting Views for AS-1

Dissent 1: Why only 3 Fundamental Assumptions?
Some members said: "There are more fundamentals - like Substance over Form, Materiality should also be Fundamental Assumption."
Majority rejected: Said those 3 are enough, others are considerations.

Dissent 2: Materiality definition too vague
Some members said: "Materiality should have % limit - like 5% of profit."
Majority said: No %, materiality is judgement, cannot fix %.

 ACCOUNTING STANDARDS DETAILED EXPLANATION

1) Application of Accounting standards in India

WHAT ARE ACCOUNTING STANDARDS

Accounting Standards are a standardized set of rules, principles, and guidelines issued by an authoritative accounting body (such as the ICAI in India or the IASB globally) that define how business transactions must be recorded, measured, presented, and disclosed in a company's financial statements.


An Accounting Standard is an official blueprint for financial reporting. It ensures that every company records its profits, assets, and debts using the exact same logic. This makes financial statements reliable, transparent, and easy to compare across different businesses.

APPLICATION OF ACCOUNTING STANDARDS IN INDIA

 In India, the application of Accounting Standards (AS) is split legally into two major buckets: Corporate Entities (governed by the Ministry of Corporate Affairs - MCA) and Non-Corporate Entities (governed by the Institute of Chartered Accountants of India - ICAI).


The Companies (Accounting Standards) Rules, 2006 (subsequently upgraded via the 2021 amendments) established the baseline framework for companies. Meanwhile, ICAI aligned non-corporate structures to a similar format. Both systems are heavily simplified compared to Ind AS (the Indian version of IFRS), which is reserved strictly for large public/listed companies.


1. Corporate Entities (Under Companies Act)

Companies are divided into Non-SMCs (Large Companies) and SMCs (Small and Medium-Sized Companies).


Non-SMC (Large Companies):
Publicly listed companies, banks, financial institutions, insurance companies, or any company with a turnover > ₹250 crore or borrowings > ₹50 crore. They must comply with all Ind As Rules 2015 (CA Final)  & Rules 2006 (CA inter)  is not applicable on these companies.

no exemptions available for Non SMC.


To qualify as an SMC, a company must satisfy all the following criteria in the preceding financial year:

1) Listing Status:  Neither listed nor in the process of listing equity/debt securities anywhere.

2) Sector Limits: Is not a bank, financial institution, or insurance company.

3) Turnover: Maximum ₹250 crore (excluding other income).

4) Borrowings: Maximum ₹50 crore (including public deposits).

5) Holding/Subsidiary: Is not a holding or subsidiary company of a Non-SMC


SMC (Small and Medium-Sized Companies): Unlisted companies falling below the ₹250 crore turnover and ₹50 crore borrowing thresholds.


Major Exemptions & Relaxations for SMCs:

Full Exemptions: 

SMCs are completely exempt from preparing a Cash Flow Statement (AS 3) and conducting Segment Reporting (AS 17).

Partial/Disclosure Relaxations:

a) Exempt from calculating or disclosing Earnings Per Share (AS 20).

b) Relaxed requirements for Employee Benefits (AS 15); they do not need complex actuarial valuations for short-term/small-scale obligations.

c) Exemptions on tedious disclosure clauses in AS 19 (Leases), 

d) AS 28 (Impairment of Assets), and 

e) AS 29 (Provisions & Contingencies).


2. Non-Corporate Entities (Sole Proprietorships, Partnerships, Trusts)

The Institute of Chartered Accountants of India (ICAI) governs non-corporate entities and breaks them down into Large Entities and Micro, Small, & Medium-Sized Entities (MSMEs).


Large Entities (Formerly Level I): 

Entities with an annual turnover exceeding ₹250 crore or outstanding borrowings exceeding ₹50 crore at any time during the preceding financial year. These entities must fully comply with all Accounting Standards (AS).


MSMEs (Formerly Levels II, III, and IV): 

Non-company entities below the Large Entity thresholds are now collectively categorized under Micro, Small, and Medium-Sized Entities (MSMEs). 

While grouped together, specific relaxations are still distributed based on sub-thresholds 

A Non-Company Entity is MSME if it satisfies ALL:

a) Equity/Debt securities not listed
b) Not a Bank, Financial Institution, Insurance Company
c) Turnover does NOT exceed Rs.250 Crores in immediately preceding year
d) Borrowings does NOT exceed Rs.50 Crores at any time during preceding year
e) Not a holding/subsidiary of Large entity
Micro: 

up to ₹10 cr turnover & borrowings up to 2 cr, 

Small: 

up to ₹50 cr turnover & borrowings up to 10 cr, 

Medium: 

up to ₹250 cr turnover & borrowings up to 50


Exemptions for Non-Corporate MSMEs:

a) AS 3 (Cash Flow Statement): Completely exempt.

b) AS 17 (Segment Reporting): Completely exempt.

c) AS 20 (Earnings Per Share): Completely exempt from calculating or disclosing basic or diluted EPS.

AS 24 (Discontinuing Operations): Completely exempt.


Optional Formats: 

Exempt from AS 21,23,27 (Consolidated Financial Statements) and AS 25 (Interim Financial Reporting) unless mandated by a specific local regulation.


Partial Relaxation (Same as SMC):
AS 15, AS 19, AS 28, AS 29 - Same relaxations as given above for SM


For very small non-corporate entities (specifically Level IV 

with turnover ≤ ₹50 crore and 

borrowings ≤ ₹10 crore), 

additional full exemptions apply to AS 15  and AS 22 (Deferred tax).


NEW UPDATE - COMPULSORY FINANCIAL STATEMENT FORMAT FROM FY 2025-26 & 2026-27

ICAI has issued Guidance Note on Financial Statements of Non-Corporate Entities & LLPs in Aug 2023, phased from:

Phase I: 

From 1st April 2025 - Applicable to all entities with turnover > Rs.5 Crores

Phase II: 

From 1st April 2026 - Applicable to ALL entities - Even smallest proprietorship with Rs.1 lakh turnover


Now even non-corporate entities must prepare Balance Sheet and P&L in ICAI prescribed format with current/non-current classification, Notes to Accounts, MSME disclosures etc.

This is compulsory for audit from this year.

Change in Status

If an entity avails of these exemptions and subsequently loses its SMC/MSME status, it must follow full accounting standard rules. If it shrinks back down, it must remain in that smaller tier for two consecutive accounting periods before it is legally permitted to claim these exemptions again.

ACCOUNTING STANDARDS 

EXAM QUESTIONS 

CAI EXAM PAPERS FOR QUICK REFERENCE FROM 2018 ONWARDS

 

 1) INTRODUCTION OF AS IN INDIA

 

2) AS 1 DISCLOSURE OF ACCOUNTING POLICIES

 

3) AS 2 INVENTORY VALUATION

 

4) AS 4 CONTINGENCIES & EVENTS AFTER B/S DATE

 

5) AS 5 NP,PRIOR PERIOD ITEMS, CHANGES IN ESTIMATES & POLICIES

 Q1: State True/False with reason: 

As per AS 5, extraordinary items should not be disclosed in P&L as part of net profit or loss for the period.

Ans:

FALSE. Para 9 of AS 5 - Extraordinary items SHOULD be disclosed in P&L as part of net profit/loss. Nature and amount to be separately disclosed so impact on current profit can be perceived. Example: Loss due to earthquake, attachment of property.


Q2: Attachment of property of enterprise is what type of item?
Ans: Extraordinary Item - because it is clearly distinct from ordinary activities and not expected to recur frequently. Disclosure required.


2019 May [4 Marks]
Q3: Distinguish between Change in Accounting Policy vs Change in Accounting Estimate.

Ans: 

Policy: Specific principles and methods adopted for preparation of FS. Change allowed only if required by law, by AS, or results in more appropriate presentation. Disclosed with impact. 

Example: Change from Cost model to Revaluation model for PPE.
Estimate: Estimation due to uncertainties inherent in business. Change due to new information. Not a change in policy. Applied prospectively. Example: Change in provision for obsolete inventory, change in useful life from 10 to 8 years - depreciation will INCREASE in current year.


2020 Nov / Jan 21 [5 Marks]
Q4: Opening stock was understated by Rs.5 lakhs due to wrong counting found in audit this year. Is it prior period item?

Ans: 

YES. As per AS 5 para 14-15, prior period items are income/expenses arising in current period as result of errors/omissions in preparation of FS of prior periods. Wrong counting is error. So it is prior period item and should be separately disclosed. Also adjust opening stock and profit b/f. Answer is Both (b) and (c).


2021 July / Dec 21 [5 Marks]
Q5: Company changed method of depreciation from WDV to SLM. Is it change in accounting policy?

Ans: 

NO. As per AS 6 and AS 5, change in method of depreciation is Change in Accounting ESTIMATE, not policy. Apply prospectively. Additional disclosure required if material.


2022 May - Practical
Q6: Company provided non-moving inventory on basis of technical evaluation unlike preceding years. Profit would have been lower by Rs.1 lakh if old method followed. How to disclose?

Ans: 

This is Change in Accounting Estimate. Para 21 of AS 5 - Nature and amount of change should be disclosed. If impracticable to quantify, fact to be disclosed. In notes: "Company has provided for non-moving inventories on basis of technical evaluation unlike preceding years. Had same method been followed as in previous year, profit for year and corresponding year end net assets would have been lower by Rs.1 lakh."

 2023 Nov [5 Marks - Exact ICAI Paper]
Q7: Identify as - Change in Policy / Estimate / Extraordinary / Prior Period / Ordinary:
(i) Non-provision for salary already due in earlier year.
(ii) Attachment of property.
(iii) Introduction of new pension scheme.
(iv) Change in reserve for obsolete inventory.
(v) Settlement of litigation case.
(vi) Actual bad debts exceeds provision.
(vii) Legislative changes having retrospective application.
(viii) Capitalisation of working capital loan interest.
(ix) Change from Cost Model to Revaluation Model for PPE.
(x) Govt grant in current year for expenses incurred in previous year.

Ans - 

This is most repeated in exam:
(i) Prior Period item
(ii) Extraordinary item
(iii) Ordinary activity (not policy change, new event)
(iv) Change in Accounting Estimate
(v) Ordinary activity but requires separate disclosure if material
(vi) Change in Estimate
(vii) Ordinary activity requiring separate disclosure
(viii) Error - if relates to previous year then prior period item
(ix) Change in Accounting Policy
(x) Ordinary activity requiring separate disclosure

2024 May - RTP [4 Marks]

Q8: Balance amount of maintenance provision written back due to crash of helicopters, no longer required. Is it prior period item?

Ans: 

NO. Para 16. Prior period items refer ONLY to errors or omissions in preparation of FS of prior periods. No error was made in past - provision was correctly made then. Change due to crash is current year event. Such write back is not ordinary feature, it shall be considered as extraordinary item or separate disclosure of ordinary item of exceptional size.


2024 Sep / Jan 25 - MTP [5 Marks]
Q9: What are valid reasons for change in accounting policy as per AS 5?

Ans: 

Only 3 reasons allowed - Para 31-32:
1. Required by statute
2. Required for compliance with Accounting Standard
3. Change would result in more appropriate presentation of FS.
Disclosure: Nature of change, amount of change if material, reason.


2025 May - Latest Trend [5 Marks]
Q10: Company changed inventory valuation from FIFO to Weighted Average and says it is more appropriate. Profit impact Rs.3 lakhs. Treatment?
Ans: 

This is Change in Accounting Policy. Criteria met - more appropriate presentation. Should be applied retrospectively as per transitional provisions if no specific AS says. Disclosure required: Nature of change, reason, and amount of impact Rs.3 lakhs. If retrospective application impracticable, disclose fact.


2026 Expected - Based on Sep 25 RTP
Q11: Give 4 examples of items that require separate disclosure as per AS 5 even though they are from ordinary activities?

Ans: 

Para 12 - When items of income and expense from ordinary activities are of such size, nature or incidence that disclosure is relevant to explain performance:
1. Write down of inventories to NRV and reversal
2. Restructuring costs
3. Disposal of PPE and long-term investments
4. Legislative changes having retrospective application
5. Litigation settlements
6. Reversals of provisions

6) AS 9 REVENUE RECOGNITION

 AS-9 from May 2018 to Sept 2025

1. MAY 2018 (5 Marks) - CA Inter Paper 1 Accounting
Q. Vijay Ltd. had made sale of Rs.25 lacs in Feb 2018. Goods were delivered in April 2018. Buyer requested delay due to godown renovation. Invoice was raised in Feb. When to recognize revenue?
Ans: As per AS-9 Para 12, if delivery is delayed at buyer's request and buyer takes title & accepts billing, & goods are ready and identified, revenue to be recognized in Feb 2018 itself, though physically delivered in April. So Rs.25 lacs in FY 2017-18.

2. NOV 2018 (5 Marks)
Q. S Ltd. sent goods on consignment Rs.10,00,000. Consignee sold 75%. 25% unsold at year end. How much revenue?
Ans: AS-9 says in consignment sale, risk remains with consignor. Revenue only for goods sold by consignee to third party. 75% = Rs.7,50,000 to be recognized as revenue. Rs.2,50,000 is closing inventory with consignee.

3. MAY 2019 (5 Marks)
Q. A Ltd. sold goods Rs.2,00,000 to B Ltd. on 01-02-2019 on approval basis. Approval period 3 months. Approval received for Rs.1,50,000 till 31-03-2019. Balance neither approved nor returned.
Ans: As per AS-9, for approval basis, if time fixed, revenue after expiry of time if not rejected. Since 3 months not expired on 31-03-2019 (expires 30-04-2019), revenue only Rs.1,50,000 to be recognized on 31-03-2019. Balance Rs.50,000 to be shown as inventory with customer.

4. NOV 2019 (5 Marks) - MOST IMPORTANT
Q. Indicate whether revenue can be recognized:
a) Trade discount Rs.10,000
b) Goods sold to distributor Rs.5 lakh, distributor acting as agent
c) Sale and repurchase agreement Rs.3 lakh
d) On 11-03-2019 clothes Rs.50,000 sold, delivered 12-04-2019 at buyer's request.

Ans:
a) Trade discount is deduction from revenue, not revenue. Net revenue = Gross - discount.
b) No revenue - consignment sale, recognise when distributor sells to third party.
c) No sale - financing arrangement.
d) Recognise Rs.50,000 in 2018-19 as goods ready and buyer requested delay.

5. NOV 2020 (5 Marks)
Q. Z Ltd. charged interest Rs.5 lakh for delayed payment from customer. Customer always delays but never paid interest in past. Can Z recognise interest?
Ans: No. As per AS-9 uncertainty principle. Since past experience shows non-collection, collection is not reasonably certain. Postpone recognition.

6. JAN 2021 / DEC 2021 (5 Marks) - REPEATED IN SEP'23
Q. Rainbow Ltd.
(i) Approval Rs.5,00,000 (ii) Postponed delivery Rs.2,40,000 (iii) Repurchase Rs.6,00,000 (iv) Interest & Royalty (v) Consignment Rs.4,00,000 40% unsold.

Ans (ICAI Suggested):
(i) Rs.5,00,000 (ii) Rs.2,40,000 (iii) Nil (iv) Rs.19.50 lakh (v) Rs.2,40,000 (60%) = Total revenue = Rs.9,80,000

7. MAY 2022 (5 Marks)
Q. Smart Ltd. sold goods Rs.8 lakh to Weak Ltd. Weak Ltd. financial condition is doubtful. At time of sale, collection was reasonably certain, but later financial condition worsened. Should Smart reverse revenue?
Ans: No reversal of revenue. As per AS-9, once revenue recognized, subsequent uncertainty about collection is treated as provision for doubtful debts, not reduction from revenue.

8. NOV 2022 (4 Marks)
Q. A Ltd. sold computer software Rs.10 lakh. Includes 1 year free after-sales service. How to recognise?
Ans: 

If after-sales service is insignificant, recognise full Rs.10 lakh at sale. If service is significant & sale + service cannot be separated, defer proportionate revenue and recognise over service period.

9. MAY 2023 (5 Marks) - PAPER: Toy Ltd.
(i) 60,000 sale delayed delivery (ii) 1,50,000 consignment 20% unsold (iii) 1,20,000 approval sale (iv) Cash sales 7,80,000 less 5% TD.
Ans: Revenue = 60,000 + 1,20,000 + 1,20,000 + 7,41,000 = Rs.10,41,000.

10. NOV 2023 (5 Marks) - PAPER: B.S. Ltd.
(i) 50,000 delayed delivery (ii) 1,25,000 consignment 20% unsold (iii) 1,00,000 approval sale
Ans: Revenue = 50,000 + 1,00,000 + 1,00,000 = Rs.2,50,000.

11. MAY 2024 (5 Marks)
Q. X Ltd. receives Rs.20 lakh government grant for sale already made. Is it revenue under AS-9?
Ans: No. AS-9 excludes government grants. Dealt under AS-12. Not revenue under AS-9.

12. SEP 2024 / JAN 2025 (5 Marks) - EXPECTED IN SEP 2026 ALSO
Q. Mithya Ltd sold goods Rs.8 lakh and repurchase agreement at Rs.10.80 lakh after 6 months. Original sale price to market is Rs.9.60 lakh.
Ans: Financing transaction. No revenue. Rs.9.60 lakh is loan. Finance charge = 1.20 lakh to be amortized over 6 months. For FY ending 31st March (8 months passed? Actually 2 months from Feb), charge 2/6 = 40,000.

13. MAY 2025 (5 Marks)
Q. Sale of 1000 units Rs.1000 each, buyer can return within 30 days. Past data 5% return. How much revenue on 31st March if sale on 25th March?
Ans: Recognise full sale Rs.10,00,000 but make provision for expected returns Rs.50,000 (5%). Net revenue in P&L Rs.9,50,000 with provision.

14. SEP 2025 (5 Marks)
Q. Installation fee included in product price Rs.5 lakh. Installation pending on 31st March.
Ans: If installation is simple and can be done by others, recognise full revenue. If installation is significant and pending, postpone proportionate revenue till installation complete.

7) AS 12 GOVT GRANT

AS12 Govt Grants: 

Assistance by Govt in cash/kind for compliance with conditions. Not included: Govt participation in ownership, transactions distinct from ordinary trading.

2 Broad Divisions::

Related to Revenue: 

(e.g., subsidy for expenses, wage subsidy) - Credit to P&L over period to match related costs. Can show as other income or deduction from related expense.

Related to Specific Fixed Asset:

Deduct from gross value of asset to arrive at book value. OR treat as deferred income and amortise over useful life in proportion to depreciation. If grant = almost entire cost, show asset at nominal value.


For Promoter's Contribution / Capital nature: 

Credit to Capital Reserve. If grant for total investment - treat as capital.


Refund: 

Treat as extraordinary if material. Revenue grant refund: first adjust unamortised deferred credit, balance to P&L. Asset grant refund: increase asset book value or reduce deferred income + extra depreciation. Capital grant refund: reduce Capital Reserve.


Disclosure: 

Policy, nature & extent recognised, unfulfilled conditions.


Q1. [May 2018, Nov 19, Jan 21, Dec 21, May 22, Nov 22 - Repeated 6 times - MOST IMP]
How are Government grants related to specific fixed assets treated?

Ans: 

As per AS-12, two methods:
(a) Deduct grant from gross value of asset - depreciation on net value.
(b) Treat as deferred income - grant credited to deferred income and allocated to P&L over useful life in proportion to depreciation.
If grant equals almost total cost - asset at nominal value.
If grant is in form of non-monetary asset (land at concessional rate) - account at acquisition cost or nominal.


Q2. [Nov 2018, May 19, Nov 20, July 21, Sep 24 - Repeated 5 times]
How are Government grants related to revenue treated? Disclosure?

Ans: 

Grants related to revenue (to compensate expenses/losses) recognised in P&L on systematic basis over periods to match related costs. Either show separately as "Other Income" OR deduct from related expense. Example: Wage subsidy for employing handicapped persons - credit to P&L over employment period. Unfulfilled conditions disclosure must.


Q3. [May 2019 - Practical]
Company received grant Rs.20 lakh for purchase of machinery costing Rs.100 lakh, useful life 10 years, depreciable @10% SLM. Show treatment.

Ans:
Method 1 (Deduct from asset):
Machinery Gross 100L - Grant 20L = 80L book value. Depreciation 8L p.a. to P&L

.Method 2 (Deferred Income):
Machinery 100L gross, Depreciation 10L p.a. Grant Rs.20L as deferred income, amortise Rs.2L p.a. to P&L as other income. Net charge to P&L = 8L (10-2) same.


Q4. [Nov 2019, May 23 - 5 Marks]
Grants in nature of Promoter's contribution - Treatment?

Ans:

 If Govt grant is given with reference to total investment in undertaking or by way of contribution towards total capital outlay (e.g., Central Investment Subsidy for backward area) and no repayment expected - treated as capital receipt - credit to Capital Reserve - not to P&L. Not available for dividend. Shareholders funds.But if grant is given for specific asset - apply Q1, not capital reserve.


Q5. [Nov 20, May 21 MTP, Nov 21]
Company received Govt grant Rs.50 lakh for flood loss of Rs.70 lakh. Already incurred. Treatment?

Ans: 

Grant related to revenue already incurred - recognise immediately in P&L of year in which grant receivable as extraordinary item or after checking conditions fulfilled. Rs.50L credit to P&L, loss Rs.70L debit. Net loss Rs.20L. If grant received before loss - defer and recognise in year of loss.


Q6. [Dec 21, May 22, Nov 22 Paper - Exact Q]
Rs.30 lakh grant received for R&D project, total cost Rs.50 lakh, revenue nature, Rs.20 lakh spent till 31st March. Treatment?

Ans: 

Grant related to revenue. Match with cost. Rs.20L/50L _30L = Rs.12L recognise in current year as income. Balance Rs.18L as deferred liability / income to be recognised next year when remaining cost incurred. If grant not matching - recognise only to extent of costs incurred.


Q7. [May 23, Nov 23 - Expected Sep 26 - High Yield]
Government gives land at concessional rate - Market value Rs.100 lakh, concessional price Rs.20 lakh paid. Accounting?

Ans: 

Non-monetary grant. As per AS-12, account at acquisition cost Rs.20L (actual paid) OR at nominal value (some say Rs.100L asset and Rs.80L deferred income). ICAI preferred: Show at Rs.20L acquisition cost. If nominal method - Asset Rs.100L and Deferred Income Rs.80L amortised over life? But for land (non-depreciable) - credit to Capital Reserve if promoter's contribution, else deferred income.


Q8. [Nov 23, Jan 24, May 24 - Refund Case - 5 Marks]
Grant Rs.20 lakh for machinery (Method 1 deducted). After 2 years, grant refundable Rs.20 lakh due to non-compliance. Depreciation 10% SLM.

Ans: 

On refund: Increase asset value. Original: Asset 100-20=80. Dep for 2 years @10% on 80 = 16, WDV 64. On refund, asset increased by 20L - WDV becomes 84. Provide additional depreciation for 2 years that would have been if no grant: (20_10%_2)=4L. Charge 4L to P&L immediately. Future depreciation on 84 over remaining 8 years = 10.5L p.a.

If Method 2 (Deferred Income): 

Reduce deferred income balance and charge shortfall to P&L. Deferred balance after 2 yrs = 20-4=16L. On refund 20L: 16L adjusted against deferred, 4L charged to P&L.


Q9. [May 24, Sep 24 - Capital vs Revenue Doubt]
Government grant Rs.10 lakh received as subsidy for power consumption already incurred - Revenue or Capital?

Ans: 

Revenue grant - compensates expense already incurred - recognise in P&L immediately in year it becomes receivable - show as other income or deduct from power expense. Not capital reserve.


Q10. [Sep 25, Jan 26 Mock - New Pattern]
Company received grant Rs.5 lakh for employment generation - 100 persons to be employed for 3 years, otherwise refund proportionate. 80 persons employed in Year 1. Treatment?

Ans: 

Conditions attached. Recognise only proportionate grant that conditions fulfilled. Year 1: 80/100 _5L/3? Actually grant for 3 years total employment. Systematic: Recognise Rs.5L over 3 years matching employment. Year 1: If 80 employed, but condition is 100, still recognise? As per AS-12, recognise only if reasonable assurance conditions complied. If 80 only, recognise proportionately? ICAI says recognise full if expected to comply, else defer. Best: Recognise (5L/3)=1.66L as income, but if 20 shortfall expected refund - provide liability. Disclosure of contingent liability.


Q11. [Nov 20 - Disclosure]
What disclosures required under AS-12?

Ans:

a) Accounting policy adopted for grants including method of presentation.
b) Nature and extent of grants recognised including non-monetary.
c) Unfulfilled conditions and contingencies.


Q12. [RTP May 18, Nov 18, May 20]
Govt loan at nil interest or low interest - Is it grant?

Ans: 

Forgivable loan where conditions met - treated as grant when reasonable assurance of forgiveness. Low interest loan itself NOT grant - benefit of low interest not quantified under AS-12. But if loan forgiven - grant.

8) AS 7 CONSTRUCTION CONTRACTS

 

9) AS 16 BORROWING COST

 2018 — MAY
Q1. X Ltd. took a loan of Rs. 20 Lakh @ 12% for construction of a building. Construction started on 1st April 2017 and completed on 31st March 2018. The loan was taken on 1st April 2017. Calculate borrowing cost to be capitalised.
Ans:
Interest for 12 months = 20,00,000 x 12% = Rs. 2,40,000
Building is Qualifying Asset (12 months). Construction period = Capitalisation period.
Amount Capitalised = Rs. 2,40,000 added to Building Cost.
Amount Charged to P&L = Nil.

2018 — NOV
Q2. A Ltd. has taken a loan of Rs. 10 Lakh @ 10% on 1-4-2017 for construction of factory. Expenditure incurred: 1-4-2017 Rs. 4 Lakh, 1-10-2017 Rs. 4 Lakh, 1-1-2018 Rs. 2 Lakh. Factory ready on 31-3-2018. Calculate borrowing cost.
Ans:
Interest = 10,00,000 x 10% = Rs. 1,00,000
Since loan is specific and asset is qualifying, full interest capitalised.
Capitalised = Rs. 1,00,000
Logic: Expenditure timing does not matter for Specific Borrowing. Full interest is capitalised.

2019 — MAY
Q3. Y Ltd. borrowed Rs. 50 Lakh @ 12% for construction of a plant. Plant construction started 1-4-2018, completed 30-6-2019. The company temporarily invested Rs. 10 Lakh for 3 months and earned Rs. 30,000 interest. Calculate borrowing cost capitalised for 2018-19.
Ans:
Interest = 50,00,000 x 12% = Rs. 6,00,000
Less: Income from temporary investment = Rs. 30,000
Net Capitalised = Rs. 5,70,000
Logic: AS-16 says deduct temporary income from specific borrowing.

2019 — NOV
Q4. Explain when capitalisation of borrowing cost should be suspended?
Ans:
Capitalisation is suspended when active development of qualifying asset is interrupted for an extended period. Example: Construction stopped due to labour strike, legal dispute, natural calamity for 6 months.
But if interruption is temporary / necessary — e.g., monsoon, technical procedure — do NOT suspend.
Logic: If work stopped, interest is not helping to make asset, so expense it.

2020 — NOV
Q5. Z Ltd. has general borrowings: 12% Debentures Rs. 20 Lakh, 10% Loan Rs. 30 Lakh. It incurred Rs. 15 Lakh on qualifying asset during 2019-20. Calculate borrowing cost to be capitalised.
Ans:
Weighted Avg Rate = [ (20L x 12%) + (30L x 10%) ] / 50L = (2,40,000 + 3,00,000) / 50L = 10.8%
Capitalised = 15,00,000 x 10.8% = Rs. 1,62,000
Cap check: Total Interest = Rs. 5,40,000, so 1,62,000 is allowed.

2021 — MAY
Q6. P Ltd. took foreign currency loan for construction. Exchange loss Rs. 1,00,000. Interest saving if loan taken in India would be Rs. 60,000. How much is borrowing cost?
Ans:
As per AS-16, exchange difference to the extent of interest saving is borrowing cost.
Borrowing Cost = Rs. 60,000
Balance Rs. 40,000 = Exchange loss charged to P&L.
Logic: Only the part which is equivalent to interest is borrowing cost.

2021 — NOV
Q7. Construction of building completed in parts — Ground floor ready on 31-12-2020, full building ready 31-3-2021. Borrowing cost treatment?
Ans:
AS-16 says — When parts of qualifying asset are ready, stop capitalisation for that part.
Ground floor portion: Stop capitalising from 31-12-2020. Interest after that date = P&L.
Other floors: Continue till 31-3-2021.

2022 — MAY
Q8. M Ltd. borrowed Rs. 25 Lakh @ 11% specifically for building. Construction started 1-4-2021, stopped 1-7-2021 to 31-12-2021 due to strike, resumed and completed 31-3-2022. Calculate capitalisation.
Ans:
Total Interest = 25L x 11% = Rs. 2,75,000
Suspension period = 6 months (July-Dec) — Extended interruption.
Interest for suspension = 2,75,000 x 6/12 = Rs. 1,37,500 — Expense to P&L
Capitalised = 2,75,000 - 1,37,500 = Rs. 1,37,500

2022 — NOV
Q9. Is inventory a qualifying asset?
Ans:
Yes, but only if it takes substantial period of time to produce. E.g., Liquor, Wine, Timber which takes >12 months.
Normal inventory like FMCG, ready stock — No, not qualifying.
Students write always Yes which is Wrong.

2023 — MAY
Q10. A company started construction on 1-4-2022. Loan taken 1-5-2022. Expenditure started 1-4-2022. When to start capitalisation?
Ans:
Start from 1-5-2022 — Because all 3 conditions must be met together:
1) Expenditure incurred — Yes from 1-4
2) Borrowing cost incurred — From 1-5
3) Activity in progress — Yes
So common date is 1-5-2022. Interest for April is P&L.

2023 — NOV
Q11. R Ltd. has borrowed funds: Specific loan Rs. 10 Lakh @ 12%, General loans Rs. 20 Lakh @ 10%. Qualifying asset expenditure Rs. 30 Lakh. Calculate capitalisation.
Ans:
Specific Interest = 10L x 12% = Rs. 1,20,000 — fully capitalised.
Remaining expenditure = 20L to be met from general borrowings.
General Rate = 10%
Capitalised from general = 20L x 10% = Rs. 2,00,000
Total Capitalised = Rs. 3,20,000

2024 — MAY
Q12. Can borrowing cost on working capital loan be capitalised?
Ans:
No. Working capital loan is for day-to-day operations, not for qualifying asset. Full interest is charged to P&L. AS-16 does not allow it.

2024 — NOV
Q13. Company purchased machinery on deferred credit for Rs. 22 Lakh, Cash Price Rs. 20 Lakh. How to treat difference?
Ans:
Difference Rs. 2 Lakh is borrowing cost as per AS-16.
If machine is qualifying asset, capitalise Rs. 2 Lakh. If not, charge to P&L over period.

2025 — MAY
Q14. Define Qualifying Asset & give 3 examples. Also state disclosure requirements of AS-16.
Ans:
Qualifying Asset:
Asset which necessarily takes substantial period of time to get ready.
Examples:
1) Building,
2) Plant,
3) Power generation facility.
Disclosures:
1) Accounting policy adopted for borrowing costs.
2) Amount of borrowing cost capitalised during the year.

2025 — NOV
Q15. X Ltd. incurred Rs. 12 Lakh expenditure on 1-4-2024, Rs. 8 Lakh on 1-10-2024. General borrowing rate 12%. Asset ready 31-3-2025. Calculate.
Ans:
Weighted Avg Expenditure = 12L x 12/12 + 8L x 6/12 = 12L + 4L = Rs. 16L
Capitalised = 16L x 12% = Rs. 1,92,000
Note: Use time-weight for general borrowings, not full amount.

2026 — MAY
Q. S Ltd. took loan of Rs. 40 Lakh @ 10% for qualifying asset. Loan taken 1-4-2025. Asset construction completed 31-12-2025. But company used asset from 1-1-2026. Calculate capitalisation for 2025-26.
Ans:
Interest for 9 months (April-Dec) = 40L x 10% x 9/12 = Rs. 3,00,000 Capitalised.
Interest for Jan-Mar 2026 = Rs. 1,00,000 — P&L, because asset is substantially ready on 31-12-2025.
Use from Jan does not matter. Stop rule applies.
ADDITIONAL QUESTIONS 
AS RELATED TO ASSETS & LIABILITIES. QUESTIONS & ANSWERS OF RTP/MTP/PAST EXAM PAPERS
image
 
image
 
image
 
image
 
image
 
image
 
image
 
image
 
image
 
image
 
MOCK TEST PAPERS 
 
image
 
image
 
image
 
image
 
ACCOUNTING STANDARDS 

ADDITIONAL QUESTIONS

QUESTION & ANSWERS 

RTP,MTP,PAST EXAM PAPERS QUESTIONS RELATED TO ACCOUNTING STANDARDS

1 ) INTRODUCTION TO ACCOUNTING STANDARDS

Question 1
Explain the significance of emergence of IFRS as Global Standards
Answer
Few key aspects which required the need for convergence are as under:
1) Raising funds from international markets:
Each country has its own set of rules and regulations for accounting and financial reporting. Therefore, when an enterprise decides to raise capital from the markets other than the country in which it is located, the rules and regulations of that other country will apply and this in turn will require that the enterprise is in a position to understand the differences between the rules governing financial reporting in the foreign country as compared to its own country of origin.
Therefore, translation and reinstatements are of utmost importance in a world that is rapidly globalizing in all ways.


2) Comparability of Financial Statements:
International analysts and investors would like to compare financial statements based on similar ASs, and this has led to the growing need for an internationally accepted set of ASs for cross-border filings. The harmonization of financial reporting around the world will help to raise confidence of investors, generally, in the information they are using to make their decisions and assess their risks.

3) Uniformity, Comparability Transparency etc.:
A strong need was felt by legislation to bring about uniformity, rationalization, comparability, transparency and adaptability in financial statements. Having a multiplicity of types of ASs around the world is against the public interest. If accounting for the same events and information produces different reported numbers, depending on the system of standards that are being used, then it is self-evident that accounting will be increasingly discredited in the eyes of those using the numbers. It creates confusion, encourages error and may facilitate fraud. The cure for these ills is to have a single set of global standards, of the highest quality, set in the interest of public. Global Standards facilitate cross border flow of money, global listing in different stock markets and comparability of financial statements.


4) Global Investment:
The convergence of financial reporting and ASs is a valuable process that contributes to the free flow of global investment and achieves substantial benefits for all capital market stakeholders. It improves the ability of investors to compare investments on a global basis and, thus, lower their risk of errors of judgment.

Question 2
What do you mean by Carve outs/ins in Ind AS? Explain.
Answer
The Government of India in consultation with the ICAI decided to converge and not to adopt IFRS issued by the IASB. The decision of convergence rather than adoption was taken after the detailed analysis of IFRS requirements and extensive discussion with various stakeholders.

Accordingly, while formulating Ind AS, efforts have been made to keep these Standards, as far as possible, in line with the corresponding IAS/IFRS and departures have been made where considered absolutely essential.


These changes have been made considering various factors, such as:
1) Carve outs : Difference in economic environment:
Certain changes have been made considering the economic environment of the country, which is different as compared to the economic environment presumed to be in existence by IFRS. These differences are due to differences in economic conditions prevailing in India. These differences which are in deviation to the accounting principles and practices stated in IFRS, are commonly known as 'Carve-outs'.


2)  Carve In's: Additional guidance given in Ind AS over and above what is given in IFRS, is termed as 'Carve in'.
 

3) Not resulting in carve outs: Removal of options in accounting principles and practices: 

Removal of options in accounting principles and practices in Ind AS vis-a-vis IFRS, have been made to maintain consistency and comparability of the financial statements to be prepared by following Ind AS. However, these changes will not result into carve outs.

2)  FRAMEWORK FOR PREPARATION AND PRESENTATION OF FS

Question 1
With regard to financial statements name any four:
(1) Users
(2) Qualitative characteristics
(3) Elements.

RTP November 2015; RTP November 2017; RTP May 2019; RTP November 2020
Answer:
(1) Users of financial statements:
a. Investors
b. Employees
c. Lenders, Supplies/Creditors
d. Customers
e. Government & Public

(2) Qualitative Characteristics of Financial Statements:
a. Understandability
b. Relevance
c. Comparability
d. Reliability
e. Faithful Representation

(3) Elements of Financial Statements:
a. Asset
b. Liability
c. Equity
d. Income/Gain
e. Expense/Loss

Question 2
Write short note on main elements of Financial Statements.

May 2017 Examination - 4 Marks; May 2018 Examination - 4 Marks RTP May 2018
Answer:
The framework classifies items of financial statements can be classified in five broad groups depending on their economic characteristics:
Asset

Resource controlled by the enterprise as a result of past events from which future economic benefits are expected to flow to the enterprise
Liability

Present obligation of the enterprise arising from past events, the settlement of which is expected to result in an outflow of a resource embodying economic benefits.
Equity

Residual interest in the assets of an enterprise after deducting all its liabilities.
Income/gain

Increase in economic benefits during the accounting period in the form of inflows or enhancement of assets or decreases in liabilities that result in increase in equity other than those relating to contributions from equity participants
Expense/loss

Decrease in economic benefits during the accounting period in the form of outflows or depletions of assets or incurrence of liabilities that result in decrease in equity other than those relating to distributions to equity participants.

Question 3
Explain in brief, the alternative measurement bases, for determining the value at which an element can be recognized in the Balance Sheet or Statement of Profit and Loss.


November 2016 Examination - 4 Marks
MTP April 2018; MTP March 2019; MTP March 2021 RTP November 2018


What is meant by 'Measurement'? What are the bases of measurement of Elements of Financial Statements? Explain the brief.


December 2021 Examination - 4 Marks
RTP November 2021

Answer:
The Framework for Recognition and Presentation of Financial statements recognizes four alternative measurement bases for the purpose of determining the value at which an element can be recognized in the balance sheet or statement of profit and loss.
These bases are:
1) Historical Cost:
Historical cost means acquisition price. According to this, assets are recorded at an amount of cash or cash equivalent paid or the fair value of the asset at the time of acquisition. Liabilities are generally recorded at the amount of proceeds received in exchange for the obligation.

2) Current Cost:
Current cost gives an alternative measurement basis. Assets are carried out at the amount of cash or cash equivalent that would have to be paid if the same or an equivalent asset was acquired currently. Liabilities are carried at the undiscounted amount of cash or cash equivalents that would be required to settle the obligation currently.

3) Realizable (Settlement) Value:
As per realizable value, assets are carried at the amount of cash or cash equivalents that could currently be obtained by selling the assets in an orderly disposal. Liabilities are carried at their settlement values; i.e. the undiscounted amount of cash or cash equivalents paid to satisfy the liabilities in the normal course of business.

4) Present Value:
Under present value convention, assets are carried at present value of future net cash flows generated by the concerned assets in the normal course of business. Liabilities under this convention are carried at present value of future net cash flows that are expected to be required to settle the liability in the normal course of business.

Question 4
What are the qualitative characteristics that improve the usefulness of information provided in the financial statements?


November 2011 Examination – 4 Marks, May 2013 Examination – 4 Marks, November 2020 Examination – 4 Marks

Answer:
The following qualitative characteristics will help in improving the usefulness of the information provided in the financial statements:


1. Understandability:
Information in financial statements should be presented in a manner that the users with reasonable knowledge of business and economic activities and accounting, may readily understand it. All relevant information should be given therein.

2. Relevance:
The relevance of a piece of information should be judged by its materiality i.e. whether its omission or misstatement can influence economic decisions of users or not. No relevant information should be withheld on the grounds of complexity.

3. Reliability:
The information is said to be reliable when transactions and events reported are represented faithfully and also when they are reported in terms of their substance and economic reality. Prudence concept is also used whenever required.

4. Comparability:
The financial statements should permit both inter-firm and intra firm comparison. One essential feature or requirement of comparability is disclosure of financial effect of change in accounting policies.

Question 5
"One of the characteristics of the financial statement is neutrality."
Do you agree with this statement? Explain in brief.

 

November 2018 Examination - 5 Marks
MTP August 2018

Answer:
Yes, one of the characteristics of financial statements is neutrality. To be reliable, the information contained in financial statement must be neutral, that is free from bias.

Financial Statements are not neutral if by the selection or presentation of information, the focus of analysis could shift from one area of business to another thereby arriving at a ’orally different conclusion based on the business results. Information contained in the financial statements must be free from bias. It should reflect a balanced view of the financial position of the company without attempting to present them in biased manner. Financial statements cannot be prepared with the purpose to influence certain division, i.e. they must be neutral.


PRACTICAL PROBLEMS
Question 6
ABC Ltd. has entered into a binding agreement with XYZ Ltd. to buy a custom -made machine amounting to Rs. 4,00,000. As on 31st March, 2018 before delivery of the machine, ABC Ltd. had to change its method of production. The new method will not require the machine ordered and so it shall be scrapped after delivery. The expected scrap value is 'NIL'.
Show the treatment of machine in the books of ABC Ltd.


May 2017 Examination - 4 Marks
MTP August 2018; MTP October 2018; MTP March 2022

Answer:
A liability is recognized when outflow of economic resources in settlement of a present obligation can be anticipated and the value of outflow can be reliably measured.

In the above case, ABC Ltd. should recognize a liability of Rs.4,00,000 payable to XYZ Ltd. When flow of economic benefit to the enterprise beyond the current accounting period is considered improbable, the expenditure incurred is recognized as an expense rather than as an asset.

In the present case, flow of future economic benefit from the machine to the enterprise is improbable. The entire amount of purchase price of the machine should be recognized as an expense.

Hence ABC Ltd. should charge the amount of Rs. 4,00,000 (being loss due to change in production method) to Profit and loss statement and record the corresponding liability (amount payable to XYZ Ltd.) for the same amount in the books for the year ended 31st March, 2018.

Question 7
A Ltd. entered into a binding contract with C Ltd. to buy a machine for Rs. 1,00,000. The machine is to be delivered on 15th February, 2009. On 1st January, 2009, A Ltd. changed its process of production. The new process will not require the machine ordered and it shall have to be scrapped after delivery. The expected scrap value of the machine is nil.
Explain how A Ltd. should recognize the entire transaction in the books of account for the year ended 31st March, 2009.
Nov 2009 Examination - 2 Marks
RTP May 2020; MTP October 2020 (Figures X 4 Times)

Answer:
A Ltd. entered into a binding contract with C Ltd. and therefore, it should recognize a liability of Rs.1,00,000. The entire amount of purchase price of the machine should be recognized in the year ended 31st March, 2009 as loss because future economic benefit from the machine to the enterprise is improbable.
The accounting entry should be as follows:
Profit and Loss A/c Dr. 1,00,000
To C Ltd.        1,00,000
(Being value of machinery fully depreciated because of change in the process of production i.e.obsolescence)

Question 8
Shankar started a business on 1st April, 2017 with Rs. 12,00,000 represented by 60,000 units of Rs. 20 each. During the financial year ending on 31st March, 2018, he sold the entire stock for Rs. 30 each. In order to maintain the capital intact, calculate the maximum amount, which can be withdrawn by Shankar in the year 2017-18 if Financial Capital is maintained at Historical cost.


May 2018 Examination - 4 Marks
RTP November 2013; RTP May 2015; RTP November 2018


Answer:

Financial Capital Maintenance at
Historical Cost (Rs.)

Closing equity (Rs. 30 x 60,000 units) 18,00,000 represented by cash
Opening equity 60,000 units x Rs. 20 = 12,00,000
Permissible drawings to keep Capital intact 6,00,000 (18,00,000 -12,00,000)


Therefore, Rs. 6,00,000 is the maximum amount which can be withdrawn by Shankar in the year 2017-18 if the Financial Capital Maintenance is maintained at Historical Cost.

Question 9
Explain how financial capital is maintained at historical cost?
Kishore started a business on 1st April, 2019 with Rs. 15,00,000 represented by 75,000 units of Rs.20 each. During the financial year ending on 31st March, 2020, he sold the entire stock for Rs. 30 each. In order to maintain the capital intact, calculate the maximum amount, which can be withdrawn by Kishore in the year 2019-20 if Financial Capital is maintained at historical cost.


January 2021 Examination - 5 Marks
RTP May 2021 (Similar)

Answer:
Financial capital maintenance at historical cost: Under this convention, opening and closing assets are stated at respective historical costs to ascertain opening and closing equity. If retained profit is greater than or equals to zero, the capital is said to be maintained at historical costs. This means the business will have enough funds to replace its assets at historical costs. This is quite right as long as prices do not rise.

Maximum amount withdrawn by Kishore in year 2019-20 if Financial capital is maintained at historical cost

Financial Capital Maintenance at
Historical Cost (Rs.)

Closing equity (Rs. 30 x 75,000 units) 22,50,000 represented by cash
Opening equity 75,000 units x Rs. 20 = 15,00,000
Permissible drawings to keep Capital intact 7,50,000(22,50,000 -15,00,000)


Thus Rs. 7,50,000 is the maximum amount that can be withdrawn by Kishore in year 2019-20 if Financial capital is maintained at historical cost.


Q10 & 11

https://read.bookcreator.com/RyTfw9mJUjVfw5pzbm3AS3CYUxA2/W3bCVmwBS42pKIXBYjZzqw

 

3)  APPLICABILITY OF ACCOUNTING STANDARDS

Question 1
What are Accounting Standards?
Explain the issues, with which they deal.


RTP November 2018; RTP May 2013; RTP November 2020
November 2017 Examination - 5 Marks

Answer:
What are Accounting Standards:
Accounting Standards are written policy documents issued by expert accounting body or by government or other regulatory body covering the aspects of recognition, measurement, presentation and disclosure of accounting transactions in the financial statements.

Accounting Standards reduce the accounting alternatives in the preparation of financial statements and ensure standardization of alternative accounting treatments and comparability of financial statements of different enterprises.

Accounting Standards deal with the issues of:
(i) Recognition of events and transactions in the financial statements,
(ii) Measurement of these transactions and events,
(iii) Presentation of these transactions and events in the financial statements in a manner that is meaningful and understandable to the reader; and
(iv) Disclosure requirements which should be there to enable the public at large and the stakeholders and the potential investors, in particular, to get an insight into what these financial statements are trying to reflect and thereby facilitating them to take prudent and informed business decisions.

Question 2
"Accounting Standards standardize diverse accounting policies with a view to eliminate the non-comparability of financial statements and improve the reliability of financial statements."

Discuss and explain the benefits of Accounting Standards.


November 2018 Examination (New Course) - 4 Marks , MTP November 2021 , November 2022 Examination - 4 Marks

Answer:
What are Accounting Standards:
Accounting Standards standardize diverse accounting policies with a view to eliminate the non-comparability of financial statements and improve the reliability of financial statements. Accounting Standards provide a set of standard accounting policies, valuation norms and disclosure requirements.

Accounting standards aim at improving the quality of financial reporting by promoting comparability, consistency and transparency, in the interests of users of financial statements.

The following are the benefits of Accounting Standards:
(i) Standardization of alternative accounting treatments:
Accounting Standards reduce to a reasonable extent, confusing variations in the accounting treatment followed for the purpose of preparation of financial statements.

(ii) Requirements for additional disclosures:
There are certain areas where important is not statutorily required to be disclosed. Standards may call for disclosure beyond that required by law.

(iii) Comparability of financial statements:
The application of accounting standards would facilitate comparison of financial statements of different companies situated in India and facilitate comparison, to a limited extent, of financial statements of companies situated in different parts of the world. However, it should be noted in this respect that differences in the institutions, traditions and legal systems from one country to another give rise to differences in Accounting Standards adopted in different countries.


CLASSIFICATION OF ENTERPRISES - BY ICAI (LEVEL I, II AND III ENTITIES)

Question 3
List the criteria to be applied for rating a non-corporate entity as Level-I entity for the purpose of compliance of Accounting Standards in India.

Answer:
Non-corporate entities which fall in any one or more of the following categories, at the end of the relevant accounting period, are classified as Level I entities:

(i) Entities whose equity or debt securities are listed or are in the process of listing on any stock exchange, whether in India or outside India.
(ii) Banks (including co-operative banks), financial institutions or entities carrying on insurance business.
(iii) All commercial, industrial and business reporting entities, whose turnover (excluding other income) exceeds rupees fifty crore in the immediately preceding accounting year.
(iv) All commercial, industrial and business reporting entities having borrowings (including public deposits) in excess of rupees ten crore at any time during the immediately preceding accounting year.
(v) Holding and subsidiary entities of any one of the above.

Question 4
List the criteria to be applied for rating a non-corporate entity as Level-II entity for the purpose of compliance of Accounting Standards in India. RTP May 2018
 
Answer:
Non-corporate entities which are not level I entities but fall in any one or more of the following categories are classified as level II entities:

(i) All commercial, industrial and business reporting entities, whose turnover (excluding other income) exceeds rupees one crore but does not exceed rupees fifty crore in the immediately preceding accounting year.

(ii) All commercial, industrial and business reporting entities having borrowings (including public deposits) in excess of rupees one crore but not in excess of rupees ten crore at any time during the immediately preceding accounting year.

(iii) Holding and subsidiary entities of any one of the above.


Question 5
An organization whose objects are charitable or religious, believes that the Accounting Standards are not applicable to it since only a very small proportion of its activities are business in nature. Comment. RTP May 2002

Answer:
Accounting Standards apply in respect of any enterprise (whether organized in corporate, co-operative or other forms) engaged in commercial, industrial or business activities, whether or not profit oriented and even if established for charitable or religious purposes. Accounting Standards however, do not apply to enterprises solely carrying on the activities, which are not of commercial, industrial or business nature, (e.g., an activity of collecting donations and giving them to flood affected people). Exclusion of an enterprise from the applicability of the Accounting Standards would be permissible only if no part of the activity of such enterprise is commercial, industrial or business in nature. Even if a very small proportion of the activities of an enterprise were considered to be commercial, industrial or business in nature, the Accounting Standards would apply to all its activities including those, which are not commercial, industrial or business in nature.


EXEMPTIONS FROM AS
(BASED ON ICAI DIRECTIVE)


Question 6
M/s Omega & Co. (a partnership firm), had a turnover of Rs. 1.25 crores (excluding other income) and borrowings of Rs. 0.95 crores in the previous year. It wants to avail the exemptions available in application of Accounting Standards to non-corporate entities for the year ended 31.3.2016.

Advise the management of M/s Omega & Co in respect of the exemptions of provisions of ASs, as per the directive issued by the ICAI.


RTP November 2013; RTP November 2015; RTP May 2017
MTP October 2018


Answer:
For availment of the exemptions, first of all, it has to be seen that M/s Omega & Co. falls in which level of the non-corporate entities. Its classification will be done on the basis of the classification of non-corporate entities as prescribed by the ICAI.

According to the ICAI, non-corporate entities can be classified under 3 levels viz Level I, Level II (SMEs) and Level III (SMEs).

If an entity whose turnover (excluding other income) exceeds rupees fifty crore in the immediately preceding accounting year, it does not fall under the category of Level I entities. Non-corporate entities which are not Level I entities but fall in any one or more of the following categories are classified as Level II entities:

(i) All commercial, industrial and business reporting entities, whose turnover (excluding other income) exceeds rupees one crore but does not exceed rupees fifty crore in the immediately preceding accounting year.

(ii) All commercial, industrial and business reporting entities having borrowings (including public deposits) in excess of rupees one crore but not in excess of rupees ten crore at any time during the immediately preceding accounting year.
(iii) Holding and subsidiary entities of any one of the above.

As the turnover of M/s Omega & Co. is more than Rs. 1 crore, it falls under 1st criteria of Level II non-corporate entities as defined above.

Even if its borrowings of Rs. 0.95 crores is less than Rs. 1 crores, it will be classified as Level II Entity.

Thus, AS 3, AS 17, AS 21, AS 23, AS 27 will not be applicable to M/s Omega & Co.

Relaxations from certain requirements in respect of AS 15, AS 19, AS 20, AS 25, AS 28 and AS 29 are also available to M/s Omega & Co.

Question 7
List the Criteria for classification of non-corporate entities as level I Entities for the purpose of application of Accounting Standards as per the Institute of Chartered Accountants of India.
January 2021 Examination - 5 Marks


Answer:
Criteria for classification of non-corporate entities as level 1 entities for purpose of application of Accounting Standards decided by the Institute of Chartered Accountants of India is given below:

Non-corporate entities which fall in any one or more of the following categories, at the end of the relevant accounting period, are classified as Level I entities:

(i) Entities whose equity or debt securities are listed or are in the process of listing on any stock exchange, whether in India or outside India.
(ii) Banks (including co-operative banks), financial institutions or entities carrying on insurance business.
(iii) All commercial, industrial and business reporting entities, whose turnover (excluding other income) exceeds rupees fifty crore in the immediately preceding accounting year.
(iv) All commercial, industrial and business reporting entities having borrowings (including public deposits) in excess of rupees ten crore at any time during the immediately preceding accounting year.
(v) Holding and subsidiary entities of any one of the above.

EXEMPTIONS FROM AS
[BASED ON COMPANIES (ACCOUNTING STANDARDS) RULES, 2006]


Question 8
A company was classified as Non-SMC in 2015-2016. In 2016-2017 it has been classified as SMC. The management desires to avail the exemption or relaxations available for SMCs in 2016-2017. However, the accountant of the company does not agree with the same. Comment. RTP May 2015

Answer:
As per Rule 5 of the Companies (Accounting Standards) Rules, 2006, an existing company, which was previously not an SMC and subsequently becomes an SMC, should not be qualified for exemption or relaxation in respect of accounting standards available to an SMC until the company remains an SMC for two consecutive accounting periods.

Therefore, the management of the company cannot avail the exemptions available with the SMCs for the year ended 31st March, 2017.

Question 9
Comment whether the following Companies can be classified as a Small and Medium Sized Company (SMC) as per the Companies (Accounting Standards), Rules, 2006:

(i) A Pvt. Ltd., a subsidiary of a multinational company listed on London Stock Exchange. It has a turnover of Rs. 12 crores and borrowings of Rs. 5 crores.
(ii) B Pvt. Ltd., has a turnover of Rs. 45 crores, other income of Rs. 7 crores and bank borrowings of Rs. 9 crores.

RTP May 2014


Answer:
As per the companies (Accounting Standards) Rules, 2006, "Small and Medium Sized Company" (SMC) means, a company:

(i) Whose equity or debt securities are not listed or are not in the process of listing on any stock exchange, whether in India or outside India'
(ii) Which is not a bank, financial institution or an insurance company;
(iii) Whose turnover (excluding other income) does not exceed rupee; fifty crores in the immediately preceding accounting year,
(iv) Which does not have borrowings (including public deposits) in excess of rupees ten crore at any time during the immediately preceding accounting year; and
(v) which is not a holding or subsidiary company of a company which is not a small and medium-sized company.

Explanation:
A company shall qualify as a Small and Medium Sized Company, if the condition mentioned, therein are satisfied as at the end of the relevant accounting period.

(i) As per the definition of SMC, point (v), a company will be a SMC, if it is not holding or subsidiary company of another company which is not a SMC. Since A Pvt. Ltd., is a subsidiary of another Company which is listed, on London Stock Exchange (and is therefore not a SMC), A Pvt. Ltd., cannot be a SMC.
Note: The turnover and borrowings are not relevant in this case.

(ii) As per the definition of SMC, point (iii), a company will be a SMC if its turnover does not exceed Rs. 50 crores or borrowings do not exceed Rs. 10 crores. For calculating this turnover, other income is not to be included. Since B Pvt. Ltd., has a turnover of Rs. 45 crores and borrowing of Rs. 9 crores, it will satisfy the definition and can be classified as SMC.

Question 10
XYZ Ltd., (a corporate entity) with a turnover of Rs. 35 lakhs and borrowings of Rs. 10 lakhs during any time in the previous year, wants to avail the exemptions available in adoption of Accounting Standards applicable to companies for the year ended 31.3.2017.

Advise the management on the exemptions that are available as per the Companies (AS) Rules, 2006.
If XYZ is a partnership firm is there any other exemptions additionally available.
RTP May 2019


Answer:
The companies can be classified under two categories viz SMCs and Non-SMCs under the Companies (AS) Rules, 2006.

As per the Companies (AS) Rules, 2006, criteria for above classification as SMCs, are:

"Small and Medium Sized Company" (SMC) means, a company-

(i) whose equity or debt securities are not listed or are not in the process of listing on any stock exchange, whether in India or outside India;
(ii) which is not a bank, financial institution or an insurance company;
(iii) whose turnover (excluding other income) does not exceed rupees fifty crore in the immediately preceding accounting year;
(iv) which does not have borrowings (including public deposits) in excess of rupees ten crore at any time during the immediately preceding accounting year; and
(v) which is not a holding or subsidiary company of a company which is not a small and medium-sized company.

Since, XYZ Ltd.'s turnover of Rs. 35 lakhs does not exceed Rs. 50 crores & borrowings of Rs. 10 lakhs is less than Rs. 10 crores, it is a small and medium sized company

The following relaxations and exemptions are available to XYZ Ltd.:
1. AS 3 ("Cash Flow Statements") is not mandatory.
2. AS 17 ("Segment Reporting") is not mandatory.
3. SMEs are exempt from some paragraphs of AS 19 ("Leases").
4. SMEs are exempt from disclosures of diluted EPS (both including and excluding extraordinary items).
5. SMEs are allowed to measure the 'value in use' on the basis of reasonable estimate thereof instead of computing the value in use by present value technique under AS 28 ("Impairment of Assets").
6. SMEs are exempt from certain disclosure requirements of AS 29 ("Provisions, Contingent Liabilities and Contingent Assets").
7. SMEs are exempt from certain requirements of AS 15 ("Employee Benefits").
8. Accounting Standards 21, 23, 27 are not applicable to SMEs.

Question 11
A company with a turnover of Rs. 225 crores and borrowings of Rs. 51 crore during the year ended 31st March, 2021, wants to avail the exemptions available in adoption of Accounting Standards applicable to companies for the year ended 31.3. 2021.

Advise the management on the exemptions that are available as per the Companies (Accounting Standards) Rules, 2021.
RTP May 2022

Answer:
The question deals with the issue of Applicability of Accounting Standards for corporate entities. The companies can be classified under two categories viz SMCs and Non-SMCs under the Companies (Accounting Standards) Rules, 2021. A

As per the Companies (Accounting Standards) Rules, 2021, criteria for above classification as SMCs, are:

"Small and Medium Sized Company" (SMC) means, a company-
• whose equity or debt securities are not listed or are not in the process of listing on any stock exchange, whether in India or outside India;
• which is not a bank, financial institution or an insurance company;
• whose turnover (excluding other income) does not exceed rupees two-fifty crores in the immediately preceding accounting year;
• which does not have borrowings (including public deposits) in excess of rupees fifty crores at any time during the immediately preceding accounting year; and
• which is not a holding or subsidiary company of a company which is not a small and medium-sized company.

Since, XYZ Ltd.'s turnover was Rs. 225 crores which does not exceed Rs. 250 crores but borrowings of Rs. 51 crore are more than Rs. 50 crores, it is not a small and medium sized company (SMC). The exemptions available to SMC are not available to this company.

4)   AS1 DISCLOSURE OF ACCOUNTING POLICIES

FUNDAMENTAL ACCOUNTING ASSUMPTIONS


Question 1
What are fundamental accounting assumptions?
RTF November 2015; RTP November 2017; RTP May 2019
Answer:
1. Accrual.
2. Going Concern; and
3. Consistency

Question 2
What are the three fundamental accounting assumptions recognised by Accounting Standard (AS) 1? Briefly describe each one of them.
RTP May 2013; RTP November 2020
Question
Briefly define the Fundamental Accounting Assumptions?
November 2017 Examination - 5 Marks

Answer:
Accounting Standard (AS) 1 recognizes three fundamental accounting assumptions. These are as follows:

(i) Going Concern:
The financial statements are normally prepared on the assumption that an enterprise will continue its operations in the foreseeable future and neither there is intention, nor there is need to materially curtail the scale of operations.

(ii) Consistency:
The principle of consistency refers to the practice of using same accounting policies for similar transactions in all accounting periods unless the change is required (i) by a statute, (ii) by an accounting standard or (Hi) for more appropriate presentation of financial statements.


(iii) Accrual basis of accounting:
Under this basis of accounting, transactions are recognised as soon as they occur, whether or not cash or cash equivalent is actually received or paid.


AREAS IN WHICH DIFFERENT ACCOUNTING POLICIES ARE ENCOUNTERED

Question 3
Mention few areas in which different accounting policies are followed by companies.

Question
"Recognizing the need to harmonize the diverse accounting policies and practices, accounting standards are framed." Give examples of areas in which different accounting policies may be adopted by the enterprise.
November 2010 Examination - 5 Marks


Answer:
Following are the examples of the areas in which different accounting policies may be adopted by different enterprises:
(i) Valuation of inventories.
(ii) Methods of valuing goodwill.
(iii) Valuation of investments.
(iv) Recognition of profit on long-term contracts.
(v) Valuation of fixed assets.
 

CONSIDERATIONS IN SELECTION OF ACCOUNTING POLICIES

Question 4
A limited has sold its building for Rs. 50 lakhs and the purchaser has paid the full price. The Company has given possession to the purchaser. The book value of the building is Rs. 35 lakhs. As at 31st March 2013, documentation and legal formalities are pending. The company has not recorded the sale. It has shown the amount received as advance.

Do you agree with this treatment?
What accounting treatment should the buyer give in its financial statements?


RTP November 2013; RTP November 2014; RTP November 2017


Answer:
What AS-1 states:
AS-1, states that the accounting treatment and presentation in Financial Statements of transactions should be governed by their substance and not merely by the legal form.

Analysis and conclusion:
Although legal title has not been transferred, the economic reality and substance is that the rights and beneficial interest in the immovable property have been transferred.

Therefore, recording of acquisition/disposal (by the transferee and transferor respectively) would, in substance, represent the purchase/sale.

Accounting for Seller:
A Ltd., should record the sales and recognize the profit of Rs.15 lakhs in its profit and loss account. It should eliminate building from its balance sheet.

In notes to accounts, it should disclose that building has been sold, full consideration has been received, possession has been handed over to the buyer and documentation and legal formalities are pending.

Accounting for Buyer:
The buyer should recognize the building as an asset in his balance sheet and charge depreciation on it.
The buyer should disclose in his notes to account that possession has been received however documentation and legal formalities are pending.

Question 5
Om Ltd. purchases goods on behalf of its customers for execution of work under a works contract against which it receives full payment and necessary declaration form under GST to be passed on to the supplier. The company follows the practice of treating the same as its purchases and accordingly debits to its Profit and Loss Account.
Give your views on the above.

May 2019 Examination - 5 Marks

Answer:
What AS-1 states:
AS-1, states that the accounting treatment and presentation in Financial Statements of transactions should be governed by their substance and not merely by the legal form.

Analysis and conclusion:
The treatment in the given case would depend on the terms of the Works Contract and also the substance of the agreement.

Therefore, there can be two possibilities:
Possibility 1 - Company acts as the agent of the customer:
Disclosure should be made to this effect that the material purchased belongs to the customer.

Where ownership of goods vests with the customers and the company merely purchases goods on behalf of its customers, it acts in the capacity of an agent for execution of works under a works contract for which it receives full payment.

Hence, these purchases cannot be treated as the purchases of the Company and so, the debit to its P&L A/c is not correct

Possibility 2 - Company is the owner of the materials purchased in substance and has the right (though a restricted one) to use the materials, for all practical purposes:
If the terms of Works Contract provide for factor linked payment by customer and in substance the materials acquired by the Company belongs to the company only, irrespective of the legal form of ownership, the Company is justified in debiting its P&L A/c.

Question 6
XYZ Company is engaged in the business of financial services and is undergoing tight liquidity position, since most of the assets of the company are blocked in various claims/ petitions in a Special Court. XYZ has accepted Inter-Corporate Deposits (ICDs) and, it is making its best efforts to settle the dues. There were claims at varied rates of interest, from lenders, from the due date of ICDs to the date of repayment. The company has provided interest, as per the terms of the contract till the due date and a note for non-provision of interest on the due date to date of repayment was affected in the financial statements. On account of uncertainties existing regarding the determination of the amount and in the absence of any specific legal obligation at present as per the terms of contracts, the company considers that these claims are in the nature of "claims against the company not acknowledged as debt", and the same has been disclosed by way of a note in the accounts instead of making a provision in the profit and loss accounts.
State whether the treatment done by the Company is correct or not.

RTP May 2013; May 2017 Examination - 5 Marks 


Answer:
What AS-1 states:
AS 1 recognises 'prudence' as one of the major considerations governing the selection and application of accounting policies.

In view of the uncertainty attached to future events, profits are not anticipated but recognised only when realised though not necessarily in cash.

Provision is made for all known liabilities and losses even though the amount cannot be determined with certainty and represents only a best estimate in the light of available information.

Also, as per AS 1, 'accrual' is one of the fundamental accounting assumptions.

Analysis and conclusion:
Irrespective of the terms of the contract, so long as the principal amount of a loan is not repaid, the lender cannot be replaced in a disadvantageous position for non-payment of interest in respect of overdue amount. It is apparent that the company has an obligation on account of the overdue interest.

In this situation, the company should provide for the liability (since it is not waived by the lenders) at an amount estimated or on reasonable basis based on facts and circumstances of each case. However, in respect of the overdue interest amounts, which are settled, the liability should be accrued to the extent of amounts settled. Non-provision of the overdue interest liability amounts to violation of accrual basis of accounting.

Therefore, the treatment, done by the company, of not providing the interest amount from due date to the date of repayment is not correct.

DISCLOSURE OF ACCOUNTING POLICIES


Question 7
In the books of M/s Prashant Ltd., closing inventory as on 31.03.2015 amounts to Rs.1,63,000 (on the basis of FIFO method).

The company decides to change from FIFO method to weighted average method for ascertaining the cost of inventory from the year 2014-15. On the basis of weighted average method, closing inventory as on 31.03.2015 amounts to Rs. 1,47,000. Realisable value of the inventory as on 31.03.2015 amounts to Rs. 1,95,000.
Discuss disclosure requirement of change in accounting policy as per AS-1.


MTP October 2018; MTP November 2021(Similar) 


Answer:
What AS-1 states:
As per AS 1 "Disclosure of Accounting Policies", any change in an accounting policy which has a material effect should be disclosed in the financial statements. The amount by which any item in the financial statements is affected by such change should also be disclosed to the extent ascertainable. Where such amount is not ascertainable, wholly or in part, the fact should be indicated.

Analysis and conclusion:
Prashant Ltd. should disclose the change in valuation method of inventory and its effect on financial statements.

The company may disclose the change in accounting policy in the following manner:
'The company values its inventory at lower of cost and net realisable value. Since net realisable value of all items of inventory in the current year was greater than respective costs, the company valued its inventory at cost. In the present year Le. 2014-15, the company has changed to weighted average method, which better reflects the consumption pattern of inventory, for ascertaining inventory costs from the earlier practice of using FIFO for the purpose. The change in policy has reduced current profit and value of inventory by Rs. 16,000.


Question 8
ABC Ltd. was making provision for non-moving inventories based on issues for the last 12 months up to 31.3.2016.

The company wants to provide during the year ending 31.3.2017 based on technical evaluation:

Total value of Inventory Rs. 100 lakhs
Provision required based on 12 months issue Rs.3.5 lakhs
Provision required based on technical evaluation Rs.2.5 lakhs

Does this amount to change in Accounting Policy?
Can the company change the method of provision?


RTP May 2017; RTP May 2020
Answer:
Analysis and conclusion:
Accounting policy of a company may require that provision for non-moving inventories should be made. The method of estimating the amount of provision may be changed in case a more prudent estimate can be made.

The decision of making provision for non-moving inventories on the basis of technical evaluation does not amount to change in accounting policy.

In the above case, considering the total value of inventory, the change in the amount of required provision of non-moving inventory from Rs. 3.5 lakhs to Rs. 2.5 lakhs is also not material.

The disclosure can be made for such change in the following lines by way of notes to the accounts in the annual accounts of ABC Ltd. for the year 2016-17:
"The company has provided for non-moving inventories on the basis of technical evaluation unlike preceding years. Had the same method been followed as in the previous year, the profit for the year and the corresponding effect on the year-end net assets would have been lower by Rs. 1 lakh."

Question 9
(i) ABC Ltd. was previously making provision for non-moving stocks based on stocks not issued for the last 12 months up to 31.03.2020. Now, the company wants to make provisions based on technical evaluation during the year ending 31.03.2021.
Total value of stock Rs. 133.75 lakhs
Provision required based on technical evaluation Rs. 4.00 lakhs.
Provision required based on 12 months not issued Rs. 5.00 lakhs.


(ii) In the Books of Kay Ltd., Closing stock as on 31st March, 2021 amounts to Rs.1,24,000 (on the basis of FIFO method)
The company decides to change from FIFO method to weighted average method for ascertaining the cost of inventory from the year 2020-2021. On the basis of weighted average method, closing stock as on 31st March, 2021 amounts to Rs. 1,15,000. Realisable value of the inventory as on 31st March, 2021 amounts to Rs. 1,54,000.

Discuss Disclosure Requirements of change in accounting policy in above cases as per AS 1.

December 2021 Examination - 5 Marks
MTP March 2021 (Similar); MTP April 2022 (Part i)
Answer:
(i) Analysis:
The decision of making provision for non-moving inventories on the basis of technical evaluation does not amount to change in accounting policy. Accounting policy of a company may require that provision for non-moving inventories should be made. The method of estimating the amount of provision may be changed in case a more prudent estimate can be made.

In the given case, considering the total value of inventory, the change in the amount of required provision of non-moving inventory from Rs. 5 lakhs to Rs. 4 lakhs is also not material.

The disclosure can be made for such change in the following lines by way of notes to the accounts in the annual accounts of ABC Ltd. for the year 2020 -21:

"The company has provided for non-moving inventories on the basis of technical evaluation unlike preceding years. Had the same method been followed as in the previous year, the profit for the year and the corresponding effect on the year-end net assets would have been lower by Rs. 1 lakh."

(ii) What AS-1 states:
As per AS 1, any change in an accounting policy which has a material effect should be disclosed in the financial statements. The amount by which any item in the financial statements is affected by such change should also be disclosed to the extent ascertainable. Where such amount is not ascertainable, wholly or in part, the fact should be indicated. Thus company should disclose the change in valuation method of inventory and its effect on financial statements.

The company may disclose the change in accounting policy in the following manner:

“The company values its inventory at lower of cost and net realizable value. Since net realizable value of all items of inventory in the current year was greater than respective costs, the company valued its inventory at cost. In the present year i.e. 2020-21, the company has changed to weighted average method, which better reflects the consumption pattern of inventory, for ascertaining inventory costs from the earlier practice of using FIFO for the purpose. The change in policy has reduced current profit and value of inventory by Rs. 9,000."

Question 10
Jagannath Ltd. had made a rights issue of shares in 2017. In the offer document to its members, it had projected a surplus of Rs. 40 crores during the accounting year to end on 31st March, 2017. The draft results for the year, prepared on the hitherto followed accounting policies and presented for perusal of the board of directors showed a deficit of Rs. 10 crores.

The board in consultation with the managing director, decided on the following:
(i) Value year-end inventory at works cost 50 crores) instead of the hitherto method of valuation of inventory at prime cost 30 crores).
(ii) Provide depreciation for the year on straight line basis on account of substantial additions in gross block during the year, instead of on the reducing balance method, which was hitherto adopted. As a consequence, the charge for depreciation at Rs. 27 crores is lower than the amount of Rs. 45 crores which would have been provided had the old method been followed, by Rs. 18 cores.
(iii) Not to provide for "after sales expenses" during the warranty period. Till the last year, provision at 2% of sales used to be made under the concept of "matching of costs against revenue" and actual expenses used to be charged against the provision. The board now decided to account for expenses as and when actually incurred. Sales during the year total to Rs. 600 crores.
(iv) Provide for permanent fall in the value of investments - which fall had taken place over the past five years - the provision being Rs. 10 crores.

As chief accountant of the company, you are asked by the managing director to draft the notes on accounts for inclusion in the annual report for 2016-2017.

RTP November 2015
Answer:
What AS-1 states:
As per AS 1, any change in the accounting policies which has a material effect in the current period or which is reasonably expected to have a material effect in later periods should be disclosed. In the case of a change in accounting policies which has a material effect in the current period, the amount by which any item in the financial statements is affected by such change should also be disclosed to the extent ascertainable. Where such amount is not ascertainable, wholly or in part, the fact should be indicated.

Accordingly, the notes on accounts should properly disclose the change and its effect.
Disclosure in Notes to Accounts:
(i) During the year inventory has been valued at factory cost, against the practice of valuing it at prime cost as was the practice till last year. This has been done to take cognizance of the more capital- intensive method of production on account of heavy capital expenditure during the year. As a result of this change, the year-end inventory has been valued at Rs. 50 crores and the profit for the year is increased by Rs. 20 crores.

(ii) In view of the heavy capital-intensive method of production introduced during the year, the company has decided to change the method of providing depreciation from reducing balance method to straight line method. As a result of this change, depreciation has been provided at Rs. 27 crores which is lower than the charge which would have been made had the old method and the old rates been applied, by Rs. 18 crores. To that extent, the profit for the year is increased.

(iii) So far, the company has been providing 2% of sales for meeting "after sales expenses during the warranty period. With the improved method of production, the probability of defects occurring in the products has reduced considerably.
Hence, the company has decided not to make provision for such expenses but to account for the same as and when expenses are incurred. Due to this change, the profit for the year is increased by Rs. 12 crores than would have been the case if the old policy were to continue.

(iv) The company has decided to provide Rs. 10 crores for the permanent fall in the value of investments which has taken place over the period of past five years. The provision so made has reduced the profit disclosed in the accounts by Rs. 10 crores.

Question 11
You are required to comment on the following cases as per the provisions of Accounting Standard-1 'Disclosure of Accounting Policies':

(1) Bee Limited has not complied with AS-2 "Valuation of inventories" and the same is disclosed in the Notes on Accounts. Management is of the view that the financial statements give a true and fair view as non-compliance with AS-2 is disclosed.

(2) Cee Limited sold its Office Building for Rs. 10,00,000 on 1st March, 2023. The buyer has paid the full amount and taken possession of the building. The book value of the Office Building is Rs. 4,00,000. On 31st 2023, documentation and legal formalities are pending. The company has not recorded the disposal and the amount received is shown as an advance.

(3) Dee Limited has prepared its accounts on cash basis and the same is not disclosed.

(4) Jee Limited disclosed significant accounting policies adopted in the preparation of financial statements, in the Directors' Report.


May 2023 Examination - 5 Marks

Answer
(1) As per AS-1 disclosure of accounting policies is not a remedy for wrong or inappropriate treatment in accounting. In the given case the financial statement does not give a true and fair view as they are not in compliance with AS-2.

(2) Considering the substance over form as per AS-1, documentation and legal formalities represent the form of the transaction, although the legal title has not been transferred, the economic reality and substance are that the rights and beneficial interest in the Office Building have been transferred. Therefore, recording of acquisition/ disposal (by the transferee and transferor respectively) would in substance represent the transaction entered into.

(3) Accrual is a fundamental accounting assumption. If it is not followed by the company, the facts should be disclosed under AS-1. Hence the company should disclose the fact that the cash basis of accounting has been followed in the notes on accounts.

(4) The practice followed by the company is not correct. It should be disclosed as part of financial statements (The director's report is not part of financial statements).


Question 12
Omega Ltd. projected a surplus of Rs. 40 crores during the accounting year to end on 31st March, 2013. The draft results for the year, prepared on the hitherto followed accounting policies and presented for perusal of the board of directors showed a deficit of Rs. 10 crores.

The board in consultation with the managing director, decided on the following:
(i) Provide depreciation for the year on straight line basis on account of substantial additions in gross block during the year, instead of on the reducing balance method, which was hitherto adopted. As a consequence, the charge for depreciation at Rs. 27 crores is lower than the amount of Rs. 45 crores which would have been provided had the old method been followed, by Rs. 18 cores.)

(ii) Provide for permanent fall in the value of investments - which fall had taken place over the past five years - the provision being Rs. 10 crores. As chief accountant of the company, you are asked by the managing director to draft the notes on accounts for inclusion in the annual report for 2012-2013.
RTP May 2014; RTP May 2018
Answer:
What AS-1 states:
As per AS 1 “Any change in the accounting policies which has a material effect in the current period or which is reasonably expected to have a material effect in later periods should be disclosed. In the case of a change in accounting policies which has a material effect in the current period, the amount by which any item in the financial statements is affected by such change should also be disclosed to the extent ascertainable. Where such amount is not ascertainable, wholly or in part, the fact should be indicated.

Accordingly, the notes on accounts should properly disclose the change and its effect.
Disclosure in Notes to Accounts:
(i) In view of the heavy capital-intensive method of production introduced during the year, the company has decided to change the method of providing depreciation from reducing balance method to straight line method. As a result of this change, depreciation has been provided at Rs. 27 crores which is lower than the charge which would have been made had the old method and the old rates been applied, by Rs. 18 crores. To that extent, the profit for the year is increased.

(ii) The company has decided to provide Rs. 10 crores for the permanent fall in the value of investments which has taken place over the period of past five years. The provision so made has reduced the profit disclosed in the accounts by Rs. 10 crores.

Question 13
State whether the following statements are 'True' or 'False'. Also give reason for your answer.
(i) Certain fundamental accounting assumptions underline the preparation and presentation of financial statements. They are usually specifically stated because their acceptance and use are not assumed.

(ii) If fundamental accounting assumptions are not followed in presentation and preparation of financial statements, a specific disclosure is not required.

(iii) All significant accounting policies adopted in the preparation and presentation of financial statements should form part of the financial statements.

(iv) Any change in an accounting policy, which has a material effect should be disclosed. Where the amount by which any item in the financial statements is affected by such change is not ascertainable, wholly or in part, the fact need not to be indicated.

(v) There is no single list of accounting policies which are applicable to all circumstances.
May 2018 Examination - 5 Marks
RTP May 2020;
MTP May 2020; MTP April 2021; MTP March 2022


Answer:

(i) False - As per AS 1 "Disclosure of Accounting Policies", certain fundamental accounting assumptions underlie the preparation and presentation of financial statements. They are usually not specifically stated because their acceptance and use are assumed. Disclosure is necessary if they are not followed.


(ii) False - As per AS 1, if the fundamental accounting assumptions, viz. Going Concern, Consistency and Accrual are followed in financial statements, specific disclosure is not required. If a fundamental accounting assumption is not followed, the fact should be disclosed.


(iii) True - To ensure proper understanding of financial statements, it is necessary that all significant accounting policies adopted in the preparation and presentation of financial statements should be disclosed. The disclosure of the significant accounting policies as such should form part of the financial statements and they should be disclosed in one place.


(iv) True - Any change in the accounting policies which has a material effect in the current period or which is reasonably expected to have a material effect in later periods should be disclosed. Where such amount is not ascertainable, wholly or in part, the fact should be indicated.


(v) True - As per AS 1, there is no single list of accounting policies which are applicable to all circumstances. The differing circumstances in which enterprises operate in a situation of diverse and complex economic activity make alternative accounting principles and methods of applying those principles acceptable.

Question 14
Kumar Ltd. had made a rights issue of shares in 2017. In the offer document to its members, it had projected a surplus of Rs. 40 crores during the accounting year to end on 31st March, 2017. The draft results for the year, prepared on the hitherto followed accounting policies and presented for perusal of the board of directors showed a deficit of Rs. 10 crores. The board in consultation with the managing director, decided not to provide for "after sales expenses" during the warranty period. Till the last year, provision at 2% of sales used to be made under the concept of "matching of costs against revenue" and actual expenses used to be charged against the provision. The board now decided to account for expenses as and when actually incurred. Sales during the year total to Rs. 600 crores.

As chief accountant of the company, you are asked by the managing director to prepare the notes on accounts for inclusion in the annual report for 2016-2017.


MTP April 2018; MTP August 2018; MTP March 2019


Answer:
What AS-1 states:
As per AS 1, any change in the accounting policies ivhich has a material effect in the current period or which is reasonably expected to have a material effect in later periods should be disclosed. In the case of a change in accounting policies which has a material effect in the current period, the amount by which any item in the financial statements is affected by such change should also be disclosed to the extent ascertainable. Where such amount is not ascertainable, wholly or in part, the fact should be indicated.

Accordingly, the notes on accounts should properly disclose the change and its effect.
Disclosure in Notes to Accounts:
So far, the company has been providing 2% of sales for meeting "after sales expenses during the warranty period. With the improved method of production, the probability of defects occurring in the products has reduced considerably. Hence, the company has decided not to make provision for such expenses but to account for the same as and when expenses are incurred. Due to this change, the profit for the year is increased by Rs. 12 crores than would have been the case if the old policy were to continue.

PRACTICAL QUESTIONS Q14 & 15 


https://read.bookcreator.com/RyTfw9mJUjVfw5pzbm3AS3CYUxA2/HTohzN1mSwSPAn4q_H7UuQ

 ADDITIONAL QUESTIONS
 ACCOUNTING STANDARDS RELATED TO PRESENTATION & DISCLSOURES
image
1) AS17 SEGMENT REPORT
image
2) AS18 RELATED PARTY DISCLOSURE
image
3) AS20 EARNINGS PER SHARE
image
4) AS24 DISCONTUING OPERATIONS
image
5) AS25 INTERIM FINANCIAL REPORTING
image
6) AS3 CASH FLOW STATEMENT
ADDITIONAL QUESTIONS 
 ACCOUNTING STANDARDS RELATED TO ITEMS IN FINANCIAL STATEMENTS(WILL BE UPLOADED SOON)
image
AS 4 EVENTS AFTER B/S DATE
image
AS 5 NP,PRIOR PERIOD, ESTIMATES & POLICIES
image
AS 11 FOREIGN CURRENCY TRANSACTIONS
 ADDITIONAL QUESTIONS
 ACCOUNTING STANDARDS RELATED TO REVENUE RECOGNITION & OTHER STANDARDS (WILL BE UPLOADED SOON)
image
 1) AS7 CONSTRUCTION CONTRACTS
image
 2) AS9 REVENUE RECOGNITION
image
 3) AS12 GOVT GRANTS
image
 4) AS14 AMALGAMATION 
Best study material for you
Get ready for your exam with best content and latest updated books for further practice.
image
GST NOTES FOR MAY 2025 EXAM
image
GST QUESTION & ANSWERS
image
ADV A/C'S ADDITIONAL QUESTIONS
image
HANDWRITTEN NOTES
image
 RESEARCH PAPER 
image
OTHER LAWS
image
CA INTER CONSOLIDTION 

ILL NO.5

 ICAI MODULE QUESTIONON YIELD VALUE PER SHARE

CLICK TO SEE SOLN

ASK YOUR DOUBTS HERE

image
CA INTER ADVANCE ACCOUNTS EXAM PAPER SOLUTION 

MAY 2024 

image

 LECTURE 5

 
image

 LECTURE 1

 
image

 LECTURE 2

 
ADVANCE ACCOUNTS CFS EXAM PAPERS FROM 2018 TILL DATE

CONSOLIDATION 

image

LECTURE 3

PURCHASE FAST TRACK BATCH FOR PLENTY OF REVISION VIDEOS
image

LECTURE 1

 
image

LECTURE 2 

FOR ALL PAPERS PURCHASE FAST TRACK BATCH 
CA INTER RECORDED COURSES
Get ready for your exam with best content 
image
ADVANCE ACCOUNTS
image
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
image
DIRECT & INDIRECT TAX
BEGIN YOUR CA JOURNEY

POPULAR COURSES (RECORDED)

image
BOOKS
Shipment address courses
₹ 3,150
₹ 3,490 9.00% OFF
Buy Now
image
New course ID for NIshant
₹ 8
Buy Now
image
NEW MID 2: Purchase after Latest deployment
₹ 2
Buy Now
image
MVA videoSDk Rohit
₹ 2
Buy Now